Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Defining Marginality and Liminality for the Study of the Ancient Near East
View through CrossRef
Abstract
Marginality and liminality are concepts that are used in the study of the ancient Near East, although formal definitions for these terms are rarely given. This paper explores the history of the uses of these terms in social theory, discussing the origins of the terms in the writings of early twentieth-century thinkers such as Georg Simmel, Robert Ezra Park, and Victor Turner. It details how these ideas and concepts were debated by psychologists, sociologists, and anthropologists throughout the twentieth century, when these terms were adopted into Near Eastern studies. While these concepts were defined by social theorists, investigations of the archaeological, textual, and art-historical evidence from the ancient Near East show that they well reflect emic conceptualizations. Examples from Near Eastern contexts demonstrate the benefits of using flexible and multi-vocalic conceptualizations of marginality and liminality that still recognize the distinctiveness of these two issues. The paper concludes by offering different frameworks for applying these concepts to the study of the Bronze Age Near East.
Title: Defining Marginality and Liminality for the Study of the Ancient Near East
Description:
Abstract
Marginality and liminality are concepts that are used in the study of the ancient Near East, although formal definitions for these terms are rarely given.
This paper explores the history of the uses of these terms in social theory, discussing the origins of the terms in the writings of early twentieth-century thinkers such as Georg Simmel, Robert Ezra Park, and Victor Turner.
It details how these ideas and concepts were debated by psychologists, sociologists, and anthropologists throughout the twentieth century, when these terms were adopted into Near Eastern studies.
While these concepts were defined by social theorists, investigations of the archaeological, textual, and art-historical evidence from the ancient Near East show that they well reflect emic conceptualizations.
Examples from Near Eastern contexts demonstrate the benefits of using flexible and multi-vocalic conceptualizations of marginality and liminality that still recognize the distinctiveness of these two issues.
The paper concludes by offering different frameworks for applying these concepts to the study of the Bronze Age Near East.
Related Results
RECEPTION OF LIMINAL EXPERIENCE
RECEPTION OF LIMINAL EXPERIENCE
This article explores theoretical aspects of liminality, tracing the evolution of its concept, from its role in ancient ritual structures to its interpretation in conflict theory. ...
Ritualistic Analysis of Liminality in Theatrical Performances
Ritualistic Analysis of Liminality in Theatrical Performances
With the development of social media and stage technology, an increasing number of people are attracted by theatrical performances. Originally used to analysis human interactions i...
Liminality as a Principle of the Life of Christian Communities in the Reflections of Richard Rohr
Liminality as a Principle of the Life of Christian Communities in the Reflections of Richard Rohr
This article analyzes Richard Rohr’s reflections on the anthropological and pastoral significance of the liminality. Although we do not find among Rohr’s publications a book in whi...
Betwixt and Between Liminality and Marginality
Betwixt and Between Liminality and Marginality
Betwixt and Between Liminality and Marginality: Mind the Gap offers an interdisciplinary thinking on “the marginal” within society. Using the framework of Victor Turner’s earlier n...
Living Compound Marginality: Experiences of a Japanese Muslim Woman
Living Compound Marginality: Experiences of a Japanese Muslim Woman
The present article discusses the ways in which ethnic Japanese Muslim women are perceived and treated in contemporary Japanese society, through a case study of one Japanese female...
Occupational limbo, transitional liminality and permanent liminality: New conceptual distinctions
Occupational limbo, transitional liminality and permanent liminality: New conceptual distinctions
This article contributes new theoretical perspectives and empirical findings to the conceptualization of occupational liminality. Here, we posit ‘occupational limbo’ as a state dis...
The Misery of Women: Liminality of Gender Roles in Stephen King’s Misery
The Misery of Women: Liminality of Gender Roles in Stephen King’s Misery
There was no Annie because Annie had not been a goddess at all, only a crazy lady who had hurt Paul for reasons of her own…The hole opened and Paul stared through at what was there...
A Temporary Liminal Space Counteracting the Permanent ‘in between’ in Working Life
A Temporary Liminal Space Counteracting the Permanent ‘in between’ in Working Life
Ambiguous liminality used to exist ‘in between’, in a transition to a new social-structural order, but recently, it has gained a more permanent and normalized presence in working l...

