Javascript must be enabled to continue!
The Battle of Smolensk in 1941 in Soviet and Modern Historiography
View through CrossRef
The article analyzes the state of historiography of the Battle of Smolensk in
1941. Although this issue has already been studied in Soviet historiography, a number of new studies have been published over the past two decades, and the active use
of previously closed archival documents, both Soviet and German, has begun. Photographic materials have become an important source of studying the battle. The author paid special attention to the analysis of the works of recent years. It was revealed
that in modern historiography several approaches to the assessment of the Battle of Smolensk have been portrayed. This is an exaggeration of the successes of the German troops, and, consequently, emphasizing the shortcomings and blunders of the
Soviet command, and even distorting individual episodes of events. This is especially true for works of a popular nature, and especially affecting the younger generation. At the same time, there were works whose authors strive to maintain objectivity while assessing events. A special issue in modern historiography is the question of the price that the Soviet people paid in order at least to suspend the offensive of German troops in the most important – Moscow strategic direction.
Title: The Battle of Smolensk in 1941 in Soviet and Modern Historiography
Description:
The article analyzes the state of historiography of the Battle of Smolensk in
1941.
Although this issue has already been studied in Soviet historiography, a number of new studies have been published over the past two decades, and the active use
of previously closed archival documents, both Soviet and German, has begun.
Photographic materials have become an important source of studying the battle.
The author paid special attention to the analysis of the works of recent years.
It was revealed
that in modern historiography several approaches to the assessment of the Battle of Smolensk have been portrayed.
This is an exaggeration of the successes of the German troops, and, consequently, emphasizing the shortcomings and blunders of the
Soviet command, and even distorting individual episodes of events.
This is especially true for works of a popular nature, and especially affecting the younger generation.
At the same time, there were works whose authors strive to maintain objectivity while assessing events.
A special issue in modern historiography is the question of the price that the Soviet people paid in order at least to suspend the offensive of German troops in the most important – Moscow strategic direction.
Related Results
Soviet Shipbuilding: Productivity improvement Efforts
Soviet Shipbuilding: Productivity improvement Efforts
Constant demand for new naval and commercial vessels has created special conditions for the Government-owned Soviet shipbuilding industry, which practically has not been affected b...
Smolensk in the Life and Work of N.I. Rylenkov
Smolensk in the Life and Work of N.I. Rylenkov
The article examines the part of Rylenkov's work in which the image of the
Smolensk region is created or touched upon. The main focus is on the poetic legacy of Nikolai Ivanovich....
From the Life of the Smolensk Writers' Organization:
the Almanac «Literary Smolensk»
From the Life of the Smolensk Writers' Organization:
the Almanac «Literary Smolensk»
The subject of the article is the almanac «Literary Smolensk», published in 1940–1957. «Literary Smolensk» is a unique poetic and prose platform for professionals and aspiring auth...
Impressions of Travelers Visiting Smolensk in the 1820s–1840s
Impressions of Travelers Visiting Smolensk in the 1820s–1840s
This article, based on personal sources such as letters (specifically correspondence between Grand Duke Alexander Nikolaevich and his father) and travelers’ notes (by Frenchman E. ...
Soviet Union in World War II
Soviet Union in World War II
The Soviet Union in World War II is the story of several wars. When World War II started, the Soviet Union was effectively an ally of Nazi Germany in a relatively conventional Euro...
Biography pages of Juozas Albinas Lukša-Daumantas 1940–1941
Biography pages of Juozas Albinas Lukša-Daumantas 1940–1941
The article examines some pages of the life history of the famous post-war partisan Juozas Albinas Lukša Daumantas (10 August 1921 – 4 September 1951) from 1940 through 1941 that h...
Number and Organization of the Smolensk Garrison in 1613–1618
Number and Organization of the Smolensk Garrison in 1613–1618
The aim of the article is to present the number and organisation the Smolensk garrison in the years 1613–1618. It was headed by Smolensk captains: Jerzy Szczucki (January 1613 – Oc...
Prisoners of the Great Army in the Smolensk Province in 1812–1814
Prisoners of the Great Army in the Smolensk Province in 1812–1814
During the Patriotic War of 1812, a significant number of military personnel of Napoleon’s Great Army were captured on the territory of the Smolensk province. Many of them later li...

