Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Prospective observational cohort study on grading the severity of postoperative complications in global surgery research
View through CrossRef
AbstractBackgroundThe Clavien–Dindo classification is perhaps the most widely used approach for reporting postoperative complications in clinical trials. This system classifies complication severity by the treatment provided. However, it is unclear whether the Clavien–Dindo system can be used internationally in studies across differing healthcare systems in high- (HICs) and low- and middle-income countries (LMICs).MethodsThis was a secondary analysis of the International Surgical Outcomes Study (ISOS), a prospective observational cohort study of elective surgery in adults. Data collection occurred over a 7-day period. Severity of complications was graded using Clavien–Dindo and the simpler ISOS grading (mild, moderate or severe, based on guided investigator judgement). Severity grading was compared using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). Data are presented as frequencies and ICC values (with 95 per cent c.i.). The analysis was stratified by income status of the country, comparing HICs with LMICs.ResultsA total of 44 814 patients were recruited from 474 hospitals in 27 countries (19 HICs and 8 LMICs). Some 7508 patients (16·8 per cent) experienced at least one postoperative complication, equivalent to 11 664 complications in total. Using the ISOS classification, 5504 of 11 664 complications (47·2 per cent) were graded as mild, 4244 (36·4 per cent) as moderate and 1916 (16·4 per cent) as severe. Using Clavien–Dindo, 6781 of 11 664 complications (58·1 per cent) were graded as I or II, 1740 (14·9 per cent) as III, 2408 (20·6 per cent) as IV and 735 (6·3 per cent) as V. Agreement between classification systems was poor overall (ICC 0·41, 95 per cent c.i. 0·20 to 0·55), and in LMICs (ICC 0·23, 0·05 to 0·38) and HICs (ICC 0·46, 0·25 to 0·59).ConclusionCaution is recommended when using a treatment approach to grade complications in global surgery studies, as this may introduce bias unintentionally.
Oxford University Press (OUP)
T E F Abbott
K E Greaves
A Patel
T Ahmad
J Haddow
E Futier
M Biais
K Slim
R M Pearse
Rupert M Pearse
Scott Beattie
Pierre-Alain Clavien
Nicolas Demartines
Lee A Fleisher
Mike Grocott
James Haddow
Andreas Hoeft
Peter Holt
Rui Moreno
Naomi Pritchard
Andrew Rhodes
Duminda Wijeysundera
Matt Wilson
Tahania Ahmed
Kirsty Everingham
Russell Hewson
Marta Januszewska
Rupert M Pearse
Mandeep-Kaur Phull
Richard Halliwell
Mark Shulman
Paul Myles
Werner Schmid
