Stand, family, and rust-source effects on four attributes of lodgepole pine resistance to western gall rust

Lodgepole pine (Pinuscontorta var. latifolia Engelm.) seedlings from 23 open-pollinated pine families from five stands in west-central Alberta were inoculated with western gall rust (Endocronartiumharknessii (J.P. Moore) Y. Hiratsuka) spores from four locations within 69 km of those stands. Six weeks after inoculation and at 3-week intervals for 21 weeks thereafter, seedlings were examined for symptoms of infection and galls. Eighteen months after inoculation, most trees in a sample of 1321 had either fully developed galls or no galls; partial gall formation was uncommon. Frequency of gall formation was highly correlated with the area under the disease progress curve (AUDPC) of symptom appearance and the AUDPC of gall appearance. It was also correlated, although less strongly, with the frequency of seedlings that had initially shown symptoms of infection but had no galls 21 weeks after inoculation. Regardless of whether AUDPC of gall appearance, frequency of gall formation, or failure to develop galls following infection was used as the criterion of resistance, the results were similar. Family effects were greater than stand effects, and rust-source effects were smaller than family effects and not always significant. There was no interaction between rust-source effects and either stand or family effects.