Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
Javascript must be enabled to continue!
The Paradox of the Dao in Laozi : A Williamsonian Solution
View through CrossRef
ABSTRACT
A guiding principle is that there is no guiding principle. This means that one both should and should not follow this principle. This is called the paradox of the Dao in
Laozi
, which arises from statements like “the Dao that can be put into words is not the authentic Dao”; it suggests both the inexpressibility and the expressibility of the Dao. Chad Hansen proposes the antilanguage interpretation for the paradox of the Dao in
Laozi
. But the antilanguage interpretation is unsatisfying, for it is both incoherent by itself and inconsistent with the text in
Laozi
. Text evidence shows that vagueness is relevant to the paradox of the Dao, which could be relocated as the sorites paradox. With the help of Williamson's epistemicism and the anti‐KK argument, a new interpretation, the anti‐DD argument, is proposed for the paradox of the Dao. This interpretation both avoids the infinite regress of Hansen's interpretation and aligns better with the text in
Laozi
.
Title: The Paradox of the Dao in
Laozi
: A Williamsonian Solution
Description:
ABSTRACT
A guiding principle is that there is no guiding principle.
This means that one both should and should not follow this principle.
This is called the paradox of the Dao in
Laozi
, which arises from statements like “the Dao that can be put into words is not the authentic Dao”; it suggests both the inexpressibility and the expressibility of the Dao.
Chad Hansen proposes the antilanguage interpretation for the paradox of the Dao in
Laozi
.
But the antilanguage interpretation is unsatisfying, for it is both incoherent by itself and inconsistent with the text in
Laozi
.
Text evidence shows that vagueness is relevant to the paradox of the Dao, which could be relocated as the sorites paradox.
With the help of Williamson's epistemicism and the anti‐KK argument, a new interpretation, the anti‐DD argument, is proposed for the paradox of the Dao.
This interpretation both avoids the infinite regress of Hansen's interpretation and aligns better with the text in
Laozi
.
Related Results
On the Interpretation of Ziran in the Three Commentaries on Laozi in the Han Dynasty
On the Interpretation of Ziran in the Three Commentaries on Laozi in the Han Dynasty
The tradition of Chinese philosophical interpretation contains an inherent tension between “objectively interpreting classics” and “subjectively constructing systems”, with three m...
On Laozi’s Dao—An Attempt to Make Philosophy Speak Chinese
On Laozi’s Dao—An Attempt to Make Philosophy Speak Chinese
“How is the meaning of the Dao to be understood?” To answer this question, we should not make indiscreet remarks outside of the framework of Laozi’s thought; rather, we should ente...
Notes on the Laozi and Yan Fu’s Theory of Dao
Notes on the Laozi and Yan Fu’s Theory of Dao
In his Notes on the Laozi, Yan Fu constructs a new and unique theory of Dao that incorporates ideas from both Chinese and Western philosophies. Yan’s Dao is a unity of the physical...
The Origin of the Integration of the Yijing and the Laozi: Yan Zun’s Laozi Zhigui and Its Philosophical Construction and Historical Impact
The Origin of the Integration of the Yijing and the Laozi: Yan Zun’s Laozi Zhigui and Its Philosophical Construction and Historical Impact
Yan Zun’s Laozi Zhigui is the earliest surviving commentary that systematically interprets the Laozi through the lens of the Yijing. It holds pioneering significance in the history...
Organizational Paradox
Organizational Paradox
Organizational paradox offers a theory of the nature and management of competing demands. Historically, the dominant paradigm in organizational theory depicted competing demands as...
Global Ethics in the Thought of Laozi: Constructing China’s Soft Power
Global Ethics in the Thought of Laozi: Constructing China’s Soft Power
The thought of Laozi is of paramount importance in Chinese traditional culture. It is significant for us to discover some meaningful factors in Laozi’s ideological systems in order...
The Monotheist Laozi
The Monotheist Laozi
<p class="JIMtext">The enclosed article, “The Monotheist Laozi” seeks to explore Laozi’s Dao De Jing through a comparative theological framework, with particular emphasis on ...
FANWU LIUXING 凡物流形 (“ALL THINGS FLOW INTO FORM”) AND THE “ONE” IN THE LAOZI
FANWU LIUXING 凡物流形 (“ALL THINGS FLOW INTO FORM”) AND THE “ONE” IN THE LAOZI
AbstractThe archeological discoveries of the past several decades have radically expanded our knowledge of the Laozi and its context. Thus far, most research has focused on the var...