Michael Hiesmayr
Patrick Wouters
Stefan Hert
Suzana Lobo
Scott Beattie
Duminda Wijeysundera
Xiangming Fang
Lars Rasmussen
Emmanuel Futier
Matthieu Biais
Aurélien Venara
Karem Slim
Michael Sander
Despoina Koulenti
Kostoula Arvaniti
Mathew Chan
Atul Kulkarni
Susilo Chandra
Aida Tantri
Emad Geddoa
Muntadhar Abbas
Giorgio Della Rocca
Datin Sivasakthi
Marzida Mansor
Pastor Luna
Arthur Bouwman
Wolfgang Buhre
Vanessa Beavis
Douglas Campbell
Tim Short
Tunde Osinaike
Ricardo Matos
Ioana Grigoras
Mikhail Kirov
Denis Protsenko
Bruce Biccard
Cesar Aldecoa
Michelle Chew
Christoph Hofer
Martin Hubner
James Ditai
Tamas Szakmany
Lee Fleisher
Marissa Ferguson
Michael MacMahon
Mark Shulman
Ritchie Cherian
Helen Currow
Kathirgamanathan Kanathiban
David Gillespie
Edward Pathmanathan
Katherine Phillips
Jenifer Reynolds
Joanne Rowley
Jeanene Douglas
Ross Kerridge
Helen Currow
Sameer Garg
Michael Bennett
Megha Jain
David Alcock
Nico Terblanche
Rochelle Cotter
Kate Leslie
Marcelle Stewart
Nicolette Zingerle
Antony Clyde
Oliver Hambidge
Adam Rehak
Sharon Cotterell
Wilson Binh Quan Huynh
Timothy McCulloch
Erez Ben-Menachem
Thomas Egan
Jennifer Cope
Richard Halliwell
Paul Fellinger
Simone Haselberger
Caroline Holaubek
Paul Lichtenegger
Florian Scherz
Werner Schmid
Franz Hoffer
Veronika Cakova
Andreas Eichwalder
Norbert Fischbach
Reinhold Klug
Elisabeth Schneider
Martin Vesely
Reinhart Wickenhauser
Karl Gernot Grubmueller
Marion Leitgeb
Friedrich Lang
Nancy Toro
Marlene Bauer
Friedrich Laengle
Thomas Mayrhofer
Christian Buerkle
Karin Forstner
Reinhard Germann
Harald Rinoesl
Elke Schindler
Ernst Trampitsch
Gerhard Fritsch
Christian Szabo
Jawad Bidgoli
Hans Verdoodt
Patrice Forget
David Kahn
Fernande Lois
Mona Momeni
Caroline Prégardien
Audrey Pospiech
Arnaud Steyaert
Laurent Veevaete
Dirk De Kegel
Karen De Jongh
Luc Foubert
Carine Smitz
Marcel Vercauteren
Jan Poelaert
Veerle Van Mossevelde
Jacques Abeloos
Stefaan Bouchez
Marc Coppens
Luc De Baerdemaeker
Isabel Deblaere
Ann De Bruyne
Stefan De Hert
Kristine Fonck
Bjorn Heyse
Tom Jacobs
Koen Lapage
Anneliese Moerman
Martine Neckebroek
Aliaksandra Parashchanka
Nathalie Roels
Nancy Van Den Eynde
Michael Vandenheuvel
Jurgen Van Limmen
Ann Vanluchene
Caroline Vanpeteghem
Patrick Wouters
Piet Wyffels
Christel Huygens
Punitha Vandenbempt
Marc Van de Velde
Dimitri Dylst
Bruno Janssen
Evelien Schreurs
Fábia Berganton Aleixo
Keulle Candido
Hugo Dias Batista
Mario Guimarães
Jaqueline Guizeline
João Hoffmann
Suzana M Lobo
Francisco Ricardo Lobo
Vinícius Nascimento
Katia Nishiyama
Lucas Pazetto
Daniela Souza
Rodrigo Souza Rodrigues
Ana Maria Vilela Santos
