Javascript must be enabled to continue!
From Dialogue to Debate Argumentative and Epic Discourse in Mesopotamian Literature Between II and I Millennium BCE
View through CrossRef
Dialogical structures in the wisdom debate of the Babylonian Theodicy and in the epic of Erra and Išum are analysed comparing both the stylistic level and the main moral and theological issues the texts bring to the fore. Rhetorical and dialectical means appear to be deployed as tools for articulating subtle reasoning and arguments. They allow myth to be subjected to renewed reflection and reworking, deeply transforming epic narrative. This scenario suggests the emergence of a new figure of sage and literatus, particularly versed in the art of debate.
Fondazione Università Ca’ Foscari
Title: From Dialogue to Debate
Argumentative and Epic Discourse in Mesopotamian Literature Between II and I Millennium BCE
Description:
Dialogical structures in the wisdom debate of the Babylonian Theodicy and in the epic of Erra and Išum are analysed comparing both the stylistic level and the main moral and theological issues the texts bring to the fore.
Rhetorical and dialectical means appear to be deployed as tools for articulating subtle reasoning and arguments.
They allow myth to be subjected to renewed reflection and reworking, deeply transforming epic narrative.
This scenario suggests the emergence of a new figure of sage and literatus, particularly versed in the art of debate.
Related Results
Maailmakirjanduse mõõtmisest meil ja mujal / Conceptualizations of World Literature in Estonia and Elsewhere
Maailmakirjanduse mõõtmisest meil ja mujal / Conceptualizations of World Literature in Estonia and Elsewhere
Teesid: Artikkel käsitleb maailmakirjanduse mõiste mahu ja sisu muutumist alates selle esilekerkimisest 19. sajandi algupoolel kuni tänapäeva käsitlusviisideni ja dilemmadeni, mill...
Scholarly Tablet Collections in First-Millennium Assyria and Babylonia, c.700–200 BCE
Scholarly Tablet Collections in First-Millennium Assyria and Babylonia, c.700–200 BCE
The half-millennium 700–200 BCE was the heyday of the cuneiform ‘library’: Pedersén counts nearly forty of them from that period in his foundational book Libraries and Archives in ...
II. The history of Old Smyrna
II. The history of Old Smyrna
The occupational history of the site, like its name Smyrna, goes back beyond Hellenic times. The earliest observed prehistoric habitation, dating to the third millennium B.C., and ...
“Between the Mouth of the Two Rivers”
“Between the Mouth of the Two Rivers”
This contribution offers an anthropological view of holy waters, springs, sacred rivers, and trees in the ancient Mesopotamian religious framework. Water is omnipresent in Mesopota...
The Creative Dimension of Lay Thinking in the Case of the Representation of Democracy for Greek Youth
The Creative Dimension of Lay Thinking in the Case of the Representation of Democracy for Greek Youth
This article intends to make a contribution to the study of lay thinking on democracy and proposes a theoretical framework based on the notion of the `argumentative pole' that I ha...
THE MOSAIC VOICE IN "PARADISE LOST"
THE MOSAIC VOICE IN "PARADISE LOST"
ABSTRACT
A limited perception of Moses' relation to the epic narrator in Paradise Lost derives from the tendency to regard his brief role as hierophant in an early d...
Ordinary Man / Common Man: Conceptual Subject’ Projections of Everyday Discourse
Ordinary Man / Common Man: Conceptual Subject’ Projections of Everyday Discourse
This paper seeks to formalize the structures of everyday discourse. The search for factors ensuring the unity and autonomy of everyday discourse is based on the assumption that the...
The Archaeology of Nok Culture in Nigeria (2nd/1st Millennium BCE)
The Archaeology of Nok Culture in Nigeria (2nd/1st Millennium BCE)
The elaborate terracotta figurines of central Nigerian Nok culture date back to the early 1st millennium bce and represent the earliest large-size sculptural tradition in sub-Sahar...