Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Global BROOK90: validation, uncertainties, current progress and future outline.

View through CrossRef
<p>‘Just drop a catchment and receive reasonable model output’ – still stays as motto and main idea of the ‘Global BROOK90’ project. The open-source R-package is build-up on global land cover, soil, topographical, meteorological datasets and the lumped hydrological model as a core to simulate water balance components on HRU scale all over the world in an automatic mode. First introduced in EGU2020 and followed by GitHub code release including an publication of methodology with few examples we want to continue with the insights on the current state and highlight the future steps of the project.</p><p>A global validation of discharge and evapotranspiration components of the model showed promising results. We used 190 small (median size of 64 km<sup>2</sup>) catchments and FLUXNET data which represent a wide range of relief, vegetation and soil types within various climate zones. The model performance was evaluated with NSE, KGE, KGESS and MAE. In more than 75 % of the cases the framework performed better than the mean of the observed discharge. On a temporal scale the performance is significantly better on a monthly vs daily scale. Cluster analysis revealed that some of the site characteristics have a significant influence on the performance. Additionally, it was found that Global BROOK90 outperforms GloFAS ERA5 discharge reanalysis (for the category with smallest catchments).</p><p>A cross-combination of three different BROOK90 setups and three forcing datasets was set up to reveal uncertainties of the Global BROOK90 package using a small catchment in Germany as a case study. Going from local to regional and finally global scale we compared mixtures of model parameterization schemes (original calibrated BROOK90, EXTRUSO and Global BROOK90) and meteorological datasets (local gauges, RaKlida and ERA5). Besides high model performances for a local dataset plus a calibrated model and weaker results for ERA5 and the Global BROOK90, it was found that the ERA5 dataset is still able to provide good results when combined with a regional and local parameterization. On the other side, the combination of a global parameterization with local and regional forcings gives still adequate, but much worse results. Furthermore, a hydrograph separation revealed that the Global BROOK90 parameterization as well as ERA5 discharge data perform weaker especially within low flow periods.</p><p>Currently, some new features are added to the original package. First, with the recent release of the ERA5 extension, historical simulations with the package now are expanded to 1950-2021 period. Additionally, an alternative climate reanalysis dataset is included in the framework (Merra-2, 0.5x0.625-degree spatial resolution, starting from 1980). A preliminary validation shows insignificant differences between both meteorological datasets with respect to the discharge based model performance.</p><p>Further upgrades of the framework will include the following core milestones: recognition of forecast and climate projections and parameter optimization features. In the nearest future we plan to utilize full power of the Climate Data Store for easy access to seasonal forecasts (i.e. ECMWF, DWD, NCEP) as well as climate projections (CMIP5) to extend the package’s scope to predict near and far future water balance components.</p>
Title: Global BROOK90: validation, uncertainties, current progress and future outline.
Description:
<p>‘Just drop a catchment and receive reasonable model output’ – still stays as motto and main idea of the ‘Global BROOK90’ project.
The open-source R-package is build-up on global land cover, soil, topographical, meteorological datasets and the lumped hydrological model as a core to simulate water balance components on HRU scale all over the world in an automatic mode.
First introduced in EGU2020 and followed by GitHub code release including an publication of methodology with few examples we want to continue with the insights on the current state and highlight the future steps of the project.
</p><p>A global validation of discharge and evapotranspiration components of the model showed promising results.
We used 190 small (median size of 64 km<sup>2</sup>) catchments and FLUXNET data which represent a wide range of relief, vegetation and soil types within various climate zones.
The model performance was evaluated with NSE, KGE, KGESS and MAE.
In more than 75 % of the cases the framework performed better than the mean of the observed discharge.
On a temporal scale the performance is significantly better on a monthly vs daily scale.
Cluster analysis revealed that some of the site characteristics have a significant influence on the performance.
Additionally, it was found that Global BROOK90 outperforms GloFAS ERA5 discharge reanalysis (for the category with smallest catchments).
</p><p>A cross-combination of three different BROOK90 setups and three forcing datasets was set up to reveal uncertainties of the Global BROOK90 package using a small catchment in Germany as a case study.
Going from local to regional and finally global scale we compared mixtures of model parameterization schemes (original calibrated BROOK90, EXTRUSO and Global BROOK90) and meteorological datasets (local gauges, RaKlida and ERA5).
Besides high model performances for a local dataset plus a calibrated model and weaker results for ERA5 and the Global BROOK90, it was found that the ERA5 dataset is still able to provide good results when combined with a regional and local parameterization.
On the other side, the combination of a global parameterization with local and regional forcings gives still adequate, but much worse results.
Furthermore, a hydrograph separation revealed that the Global BROOK90 parameterization as well as ERA5 discharge data perform weaker especially within low flow periods.
</p><p>Currently, some new features are added to the original package.
First, with the recent release of the ERA5 extension, historical simulations with the package now are expanded to 1950-2021 period.
Additionally, an alternative climate reanalysis dataset is included in the framework (Merra-2, 0.
5x0.
625-degree spatial resolution, starting from 1980).
A preliminary validation shows insignificant differences between both meteorological datasets with respect to the discharge based model performance.
</p><p>Further upgrades of the framework will include the following core milestones: recognition of forecast and climate projections and parameter optimization features.
In the nearest future we plan to utilize full power of the Climate Data Store for easy access to seasonal forecasts (i.
e.
ECMWF, DWD, NCEP) as well as climate projections (CMIP5) to extend the package’s scope to predict near and far future water balance components.
</p>.