Jaquelline Jardim
Joao Silva
Paulo Nascimento Junior
Thalissa Hermínia Baio
Gabriel Isaac Pereira Castro
Henri Roger Watanabe Oliveira
Cristina Prata Amendola
Gutemberg Cardoso
Daniela Ortega
Ana Flavia Brotto
Mirella Cristine De Oliveira
Álvaro Réa-Neto
Fernando Dias
Pedro Azambuja
Marcos Freitas Knibel
Antonio Martins
William Almeida
Calim Neder Neto
Maria Angela Tardelli
Eliana Caser
Marcio Machado
Crisitiano Aguzzoli
Sérgio Baldisserotto
Fernanda Beck Tabajara
Fernanda Bettega
La Hore Correa Rodrigues Júnior
Julia Gasperi
Lais Faina
Marcos Farias Nolasco
Bruna Ferreira Costa Fischer
Mariana Fosch Campos Ferreira
Cristina Hartmann
Marta Kliemann
Gustavo Luis Hubert Ribeiro
Julia Merladete Fraga
Thiago Motta Netto
Laura Valduga Pozza
Paulo Rafael Wendling
Caroline Azevedo
Juliana Garcia
Marcel Lopes
Bernardo Maia
Paula Maselli
Ralph Melo
Weslley Mendes
Matheus Neves
Jacqueline Ney
Claudio Piras
Christopher Applewhaite
Adrienne Carr
Lorraine Chow
Kaylene Duttchen
Julena Foglia
Michael Greene
Ashley Hinther
Kendra Houston
Thomas Jared McCormick
Jennifer Mikhayel
Sam Montasser
Alex Ragan
Andrew Suen
Adrianna Woolsey
Hai Chuan Yu
Duane Funk
Stephen Kowalski
Regina Legaspi
Heather McDonald
Faisal Siddiqui
Jeremy Pridham
Bernadette Rowe
Sonia Sampson
Barton Thiessen
Geoff Zbitnew
Andre Bernard
Ronald George
Philip Jones
Rita Moor
Naveed Siddiqui
Alexandra Wolfer
Diem Tran
Denyse Winch
Gary Dobson
Ashley Hinther
Thomas McCormick
Osama Montasser
Andrew Suen
Adrianna Woolsey
Andre Bernard
Ronald George
Richard Hall
Andre Bernard
Ronald George
Richard Hall
Christopher Applewhaite
Leyla Baghirzada
Thomas Jared McCormick
Andrew Suen
Si Yuan Dai
Gregory Hare
Esther Lee
Uma Shastri
Albert Tsui
Anmol Yagnik
Danielle Alvares
Stephen Choi
Heather Dwyer
Kathrina Flores
Colin McCartney
Priya Somascanthan
Scott Beattie
Jo Carroll
Janneth Pazmino-Canizares
Duminda Wijeysundera
Alexandra Wolfer
Noam Ami
Vincent Chan
Anahi Perlas
Ruth Argue
Katie Lavis
Kelly Mayson
Ying Cao
Hong Gao
Tingju Hu
Jie Lv
Jian Yang
Yang Yang
Yi Zhong
Jing Zhou
Xiaohua Zou
Miao He
Xiaoying Li
Dihuan Luo
Haiying Wang
Tian Yu
Liyong Chen
Lijun Wang
Yunfei Cai
Zhongming Cao
Yanling Li
Jiaxin Lian
Haiyun Sun
Sheng Wang
Zhipeng Wang
Kenru Wang
Yi Zhu
Xindan Du
Hao Fan
Yunbin Fu
Lixia Huang
Yanming Huang
Haifang Hwan
Hong Luo
Pi-Sheng Qu
Fan Tao
Zhen Wang
Guoxiang Wang
Shun Wang
Yan Zhang
Xiaolin Zhang
Chao Chen
Weixing Wang
Zhengyuan Liu
Lihua Fan
Jing Tang
Yijun Chen
Yongjie Chen
Yangyang Han
Changshun Huang
Guojin Liang
Jing Shen
Jun Wang
Qiuhong Yang
Jungang Zhen
Haidong Zhou
Junping Chen
Zhang Chen
Xiaoyu Li
Bo Meng
Haiwang Ye
