Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Academic Investigation and Correction of Error in [Bibliographic Study on Changgi of Joseon Dynasty] by Yang Taejin (1992): Focusing on Errors in [Records of Gisaeng and Prostitute]
View through CrossRef
This study used the resources and related data of the time to investigate various academic errors and distortions found in the [Bibliographic Study on Changgi of Joseon Dynasty] by Yang Taejin (1992), which is the first bibliographic study on the [Records of Gisaeng and Prostitute] and corrected the relevant errors.
The [Bibliographic Study on Changgi of Joseon Dynasty] considerably degenerates the fundamental characteristics of the [Records of Gisaeng and Prostitute] because it mixes “documents related to Gisaeng” and “documents related to prostitute” illogically, such as “prostitute quarter,” “Gisaeng,” “prostitute”, “forced prostitution,” “Gisaeng Control Document” by the Resident-General, “unofficial story,” and “a series of documents to control and monitor the Gisaeng in Seoul.” The [Bibliographic Study on Changgi of Joseon Dynasty] also largely distorted the historical fact that the Gisaeng was a professional entertainer under the “Modern Gisaeng System” and that the prostitute was a professional prostitute under the “Licensed Prostitution System” when they were recorded in the [Records of Gisaeng and Prostitute] in the past.
Moreover, the academic errors and distortions of the [Bibliographic Study on Changgi of Joseon Dynasty] are still posted on the websites of the “National Archives of Korea” and the “ National Archives of Korea, Government-General of Korea Records” without any verification or doubt. They are open to relevant researchers and even the general public. Thus, it is necessary for each website to correct the [Records of Gisaeng and Prostitute] based on items that are pointed out and corrected in this study and deliver and provide the correct and accurate information of the [Records of Gisaeng and Prostitute] to the public.
The Korean Society of Gyobang and Culture
Title: Academic Investigation and Correction of Error in [Bibliographic Study on Changgi of Joseon Dynasty] by Yang Taejin (1992): Focusing on Errors in [Records of Gisaeng and Prostitute]
Description:
This study used the resources and related data of the time to investigate various academic errors and distortions found in the [Bibliographic Study on Changgi of Joseon Dynasty] by Yang Taejin (1992), which is the first bibliographic study on the [Records of Gisaeng and Prostitute] and corrected the relevant errors.
The [Bibliographic Study on Changgi of Joseon Dynasty] considerably degenerates the fundamental characteristics of the [Records of Gisaeng and Prostitute] because it mixes “documents related to Gisaeng” and “documents related to prostitute” illogically, such as “prostitute quarter,” “Gisaeng,” “prostitute”, “forced prostitution,” “Gisaeng Control Document” by the Resident-General, “unofficial story,” and “a series of documents to control and monitor the Gisaeng in Seoul.
” The [Bibliographic Study on Changgi of Joseon Dynasty] also largely distorted the historical fact that the Gisaeng was a professional entertainer under the “Modern Gisaeng System” and that the prostitute was a professional prostitute under the “Licensed Prostitution System” when they were recorded in the [Records of Gisaeng and Prostitute] in the past.
Moreover, the academic errors and distortions of the [Bibliographic Study on Changgi of Joseon Dynasty] are still posted on the websites of the “National Archives of Korea” and the “ National Archives of Korea, Government-General of Korea Records” without any verification or doubt.
They are open to relevant researchers and even the general public.
Thus, it is necessary for each website to correct the [Records of Gisaeng and Prostitute] based on items that are pointed out and corrected in this study and deliver and provide the correct and accurate information of the [Records of Gisaeng and Prostitute] to the public.
Related Results
A Critical Review of Preceding Researches on [Records of Gisaeng and Changgi] and Correction of Academic Errors - Concentrating on [A Study on Gisaeng in Colonial Korea (II) : Focusing on Characteristics of Gisaeng Association] by Suh Jiyoung (2005)
A Critical Review of Preceding Researches on [Records of Gisaeng and Changgi] and Correction of Academic Errors - Concentrating on [A Study on Gisaeng in Colonial Korea (II) : Focusing on Characteristics of Gisaeng Association] by Suh Jiyoung (2005)
Among the researches that actively utilized bibliographies on [Records of Gisaeng and Changgi], this study concentrated on [A Study on Gisaeng in Colonial Korea (II) : Focusing on ...
A Study on Preceding Studies and Existing Bibliography on Records of Gisaeng and Changgi and the Colored Copy of 2022
A Study on Preceding Studies and Existing Bibliography on Records of Gisaeng and Changgi and the Colored Copy of 2022
This study explored “Preceding Studies” and “Existing Bibliography” that utilized the Records of Gisaeng and Changgi as well as “Recent Research Trends” that verified and corrected...
A Study on Establishment Process and Approval Date of the First Association of Women Artists in Korea, Hanseong Gisaeng Association : Focusing on Korean Records (8 Kinds of [Modern Newspapers] Published During Korean Empire Period)
A Study on Establishment Process and Approval Date of the First Association of Women Artists in Korea, Hanseong Gisaeng Association : Focusing on Korean Records (8 Kinds of [Modern Newspapers] Published During Korean Empire Period)
This study first examined the process of unrealized “Gisaeng Company” establishment plan, which had been initiated under the royal administrative reforms of November 1907. Then, th...
Nason Kim Dong-wook’s History of Gisaeng: Definition of ‘Giyeou/Gisaeng/changgi’
Nason Kim Dong-wook’s History of Gisaeng: Definition of ‘Giyeou/Gisaeng/changgi’
This article tried to define the concept of ‘Giyeou/Gisaeng/changgi’ focusing on Nason’s “Introduction to the history of Chosun Giyeou (Giyeou and Gisaeng)-A customs-historical app...
A Bibliographical Study on Records of Gisaeng and Changgi and It’s Value and Characteristics
A Bibliographical Study on Records of Gisaeng and Changgi and It’s Value and Characteristics
This study clarified the fundamental characteristics of the Records of Gisaeng and Changgi, which are frequently misunderstood and misread, examined related data ranging from four ...
A Study on the Bibliography of Documentation on Gisaeng and Changgi and the Domestic and Overseas Performance Activities of Gisaeng: Focusing on the gisaeng-related records composed in May 1910
A Study on the Bibliography of Documentation on Gisaeng and Changgi and the Domestic and Overseas Performance Activities of Gisaeng: Focusing on the gisaeng-related records composed in May 1910
In this study, a detailed and accurate analysis was conducted on the contents of these gisaeng-related documents while maintaining academic objectivity and neutrality, focusing on ...
Hanseong Gwonbeon and Gwonbeon Sijo in the Imperial Japan’s Forced Occupation Period
Hanseong Gwonbeon and Gwonbeon Sijo in the Imperial Japan’s Forced Occupation Period
The purpose of this study is to examine the establishment process of Hanseong Gwonbeon (government female entertainers guild) and Gwonbeon Sijo in the Imperial Japan’s forced occup...
A Study on the Bibliography of Records of Gisaeng and Changgi and the Beginning of Licensed Prostitution System by Japanese Resident-General: Focusing on the Prostitute-Related Documents Prepared From April to October, 1909
A Study on the Bibliography of Records of Gisaeng and Changgi and the Beginning of Licensed Prostitution System by Japanese Resident-General: Focusing on the Prostitute-Related Documents Prepared From April to October, 1909
This study targeted “Documents on Foundation Process of Hanseong Prostitute Association and Organizational Composition (April to October, 1909)” from (3) “Beginning of Licensed Pro...