Related Results

Validation in Doctoral Education: Exploring PhD Students’ Perceptions of Belonging to Scaffold Doctoral Identity Work
Validation in Doctoral Education: Exploring PhD Students’ Perceptions of Belonging to Scaffold Doctoral Identity Work
Aim/Purpose: The aim of this article is to make a case of the role of validation in doctoral education. The purpose is to detail findings from three studies which explore PhD stude...
Interception loss as an underestimated component of evapotranspiration modelling in a forested catchment
Interception loss as an underestimated component of evapotranspiration modelling in a forested catchment
<p>Norway spruce monoculture stands often represent a typical vegetation cover in Central Europe and these stands impact the hydrological pattern on a catchment scale...
EPD Electronic Pathogen Detection v1
EPD Electronic Pathogen Detection v1
Electronic pathogen detection (EPD) is a non - invasive, rapid, affordable, point- of- care test, for Covid 19 resulting from infection with SARS-CoV-2 virus. EPD scanning techno...
Global Surgery Research: An Overview and the Role of Medical Students and Surgical Trainees in Advancing Global Surgery Research in LMICs
Global Surgery Research: An Overview and the Role of Medical Students and Surgical Trainees in Advancing Global Surgery Research in LMICs
Global surgery research is a critical area of study aimed at enhancing access to safe and effective surgical care for patients in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). It is es...
Climate Change Adaptation
Climate Change Adaptation
Climate change adaptation is the ability of a society or a natural system to adjust to the (changing) conditions that support life in a certain climate region, including weather ex...
ASYMMETRIES OF PUBLIC FINANCES UNDER STATE INCOME FORMATION UNCERTAINTIES
ASYMMETRIES OF PUBLIC FINANCES UNDER STATE INCOME FORMATION UNCERTAINTIES
Introduction. The spread of geopolitical conflicts and hybrid wars, the diversity and asymmetries of global trends, migration crises, digitalization, the expanding use of artificia...
Communicating uncertainties in flood early warnings
Communicating uncertainties in flood early warnings
A key problem in flood early warnings for small catchments is the increasing forecast uncertainty associated with decreasing catchment size. Forecasts for small catchments often ar...
Integrated Uncertainty Assessment for Project Evaluation and Risk Analysis
Integrated Uncertainty Assessment for Project Evaluation and Risk Analysis
SummaryThe main technical contribution of the study presented in this paper was, by an integrated assessment of uncertainties in geophysics, geology and reservoir engineering, to p...

Back to Top