Xiaoyan Zhang
Yanbing Bi
Jianqiao Cao
Fengying Guo
Hong Lin
Yang Liu
Meng Lv
Pengcai Shi
Xiumei Song
Chuanyu Sun
Yongtao Sun
Yuelan Wang
Shenhui Wang
Min Zhang
Rong Chen
Jiabao Hou
Yan Leng
Qing-tao Meng
Li Qian
Zi-ying Shen
Zhong-yuan Xia
Rui Xue
Yuan Zhang
Bo Zhao
Xian-jin Zhou
Qiang Chen
Huinan Guo
Yongqing Guo
Yuehong Qi
Zhi Wang
Jianfeng Wei
Weiwei Zhang
Lina Zheng
Qi Bao
Yaqiu Chen
Yijiao Chen
Yue Fei
Nianqiang Hu
Xuming Hu
Min Lei
Xiaoqin Li
Xiaocui Lv
Jie Lv
Fangfang Miao
Lingling Ouyang
Lu Qian
Conyu Shen
Yu Sun
Yuting Wang
Dong Wang
Chao Wu
Liyuan Xu
Jiaqi Yuan
Lina Zhang
Huan Zhang
Yapping Zhang
Jinning Zhao
Chong Zhao
Lei Zhao
Tianzhao Zheng
Dachun Zhou
Haiyan Zhou
Ce Zhou
Kaizhi Lu
Ting Zhao
Changlin He
Hong Chen
Shasha Chen
Baoli Cheng
Jie He
Lin Jin
Caixia Li
Hui Li
Yuanming Pan
Yugang Shi
Xiao Hong Wen
Shuijing Wu
Guohao Xie
Kai Zhang
Bing Zhao
Xianfu Lu
Feifei Chen
Qisheng Liang
Xuewu Lin
Yunzhi Ling
Gang Liu
Jing Tao
Lu Yang
Jialong Zhou
Fumei Chen
Yunlin Feng
Benchao Hou
Jiamei Lin
Mei Liu
Foquan Luo
Xiaoyun Shi
Yingfen Xiong
Lin Xu
Shuangjia Yang
Qin Zhang
Huaigen Zhang
Weihong Zhao
Weilu Zhao
Bai Yun
Linbi Chen
Sijia Chen
Qinxue Dai
Wujun Geng
Kunyuan Han
Xin He
Luping Huang
Binbin Ji
Danyun Jia
Shenhui Jin
Qianjun Li
Dongdong Liang
Shan Luo
Lulu Lwang
Yunchang Mo
Yuanyuan Pan
Xinyu Qi
Meizi Qian
Jinling Qin
Yelong Ren
Yiyi Shi
Junlu Wang
Junkai Wang
Leilei Wang
Junjie Xie
Yixiu Yan
Yurui Yao
Mingxiao Zhang
Jiashi Zhao
Xiuxiu Zhuang
Yanqiu Ai
Fang Du
Long He
Ledan Huang
Zhisong Li
Huijuan Li
Yetong Li
Liwei Li
Su Meng
Yazhuo Yuan
Enman Zhang
Jie Zhang
Shuna Zhao
Zhenrong Ji
Ling Pei
Li Wang
Chen Chen
Beibei Dong
Jing Li
Ziqiang Miao
Hongying Mu
Chao Qin
Lin Su
Zhiting Wen
Keliang Xie
Yonghao Yu
Fang Yuan
Xianwen Hu
Ye Zhang
Wangpin Xiao
Zhipeng Zhu
Qingqing Dai
Kaiwen Fu
Rong Hu
Xiaolan Hu
Song Huang
Yaqi Li
Yingping Liang
Shuchun Yu
Zheng Guo
Yan Jing
Na Tang
Jie Wu
Dajiang Yuan
Ruilin Zhang
Xiaoying Zhao
Yuhong Li
Hui-Ping Bai
Chun-Xiao Liu
Fei-Fei Liu
Wei Ren
Xiu-Li Wang
Guan-Jie Xu
Na Hu
Bo Li
Yangwen Ou
Yongzhong Tang
Shanglong Yao
Shihai Zhang
Cui-Cui Kong
Bei Liu
Tianlong Wang
Wei Xiao
Bo Lu
Yanfei Xia
Jiali Zhou
Fang Cai
Pushan Chen
Shuangfei Hu
Hongfa Wang
Jie Wu
Qiong Xu
Liu Hu
Liang Jing
Jing Li
Bin Li
Qiang Liu
Yuejiang Liu
Xinjian Lu
Zhen Dan Peng
Xiaodong Qiu
Quan Ren
Youliang Tong
Zhen Wang
Jin Wang
Yazhou Wen
Qiong Wu
Jiangyan Xia
Jue Xie
Xiapei Xiong
Shixia Xu
Tianqin Yang
Hui Ye
Ning Yin
Jing Yuan
Qiuting Zeng
Baoling Zhang
Kang Zheng
Jing Cang
Shiyu Chen
Fang Du
Yu Fan
Shuying Fu
Xiaodong Ge
Baolei Guo
Wenhui Huang
Linghui Jiang
