Javascript must be enabled to continue!
OUTBUILDINGS: WHAT IS WRONG WITH THE LEGAL REGULATION
View through CrossRef
The article is devoted to the study of the concept of outbuildings, which is established in Federal Law No. 217-FZ dated July 29, 2017, “On the Conduct of Gardening and Vegetable Gardening by Citizens for Their Own Needs and on Amending Certain Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation”. The author notes that despite the short period of existence of this legal term (since January 1, 2019), it has already undergone legislative changes twice, which indicates the presence of problems in both theory and practice. It is also argued that the current definition suffers from inaccuracies, both in terms of the general application of the collective term “structures” to sheds, bathhouses, greenhouses, cellars, summer kitchens, and wells, and in terms of their characterization as “utility-related”. Furthermore, the article demonstrates the fallacy of classifying such structures as auxiliary (accessory), which is confirmed by the legal regime of the garden land plot. This regime implies that the construction of such buildings does not necessarily have to be linked to the emergence of other, seemingly more significant objects, such as a residential house or a garden house.
Title: OUTBUILDINGS: WHAT IS WRONG WITH THE LEGAL REGULATION
Description:
The article is devoted to the study of the concept of outbuildings, which is established in Federal Law No.
217-FZ dated July 29, 2017, “On the Conduct of Gardening and Vegetable Gardening by Citizens for Their Own Needs and on Amending Certain Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation”.
The author notes that despite the short period of existence of this legal term (since January 1, 2019), it has already undergone legislative changes twice, which indicates the presence of problems in both theory and practice.
It is also argued that the current definition suffers from inaccuracies, both in terms of the general application of the collective term “structures” to sheds, bathhouses, greenhouses, cellars, summer kitchens, and wells, and in terms of their characterization as “utility-related”.
Furthermore, the article demonstrates the fallacy of classifying such structures as auxiliary (accessory), which is confirmed by the legal regime of the garden land plot.
This regime implies that the construction of such buildings does not necessarily have to be linked to the emergence of other, seemingly more significant objects, such as a residential house or a garden house.
Related Results
THE ANALOGY OF STATUTE AND THE ANALOGY OF LAW AS DOCTRINAL INSTRUMENTS FOR LEGAL RESPONSE TO ECONOMIC CHALLENGES
THE ANALOGY OF STATUTE AND THE ANALOGY OF LAW AS DOCTRINAL INSTRUMENTS FOR LEGAL RESPONSE TO ECONOMIC CHALLENGES
Ukraine's contemporary legal system is undergoing a period of significant transformation, which necessitates not only a robust and stable legal framework, but also a flexible doctr...
Legal regulation of the genesis of digital identity
Legal regulation of the genesis of digital identity
The article deals with a new phenomenon for the legal science – the institute of legal regulation of the genesis of digital identity.The subject of the research is the relations th...
TRADITIONAL OUTBUILDINGS OF THE MORDOVIANS
TRADITIONAL OUTBUILDINGS OF THE MORDOVIANS
Introduction. The article deals with the main traditional outbuildings of the Mordvinians, reported on their functional purpose in economic activity. The forms and types of outbuil...
Autonomy on Trial
Autonomy on Trial
Photo by CHUTTERSNAP on Unsplash
Abstract
This paper critically examines how US bioethics and health law conceptualize patient autonomy, contrasting the rights-based, individualist...
TRENDS AND CONTRADICTIONS IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF LEGAL TECH
TRENDS AND CONTRADICTIONS IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF LEGAL TECH
Problem setting. Digitalization has recently become increasingly important in the professional everyday life of a lawyer. Since 2020, trends in the automation of legal processes ha...
POLITIK HUKUM PENGATURAN PERATURAN DESA DALAM PRODUK HUKUM
POLITIK HUKUM PENGATURAN PERATURAN DESA DALAM PRODUK HUKUM
The discussion about Village Regulation arrangements in legal products is closely related to theory of legal politics. Based on a legal politics review, the Village Regulation arra...
Tax-legal dimension of the EU founding treaties
Tax-legal dimension of the EU founding treaties
In this article, the author examines the legal nature and content of the EU founding treaties in the part of their impact on the regulation of tax relations. Having the nature of i...
Populisme Mahkamah Konstitusi dalam Penafsiran Perkara-Perkara pada Wilayah Open Legal Policy
Populisme Mahkamah Konstitusi dalam Penafsiran Perkara-Perkara pada Wilayah Open Legal Policy
In the past seven years, the striking characteristic of cases filed before the Constitutional Court (MK) has developed into cases at the open legal policy level. In open legal case...

