Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
Javascript must be enabled to continue!
In Defense of Real Cartesian Motion: A Reply to Lennon
View through CrossRef
On Thomas Lennon’s (2007) “Eleatic” reading of Descartes, the Cartesian world is in reality motionless, its motions conceived as mere phenomenal appearances. Lennon is aware that this radical reading appears to be at odds with various Cartesian texts that seemingly describe real motions, and accordingly he reinterprets these texts in such a way as to render them compatible with his reading. This reply to Lennon considers many further Cartesian texts that cannot be “reinterpreted” along the lines Lennon describes, with the ultimate aim of showing that the phenomenalist is committed to dividing Cartesian texts into passages dealing with reality and with appearance. I argue there are good reasons not to read Descartes in this way, and we should take Cartesian motion at face value: to be real.
Title: In Defense of Real Cartesian Motion: A Reply to Lennon
Description:
On Thomas Lennon’s (2007) “Eleatic” reading of Descartes, the Cartesian world is in reality motionless, its motions conceived as mere phenomenal appearances.
Lennon is aware that this radical reading appears to be at odds with various Cartesian texts that seemingly describe real motions, and accordingly he reinterprets these texts in such a way as to render them compatible with his reading.
This reply to Lennon considers many further Cartesian texts that cannot be “reinterpreted” along the lines Lennon describes, with the ultimate aim of showing that the phenomenalist is committed to dividing Cartesian texts into passages dealing with reality and with appearance.
I argue there are good reasons not to read Descartes in this way, and we should take Cartesian motion at face value: to be real.
Related Results
Imagined worldviews in John Lennon’s “Imagine”: a multimodal re-performance / Visões de mundo imaginadas no “Imagine” de John Lennon: uma re-performance multimodal
Imagined worldviews in John Lennon’s “Imagine”: a multimodal re-performance / Visões de mundo imaginadas no “Imagine” de John Lennon: uma re-performance multimodal
Abstract: This paper addresses the issue of multimodal re-performance, a concept developed by us, in view of the fact that the famous song “Imagine”, by John Lennon, was published ...
Cyber defense in breadth: Modeling and analysis of integrated defense systems
Cyber defense in breadth: Modeling and analysis of integrated defense systems
Cybersecurity is one of most critical concerns for any organization, as frequency and severity of cyber attacks constantly increase, resulting in loss of vital assets and/or servic...
Comparison of prospective and retrospective motion correction for Magnetic Resonance Imaging of the brain - Master's Thesis in Physics
Comparison of prospective and retrospective motion correction for Magnetic Resonance Imaging of the brain - Master's Thesis in Physics
Head motion is one of the most common sources of artefacts for Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) of the brain. Especially children, being intimidated by the dimensions and the noise...
Indonesia's Defense Policy In Addressing Space Threats In Perspective Of Defense Management
Indonesia's Defense Policy In Addressing Space Threats In Perspective Of Defense Management
This article investigates Indonesia's defense policy in addressing space threats, driven by the research objectives of analyzing the policy, assessing its effectiveness, and provid...
Enhancing Real-Time Video Processing With Artificial Intelligence: Overcoming Resolution Loss, Motion Artifacts, And Temporal Inconsistencies
Enhancing Real-Time Video Processing With Artificial Intelligence: Overcoming Resolution Loss, Motion Artifacts, And Temporal Inconsistencies
Purpose: Traditional video processing techniques often struggle with critical challenges such as low resolution, motion artifacts, and temporal inconsistencies, especially in real-...
Categorizing Motion: Story-Based Categorizations
Categorizing Motion: Story-Based Categorizations
Our most primary goal is to provide a motion categorization for moving entities. A motion categorization that is related to how humans categorize motion, i.e., that is cognitive ...
Implementation Of Indonesia's Defence Economy Through The Defence Budget Sector
Implementation Of Indonesia's Defence Economy Through The Defence Budget Sector
The implementation of military spending through the Indonesian defense industry has shown gradual positive development, driven by efforts to establish an independent defense sector...
Integrative Model Defense Indonesian Hybrid in Face Dynamics ASEAN Conflict
Integrative Model Defense Indonesian Hybrid in Face Dynamics ASEAN Conflict
Purpose – This article aim For explore idea integrative regarding defense strategy Indonesian hybrid with combine approach conventional, asymmetric, and multidimensional in face co...