Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Inference to the Best Explanation and the Receipt of Testimony
View through CrossRef
The chapter develops a local reductionist account of what is required for testimonial beliefs to be justified, and argues that human recipients of testimony typically form their beliefs in accordance with these requirements. Recipients estimate the trustworthiness of a speaker’s assertion by constructing a mini-psychological theory of her, arriving at this by inference to the best explanation, and accept what they are told only if this theory has it that the speaker is expressing her knowledge. The existence of a social norm governing assertion, the knowledge norm, is a key factor making such an explanation accessible to recipients. This local reductionism supports explanationism as a general account of the justification of empirical beliefs.
Title: Inference to the Best Explanation and the Receipt of Testimony
Description:
The chapter develops a local reductionist account of what is required for testimonial beliefs to be justified, and argues that human recipients of testimony typically form their beliefs in accordance with these requirements.
Recipients estimate the trustworthiness of a speaker’s assertion by constructing a mini-psychological theory of her, arriving at this by inference to the best explanation, and accept what they are told only if this theory has it that the speaker is expressing her knowledge.
The existence of a social norm governing assertion, the knowledge norm, is a key factor making such an explanation accessible to recipients.
This local reductionism supports explanationism as a general account of the justification of empirical beliefs.
Related Results
Scientific Explanation
Scientific Explanation
This chapter argues that the notion of explanation relevant to the philosophy of science is that of an answer to a why-question. From this point of view it surveys most of the hist...
Testimony/Bearing Witness
Testimony/Bearing Witness
What is the epistemological value of testimony? What role does language, images, and memory play in its construction? What is the relationship between the person who attests and th...
Explanatory Understanding
Explanatory Understanding
This chapter reviews the philosophical debate on scientific explanation from the perspective of the understanding question. Since the 1950s, explanation has been a central topic of...
John Wesley
John Wesley
This chapter explores the epistemological vision of the eighteenth-century Anglican evangelist John Wesley, particularly as it relates to knowledge of God. The primary thesis of th...
The Extension Defended
The Extension Defended
This chapter defends the argument in favour of optimism set out in Chapter 5 (OA2) by focusing on whether it operates with too low a standard for explanation. Three proposals for h...
Introduction
Introduction
Chapter 1 contrasts dynamical explanation in the mechanical universe (Wilczek’s “ant’s-eye view of physical reality”) with adynamical explanation in the block universe (Wilczek’s “...
Neuroscience, Psychology, Reduction, and Functional Analysis
Neuroscience, Psychology, Reduction, and Functional Analysis
The pressure for reduction in science is an artifact of what we call the nomic conception of science (NCS): the idea that the content of science is a collection of laws, together w...
Parametric Statistical Inference
Parametric Statistical Inference
Abstract
Inference involves drawing conclusions about some general phenomenon from limited empirical observations in the face of random variability. In a scientific ...