Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Lo dado, el lenguaje y el saber. Una lectura crítica de Wilfrid Sellars

View through CrossRef
This essay examines Wilfrid Sellars’s critique of the “myth of the given” in empiricism, arguing that all knowledge—including perceptual knowledge—is mediated by a conceptual‑linguistic network. Drawing on Empiricism and the Philosophy of Mind (1971), the paper shows that Sellars’s distinction between “seeing that something is the case” and merely “seeing something” entails that experience is never pure but always situated within a “space of reasons.” This article explores parallels between this view and the Sapir‑Whorf hypothesis, as well as Kuhn’s notion of paradigm, highlighting how theoretical frameworks shape both scientific observation and everyday perception. Ontological and methodological implications of denying “pure” data are discussed, pointing out tensions concerning non‑discursive forms of knowledge (animals, infants, practical know‑how). Finally, a broadened reading is proposed that acknowledges the normative and social dimension of knowledge while still recognizing situated, embodied, and affective ways of knowing.
Paideia Studio (publications)
Title: Lo dado, el lenguaje y el saber. Una lectura crítica de Wilfrid Sellars
Description:
This essay examines Wilfrid Sellars’s critique of the “myth of the given” in empiricism, arguing that all knowledge—including perceptual knowledge—is mediated by a conceptual‑linguistic network.
Drawing on Empiricism and the Philosophy of Mind (1971), the paper shows that Sellars’s distinction between “seeing that something is the case” and merely “seeing something” entails that experience is never pure but always situated within a “space of reasons.
” This article explores parallels between this view and the Sapir‑Whorf hypothesis, as well as Kuhn’s notion of paradigm, highlighting how theoretical frameworks shape both scientific observation and everyday perception.
Ontological and methodological implications of denying “pure” data are discussed, pointing out tensions concerning non‑discursive forms of knowledge (animals, infants, practical know‑how).
Finally, a broadened reading is proposed that acknowledges the normative and social dimension of knowledge while still recognizing situated, embodied, and affective ways of knowing.

Related Results

Acciones docentes durante situaciones didácticas con lectura y escritura en Biología del nivel secundario
Acciones docentes durante situaciones didácticas con lectura y escritura en Biología del nivel secundario
¿Cómo enseñan los docentes que acuden a la función epistémica de la lectura y la escritura en sus clases? En esta investigación caracterizamos las acciones docentes que permiten ac...
Introducción
Introducción
Los tres ensayos críticos que componen este dossier tienen un punto de convergencia en torno del cual he pensado articularlos: son modalidades diversas del ensayo crítico literario...
Covid Conversations 1: Peter Sellars
Covid Conversations 1: Peter Sellars
In this profoundly dialogical exchange, Peter Sellars, theatre director, researcher, and teacher, and Maria Shevtsova open out a whole array of questions on the integral relation b...
Wilfrid Sellars
Wilfrid Sellars
Wilfrid Sellars (b. 1912–d. 1989) did some of the most interesting and challenging work in Western philosophy in the 20th century. At a time when most philosophers were moving towa...
Leer
Leer
  Isabel Carril y Marí­a Caparrós quienes se consideran lectoras habituales, construyen su obra Leer… desde un sentido profundamente humanista y no meramente cognitivo, reconocen...
Marcela Fernández Valenzuela Colectivo de Geografía Crítica Gladis Armijo
Marcela Fernández Valenzuela Colectivo de Geografía Crítica Gladis Armijo
Marcela Fernández Valenzuela Profesora de Historia, Geografía y Educación Cívica, Licenciada en Educación con mención en Geografía por la Universidad Metropolitana de Ciencia...
Formación en lectura de cuentos: Impacto en intervenciones en educadoras docentes y no docentes
Formación en lectura de cuentos: Impacto en intervenciones en educadoras docentes y no docentes
Con el fin de estudiar los cambios que la formación promueve, la investigación compara el impacto de una instancia formativa de cuatro meses de duración, en las intervenciones dura...
Pedagogí­a Crí­tica
Pedagogí­a Crí­tica
Bórquez Bustos, Rodolfo Trillas, 2006 El libro presentado por Bórquez muestra un recorrido por las distintas corrientes ideológicas ligadas con la modernidad, primero desde un punt...

Back to Top