Dispersal provides trophic-level dependent insurance against a heatwave in freshwater ecosystems

AbstractClimate change-related heatwaves are major recent threats to biodiversity and ecosystem functioning. However, our current understanding of the mechanisms governing community resilience (resistance and recovery) to extreme temperature events is still rudimentary. The spatial insurance hypothesis postulates that diverse regional species pools can buffer ecosystem functioning against local disturbances through immigration of better adapted taxa. However, experimental evidence for such predictions from multi-trophic communities and pulse-type disturbances, like heatwaves, are largely missing. We performed an experimental mesocosm study with alpine lake plankton to test whether a dispersal event from natural lakes prior to a simulated heatwave could increase resistance and recovery of local communities. As the buffering effect of dispersal may differ among trophic groups, we independently manipulated dispersal of organisms from lower (microorganisms) and higher (zooplankton) trophic levels. The experimental heatwave suppressed total community biomass by having a strong negative effect on zooplankton biomass, probably due to a heat-induced increase in metabolic costs that in turn caused mortality. Heating thus resulted in weaker top-down control and a subsequent shift to bottom-heavy food webs. While zooplankton dispersal did not alleviate the negative heatwave effects on zooplankton biomass, dispersal of microorganism enhanced biomass recovery at the level of phytoplankton, thereby providing evidence for spatial insurance. The different response of trophic groups may be related to the timing of dispersal, which happened under strongly monopolized resource conditions by zooplankton, creating limited opportunity for competitors to establish. At the same time, the heatwave released phytoplankton from grazing pressure and increased nutrient recycling, which may have facilitated the establishment of new phytoplankton taxa. Our findings clearly show that even a short heatwave can strongly alter energy flow in aquatic ecosystems. Although dispersal can enhance community resilience, the strength of its buffering effects depends on the trophic level.