Xinmei Jiang
Lin Jin
Yi Liu
Yan Pan
Yun Ren
Qi Shan
Jiaxing Wang
Fei Wang
Chi Wu
Xiaoguang Zhang
Ida Cecilie Christiansen
Simon Nørgaard Granum
Bodil Steen Rasmussen
Morten Daugaard
Rajiv Gambhir
Guðný Erla Steingrímsdóttir
Peter Jensen-Gadegaard
Karsten Skovgaard Olsen
Hanna Siegel
Katrine Zwicky Eskildsen
Mona Ring Gätke
Ida Wibrandt
Simon Bisgaard Heintzelmann
Kai Henrik Wiborg Lange
Rune Sarauw Lundsgaard
Louise Amstrup-Hansen
Claus Hovendal
Michael Larsen
Mette Lenstrup
Tina Kobborg
Jens Rolighed Larsen
Anette Barbre Pedersen
Jens Rolighed Larsen
Søren Hübertz Smith
Rebecca Monett Oestervig
Lars Rasmussen
Arash Afshari
Cheme Andersen
Kim Ekelund
Erik Lilja Secher
Birgitte Brandsborg
Helene Beloeil
Sigismond Lasocki
Aurélien Venara
Matthieu Biais
Alexandre Ouattara
Marlene Sineus
Serge Molliex
Marie Lim Legouge
Florent Wallet
Antoine Tesniere
Christophe Gaudin
Paul Lehur
Emma Forsans
Stéphane Rudnicki
Valerie Serra Maudet
Didier Mutter
Ghassan Sojod
Mehdi Ouaissi
Jean-Marc Regimbeau
Emmanuel Futier
Jacques Desbordes
Nicolas Comptaer
Diae Manser
Sabine Ethgen
Gilles Lebuffe
Patrick Auer
Christine Härtl
Maria Deja
Kirill Legashov
Susanne Sonnemann
Carola Wiegand-Loehnert
Elke Falk
Marit Habicher
Stefan Angermair
Beatrix Laetsch
Katrin Schmidt
Susanne Sonnemann
Christian Von Heymann
Axel Ramminger
Florian Jelschen
Svenja Pabel
Andreas Weyland
Elke Czeslick
Jochen Gille
Michael Malcharek
Armin Sablotzki
Katharina Lueke
Peter Wetzel
Joerg Weimann
Franz-Peter Lenhart
Florian Reichle
Frederike Schirmer
Michael Hüppe
Karl Klotz
Carla Nau
Julika Schön
Thomas Mencke
Christina Wasmund
Carla Bankewitz
Georg Baumgarten
Andreas Fleischer
Vera Guttenthaler
Yvonne Hack
Andreas Hoeft
Katharina Kirchgaessner
Olja Männer
Marlen Schurig-Urbaniak
Rafael Struck
Rebekka Zyl
Maria Wittmann
Ulrich Goebel
Sarah Harris
Siegfried Veit
Evangelia Andreadaki
Flora Souri
Ioannis Katsiadramis
Anthi Skoufi
Maria Vasileiou
Eleni Aimoniotou-Georgiou
Anastasios Katsourakis
Fotini Veroniki
Glyceria Vlachogianni
Konstantina Petra
Dimitra Chlorou
Eirini Oloktsidou
Vasileios Ourailoglou
Konstantinos Papapostolou
Georgia Tsaousi
Panagoula Daikou
Georgia Dedemadi
Ioannis Kalaitzopoulos
Christos Loumpias
Sotirios Bristogiannis
Nikolaos Dafnios
Georgios Gkiokas
Elissaios Kontis
Dimitra Kozompoli
Aspasia Papailia
Theodosios Theodosopoulos
Christol Bizios
Anastasia Koutsikou
Aleaxandra Moustaka
Ioannis Plaitakis
Apostolos Armaganidis
Theodora Christodoulopoulou
Mihail Lignos
Maria Theodorakopoulou
Andreas Asimakos
Eleni Ischaki
Angeliki Tsagkaraki
Spyros Zakynthinos
Eleni Antoniadou
Ioannis Koutelidakis
Dimitrios Lathyris
