Theoretical framework and experimental solution for the air-water interface adsorption problem in cryoEM

Abstract As cryogenic electron microscopy (cryoEM) gains traction in the structural biology community as a method of choice for determining atomic structures of biological complexes, it has been increasingly recognized that many complexes that behave well under conventional negative-stain electron microscopy tend to have preferential orientation, aggregate or simply mysteriously “disappear” on cryoEM grids, but the reasons for such misbehavior are not well understood, limiting systematic approaches to solving the problem. Here, we have developed a theoretical formulation that explains these observations. Our formulation predicts that all particles migrate to the air-water interface (AWI) to lower the total potential surface energy — rationalizing the use of surfactant, which is a direct solution to reducing the surface tension of the aqueous solution. By conducting cryogenic electron tomography (cryoET) with the widely-tested sample, GroEL, we demonstrate that, in a standard buffer solution, nearly all particles migrate to the AWI. Gradual reduction of the surface tension by introducing surfactants decreased the percentage of particles exposed to the surface. By conducting single-particle cryoEM, we confirm that applicable surfactants do not damage the biological complex, thus suggesting that they might offer a practical, simple, and general solution to the problem for high-resolution cryoEM. Application of this solution to a real-world AWI adsorption problem with a more challenging membrane protein, namely, the ClC-1 channel, has led to its first near-atomic structure using cryoEM.