Javascript must be enabled to continue!
POSITIONING AHL AL-BAYT WITHOUT TENDENCIES: AL-SHAWKANI'S CONTRIBUTION TO DETERMINING THE HADITH IN ISLAMIC SHARIA
View through CrossRef
Shiites tend to prioritize Ahl al-Bayt's position in transmitting Hadith. It affects the determination of Hadith as a primary source in Islamic Sharia. The Zaydi Maddhab, the Shi'a branch, is very dominant in Yemen. However, al-Shawkani, educated by his father and his Zaydist teachers, has a different view from Zaydism in positioning Ahl al-Bayt. Al-Shawkani saw that the uncertain political conditions in Yemen and the rise of blind taqlid directed Muslims to go astray and heresy at that time. This study examines al-Shawkani's stance on Ahl al-Bayt's position in determining the basis of Sharia law through his relevant works. Therefore, this socio-historical investigation also reveals the contribution of al-Shawkani thought in Islamic studies. This research shows that although al-Shawkani was influenced by Zaydism, objectively, he did not prioritize Ahl al-Bayt and was not passionate about one particular madhhab—a stance often opposed by Yemen's Zaydist scholars. In his works, al-Shawkani indirectly agrees with the opinion of Sunni scholars in determining the narrators of the Hadith as the primary source for deciding Islamic Sharia law. Thus, the contribution of al-Shawkani, who positions Hadith narrators objectively and scientifically, both Ahl al-Bayt and non-Ahl al-Bayt, is set the same as the criteria most scholars of Hadith experts determined.
Title: POSITIONING AHL AL-BAYT WITHOUT TENDENCIES: AL-SHAWKANI'S CONTRIBUTION TO DETERMINING THE HADITH IN ISLAMIC SHARIA
Description:
Shiites tend to prioritize Ahl al-Bayt's position in transmitting Hadith.
It affects the determination of Hadith as a primary source in Islamic Sharia.
The Zaydi Maddhab, the Shi'a branch, is very dominant in Yemen.
However, al-Shawkani, educated by his father and his Zaydist teachers, has a different view from Zaydism in positioning Ahl al-Bayt.
Al-Shawkani saw that the uncertain political conditions in Yemen and the rise of blind taqlid directed Muslims to go astray and heresy at that time.
This study examines al-Shawkani's stance on Ahl al-Bayt's position in determining the basis of Sharia law through his relevant works.
Therefore, this socio-historical investigation also reveals the contribution of al-Shawkani thought in Islamic studies.
This research shows that although al-Shawkani was influenced by Zaydism, objectively, he did not prioritize Ahl al-Bayt and was not passionate about one particular madhhab—a stance often opposed by Yemen's Zaydist scholars.
In his works, al-Shawkani indirectly agrees with the opinion of Sunni scholars in determining the narrators of the Hadith as the primary source for deciding Islamic Sharia law.
Thus, the contribution of al-Shawkani, who positions Hadith narrators objectively and scientifically, both Ahl al-Bayt and non-Ahl al-Bayt, is set the same as the criteria most scholars of Hadith experts determined.
Related Results
Ahl al-Hadis and Ahl al-Ra’y (A Polemic of Domination Dynamics on Hadith)
Ahl al-Hadis and Ahl al-Ra’y (A Polemic of Domination Dynamics on Hadith)
In the horizon of Hadith study, two major streams have different thoughts on hadith interpretation, namely Ahl Al-Hadith and Ahl Al-Ra'y. Ahl Al-Hadith views hadith, based on their...
Konsep Hadith Mawdu‘i Menurut Perspektif Pengkaji Hadith Kontemporari: Antara Dirasah Al-Mawdu‘Iyyah min Al-Hadith dan Syarh Al-Mawdu‘I li Al-Hadith
Konsep Hadith Mawdu‘i Menurut Perspektif Pengkaji Hadith Kontemporari: Antara Dirasah Al-Mawdu‘Iyyah min Al-Hadith dan Syarh Al-Mawdu‘I li Al-Hadith
The hadith mawdu’i (thematic hadith) terminology is widely used in contemporary hadith discourse. However, there are confusions in understanding its true concept since several othe...
COMPARISON OF THE IMPLEMENTATION OF MAQASHID SHARIA IN CERTIFIED SHARIA HOTELS AND UNCERTIFIED SHARIA HOTELS (STUDY ON SHARIA HOTELS IN INDONESIA)
COMPARISON OF THE IMPLEMENTATION OF MAQASHID SHARIA IN CERTIFIED SHARIA HOTELS AND UNCERTIFIED SHARIA HOTELS (STUDY ON SHARIA HOTELS IN INDONESIA)
The performance of Islamic entities does not only consist of aspects of financial performance (economic performance), but also views from the aspect of sharia as a characteristic t...
GEOPOLITICS AND OCCUPATION OF THE MEDITERRANEAN SEA
GEOPOLITICS AND OCCUPATION OF THE MEDITERRANEAN SEA
The Mediterranean Sea is often forgotten in the context of the current occupation in Bayt al-Maqdis, which includes a small part of the Eastern Mediterranean Sea. Indeed, apart fro...
Al-Hadith Al-Gharib in the Discourse of Hadith Studies; The Authenticity and The Authority
Al-Hadith Al-Gharib in the Discourse of Hadith Studies; The Authenticity and The Authority
This article aims to examine the concept of al-hadith al-Gharib from the perspective of hadith scholars. The primary research questions address: (1) What defines al-hadith al-Ghari...
Autentikasi Hadis-Hadis Kitab Jinayah Dan Hudud Daripada Kitab Bulughul Maram Karya Al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani
Autentikasi Hadis-Hadis Kitab Jinayah Dan Hudud Daripada Kitab Bulughul Maram Karya Al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani
The falsification of hadith has tremendously spreaded among society. The dissemination of fabricated hadith has been normalised not only among the public but also the Islamic and r...
Perbahasan ‘Ulūm Al-Ḥadīth dalam Uṣūl Al-Fiqh Mazhab Syafii
Perbahasan ‘Ulūm Al-Ḥadīth dalam Uṣūl Al-Fiqh Mazhab Syafii
During its early years, the discipline of ‘Ulum al-Ḥadith gradually emerged into existence until it reached maturity in the seventh century with the appearance of the famous work b...
KUALITAS HADIS SHAHIH, HASAN, DHAIF SEBAGAI HUJJAH DALAM HUKUM ISLAM
KUALITAS HADIS SHAHIH, HASAN, DHAIF SEBAGAI HUJJAH DALAM HUKUM ISLAM
As the second source of Islamic law after the Qur'an, Hadith is divided into three, namely Sahih, Hasan and Dhaif Hadith. Sahih hadith is a hadith that fulfills the conditions: San...

