Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Evaluation of Douyin Short Videos on Mammography in China: Quality and Reliability Analysis
View through CrossRef
Abstract
Background
Breast cancer is the most common malignant tumor and the fifth leading cause of cancer death worldwide, imposing a significant disease burden in China. Mammography is a key method for breast cancer screening, particularly for early diagnosis. Douyin, a popular social media platform, is increasingly used for sharing health information, but the quality and reliability of mammography-related videos remain unexamined.
Objective
This study aimed to evaluate the information quality and reliability of mammography videos on Douyin.
Methods
In October 2023, a search using the Chinese keywords for “mammography” and “mammography screening” was conducted on Douyin. From 200 retrieved videos, 136 mammography-related videos were selected for analysis. Basic video information, content, and sources were extracted. Video content was assessed for comprehensiveness across 7 categories: conception, examination process, applicable objects, precautions, combined examinations, advantages, and report. Completeness was evaluated using a researcher-developed checklist, while reliability and quality were measured using 2 modified DISCERN (mDISCERN) tool and the Global Quality Score (GQS). Correlations between video quality and characteristics were also examined.
Results
Among the video sources, 82.4% (112/136) were attributed to health professionals, and 17.6% (24/136) were attributed to nonprofessionals. Among health professionals, only 1 was a radiologist. Overall, 77.2% (105/136) of the videos had useful information about mammography. Among the useful videos, the advantages of mammography were the most frequently covered topic (53/105, 50.5%). Median values for the mDISCERN and GQS evaluations across all videos stood at 2.5 (IQR 1.63‐3) and 2 (IQR 1‐2), respectively. Within the subgroup assessment, the median mDISCERN score among the useful and professional groups stood at 2 (IQR 2‐3) and 3 (IQR 2‐3), respectively, surpassing the corresponding score for the unhelpful and nonprofessional groups at 0 (IQR 0‐0) and 0 (IQR 0‐0.75; P<.001). Likewise, the median GQS among the useful and professional groups was evaluated at 2 (IQR 1.5‐2) and 2 (IQR 1‐2), respectively, eclipsing that of the unhelpful and nonprofessional groups at 1 (IQR 1‐1) and 1 (IQR 1‐1.37; P<.001). The GQS was weak and negatively correlated with the number of likes (r=−0.24; P=.004), comments (r=−0.29; P<.001), and saves (r=−0.20; P=.02). The mDISCERN score was weak and negatively correlated with the number of likes (r=−0.26; P=.002), comments (r=−0.36; P<.001), saves (r=−0.22; P=.009), and shares (r=−0.18; P=.03).
Conclusions
The overall quality of mammography videos on Douyin is suboptimal, with most content uploaded by clinicians rather than radiologists. Radiologists should be encouraged to create accurate and informative videos to better educate patients. As Douyin grows as a health information platform, stricter publishing standards are needed to enhance the quality of medical content.
JMIR Publications Inc.
Title: Evaluation of Douyin Short Videos on Mammography in China: Quality and Reliability Analysis
Description:
Abstract
Background
Breast cancer is the most common malignant tumor and the fifth leading cause of cancer death worldwide, imposing a significant disease burden in China.
Mammography is a key method for breast cancer screening, particularly for early diagnosis.
Douyin, a popular social media platform, is increasingly used for sharing health information, but the quality and reliability of mammography-related videos remain unexamined.
Objective
This study aimed to evaluate the information quality and reliability of mammography videos on Douyin.
Methods
In October 2023, a search using the Chinese keywords for “mammography” and “mammography screening” was conducted on Douyin.
From 200 retrieved videos, 136 mammography-related videos were selected for analysis.
Basic video information, content, and sources were extracted.
Video content was assessed for comprehensiveness across 7 categories: conception, examination process, applicable objects, precautions, combined examinations, advantages, and report.
Completeness was evaluated using a researcher-developed checklist, while reliability and quality were measured using 2 modified DISCERN (mDISCERN) tool and the Global Quality Score (GQS).
Correlations between video quality and characteristics were also examined.
Results
Among the video sources, 82.
4% (112/136) were attributed to health professionals, and 17.
6% (24/136) were attributed to nonprofessionals.
Among health professionals, only 1 was a radiologist.
Overall, 77.
