Javascript must be enabled to continue!
DURABLE GOODS
View through CrossRef
ABSTRACTIn his thoughtful discussion of what makes some historical texts durable, lasting through time, Jaume Aurell arrives at the conclusion that these works show a balance between antiquarianism and presentism, and that this balance gives them a certain longevity of repute. Because, however, durability is a characteristic of the work, it seems to me problematic. Survival, rather than durability, appears to be the rubric we are discussing. It is not a characteristic of the work, any more than of a historical individual who survives a critical event like the French Revolution or the Holocaust. We identify survivors only retrospectively. A myriad of contingencies—time and chance—will obtain for any text to survive. Historiographical competition is ferocious, and worthy of study. Like Tolstoy's unhappy families, each historical text that fails to survive will have its own history. Why Gibbon and not Volney? We can adduce reasons, of course, but they are looks backward; in the late eighteenth century, no predictions were certain. Both Hayden White and Frank Ankersmit have, each in his own way, suggested the characteristics of the best histories. I believe they are mistaken, if best is to be taken to mean: most likely to survive. This is a characteristic of the ongoing reception of the work. As in an ongoing conversation, the historical work may advance the discourse, or contradict it, or change the subject. Whether it will have influence after the speaker has departed is up to those who remain and are added to the group. This rhetorical survival in the conversation is what is in question here. As such, it is profoundly historical, and not “beyond time.”
Title: DURABLE GOODS
Description:
ABSTRACTIn his thoughtful discussion of what makes some historical texts durable, lasting through time, Jaume Aurell arrives at the conclusion that these works show a balance between antiquarianism and presentism, and that this balance gives them a certain longevity of repute.
Because, however, durability is a characteristic of the work, it seems to me problematic.
Survival, rather than durability, appears to be the rubric we are discussing.
It is not a characteristic of the work, any more than of a historical individual who survives a critical event like the French Revolution or the Holocaust.
We identify survivors only retrospectively.
A myriad of contingencies—time and chance—will obtain for any text to survive.
Historiographical competition is ferocious, and worthy of study.
Like Tolstoy's unhappy families, each historical text that fails to survive will have its own history.
Why Gibbon and not Volney? We can adduce reasons, of course, but they are looks backward; in the late eighteenth century, no predictions were certain.
Both Hayden White and Frank Ankersmit have, each in his own way, suggested the characteristics of the best histories.
I believe they are mistaken, if best is to be taken to mean: most likely to survive.
This is a characteristic of the ongoing reception of the work.
As in an ongoing conversation, the historical work may advance the discourse, or contradict it, or change the subject.
Whether it will have influence after the speaker has departed is up to those who remain and are added to the group.
This rhetorical survival in the conversation is what is in question here.
As such, it is profoundly historical, and not “beyond time.
”.
Related Results
Designing a Durable Energy Policy
Designing a Durable Energy Policy
Although the U.S. energy system seems to resist the changes necessary to meet today's challenges related to energy security and climate change, the system has gone through massive ...
Durable mais inégalitaire : la ville
Durable mais inégalitaire : la ville
Cet article interroge des projets urbains qui semblent faire consensus dans les villes européennes (pénalisation du trafic automobile intra-urbain, encouragement du deux-roues moto...
Reason for Opposite Movement of GDP Deflator Inflation with CPI Inflation in Korea
Reason for Opposite Movement of GDP Deflator Inflation with CPI Inflation in Korea
Korea's CPI inflation reached 6.3% in Jul. 2022, the fastest increase since Nov. 1998. However, the quarterly GDP deflator inflation for the third quarter of 2022 was only 0.2% ove...
Marketplace Chokepoints
Marketplace Chokepoints
eBay and Taobao represent a different dimension of the private transnational anti-counterfeiting regime. These marketplaces are legally operating marketplaces in which some individ...
Le tourisme réflexif, un nouveau fondement d’un tourisme durable
Le tourisme réflexif, un nouveau fondement d’un tourisme durable
El desarrollo del turismo sostenible se enfrenta con la dificultad de utilizar un discurso contradictorio, y más en un contexto en el que se dan grandes concentraciones turísticas ...
in-Durable Sociality
in-Durable Sociality
This article considers the essential and unenduring attachments among grievously war-injured US soldiers remaking their lives at a military hospital. Their sense of being in common...
The centre of their life-world: the archaeology of experience at the Middle Yayoi cemetery of Tateiwa-Hotta, Japan
The centre of their life-world: the archaeology of experience at the Middle Yayoi cemetery of Tateiwa-Hotta, Japan
Social analysis of cemeteries has traditionally viewed them as static images of social organisation. In this study of the Middle Yayoi jar-burial cemetery of Tateiwa-Hotta, however...
Discussing moral goods and confronting research fetish: Review of “Fundamentals of research on culture and psychology: Theory and methods”
Discussing moral goods and confronting research fetish: Review of “Fundamentals of research on culture and psychology: Theory and methods”
We review Valery Chirkov’s “Fundamentals of research on culture and psychology: Theory and methods.” The book is written as a textbook, but clearly takes a position that work in cu...