2% (105/136) of the videos had useful information about mammography.
Among the useful videos, the advantages of mammography were the most frequently covered topic (53/105, 50.
5%).
Median values for the mDISCERN and GQS evaluations across all videos stood at 2.
5 (IQR 1.
63‐3) and 2 (IQR 1‐2), respectively.
Within the subgroup assessment, the median mDISCERN score among the useful and professional groups stood at 2 (IQR 2‐3) and 3 (IQR 2‐3), respectively, surpassing the corresponding score for the unhelpful and nonprofessional groups at 0 (IQR 0‐0) and 0 (IQR 0‐0.
75; P<.
001).
Likewise, the median GQS among the useful and professional groups was evaluated at 2 (IQR 1.
5‐2) and 2 (IQR 1‐2), respectively, eclipsing that of the unhelpful and nonprofessional groups at 1 (IQR 1‐1) and 1 (IQR 1‐1.
37; P<.
001).
The GQS was weak and negatively correlated with the number of likes (r=−0.
24; P=.
004), comments (r=−0.
29; P<.
001), and saves (r=−0.
20; P=.
02).
The mDISCERN score was weak and negatively correlated with the number of likes (r=−0.
26; P=.
002), comments (r=−0.
36; P<.
001), saves (r=−0.
22; P=.
009), and shares (r=−0.
18; P=.
03).
Conclusions
The overall quality of mammography videos on Douyin is suboptimal, with most content uploaded by clinicians rather than radiologists.
Radiologists should be encouraged to create accurate and informative videos to better educate patients.
As Douyin grows as a health information platform, stricter publishing standards are needed to enhance the quality of medical content.
Related Results
Oral Diabetes Medication Videos on Douyin: Analysis of Information Quality and User Comment Attitudes
Oral Diabetes Medication Videos on Douyin: Analysis of Information Quality and User Comment Attitudes
Background
Oral diabetes medications are important for glucose management in people with diabetes. Although there are many health-related videos on Douyin (the ...
Oral Diabetes Medication Videos on Douyin: Analysis of Information Quality and User Comment Attitudes (Preprint)
Oral Diabetes Medication Videos on Douyin: Analysis of Information Quality and User Comment Attitudes (Preprint)
BACKGROUND
Oral diabetes medications are important for glucose management in people with diabetes. Although there are many health-related videos on Douyin (...
Domination of Polynomial with Application
Domination of Polynomial with Application
In this paper, .We .initiate the study of domination. polynomial , consider G=(V,E) be a simple, finite, and directed graph without. isolated. vertex .We present a study of the Ira...
Abstract IA15: Neighborhood factors and changes in mammography screening rates in response to promotora intervention in Latinas
Abstract IA15: Neighborhood factors and changes in mammography screening rates in response to promotora intervention in Latinas
Abstract
Latinas have relatively low rates of mammography screening participation, which may contribute to later stage of breast cancer at diagnosis for Latinas, and...
Short video platforms as sources of health information about cervical cancer: A content and quality analysis
Short video platforms as sources of health information about cervical cancer: A content and quality analysis
BackgroundThe development of short popular science video platforms helps people obtain health information, but no research has evaluated the information characteristics and quality...
Comparative Analysis of the Dissemination Effects of E-Cigarette Regulation on China's Douyin Platform and the Overseas Version of the Tiktok Platform
Comparative Analysis of the Dissemination Effects of E-Cigarette Regulation on China's Douyin Platform and the Overseas Version of the Tiktok Platform
Objective: This study aims to compare the content strategies of Douyin and TikTok regarding e-cigarette regulation videos, exploring how each platform adapts to its respective audi...
Intervention to Improve Mammography Screening at a Student-Run Free Clinic
Intervention to Improve Mammography Screening at a Student-Run Free Clinic
Background: Most late-stage breast cancer occurs in those who have never been screened. Uninsured women have lower screening rates than insured women. Student-run free clinics (SRF...
Abstract P5-01-02: Glandular dose in contrast-enhanced dual-energy mammography
Abstract P5-01-02: Glandular dose in contrast-enhanced dual-energy mammography
Abstract
INTRODUCTION
Estimation of the Average Glandular Dose (AGD) absorbed by the breast during x-ray based examination is an established part of q...