Irene Pozidou
Nikolaos Voloudakis
Maria Dalamagka
Elena Gkonezou
Christos Chronis
Dimitra Manolakaki
Dimitris Mosxogiannidis
Tatiana Slepova
Isaiasissy– Tsakiridou
Claire Lampiri Lampiri
Anastasia Vachlioti Vachlioti
Christos Panagiotakis Panagiotakis
Dimitrios Sfyras Sfyras
Fotios Tsimpoukas Tsimpoukas
Athanasia Tsirogianni
Elena Axioti
Andreas Filippopoulos
Elli Kalliafa
George Kassavetis
Petros Katralis
Ioannis Komnos
Georgios Pilichos
Ifigenia Ravani
Antonis Totis
Eymorfia Apagaki
Andromachi Efthymiadi
Nikolaos Kampagiannis
Theoniki Paraforou
Agoritsa Tsioka
Georgios Georgiou
Aristeidis Vakalos
Aggeliki Bairaktari
Efthimios Charitos
George Markou
Panagiota Niforopoulou
Nikolaos Papakonstantinou
Evdoxia Tsigou
Archontoula Xifara
Menelaos Zoulamoglou
Panagiota Gkioni
Stylianos Karatzas
Aikaterini Kyparissi
Efstratios Mainas
Ioannis Papapanagiotou
Theonymfi Papavasilopoulou
George Fragandreas
Eleni Georgopoulou
Eleni Katsika
Kyriakos Psarras
Eirini Synekidou
Maria Verroiotou
Evangelia Vetsiou
Donika Zaimi
Athina Anagnou
Konstantinos Apostolou
Theodora Melissopoulou
Theophilos Rozenberg
Christos Tsigris
Georgios Boutsikos
Vasileios Kalles
Nikolaos Kotsalas
Christina Lavdaiou
Fotini Paikou
Georgia-Laura Panagou
Anna Spring
Kostoula Arvaniti
Ioannis Botis
Maria Drimala
Georgios Georgakakis
Ellada Kiourtzieva
Panagiota Ntouma
Apostolos Prionas
Kyriakos Xouplidis
Eleftheria Dalampini
Chrysavgi Giannaki
Christina Iasonidou
Orestis Ioannidis
Athina Lavrentieva
Athena Lavrentieva
George Papageorgiou
Maria Kokkinoy
Maria Stafylaraki
Stylianos Gaitanakis
Periclis Karydakis
Josef Paltoglou
Panagiotis Ponireas
Panagiotis Chaloulis
Athanasios Provatidis
Anisoglou Sousana
Varvara Vanessa Gardikou
Maria Konstantivelli
Olga Lataniotou
Elisavet Lisari
Maria Margaroni
Konstantinos Stamatiou
Edouardos Nikolaidis
Ioannis Pnevmatikos
Eleni Sertaridou
Alexandros Andreou
Eleni Arkalaki
Elias Athanasakis
Fotini Chaniotaki
Aikaterini Chatzimichali
Maria Christofaki
Despina Dermitzaki
Klara Fiorentza
Georgios Frantzeskos
Elisavet Geromarkaki
Kalliopi Kafkalaki
Marina Kalogridaki
Konstyllia Karydi
Sofia Kokkini
Georgios Kougentakis
Tatiana Lefaki
Emmanouhl Lilitsis
Aikaterini Makatounaki
Polychronis Malliotakis
Dimosthenis Michelakis
Maria Neonaki
Vasileia Nyktari
Iliana Palikyra
Eleftherios Papadakis
Alexandra Papaioannou
Konstantinos Sfakianakis
Maria Sgouraki
Xenia Souvatzis
Anastasia Spartinou
Nefeli Stefanidou
Paulina Syrogianni
Georgia Tsagkaraki
Elena Arnaoutoglou
Christina Arnaoutoglou
Christina Bali
Vasilios Bouris
Rodamanthos Doumos
Konstantia-Paraskevi Gkini
Clio Kapaktsi
Vasilios Koulouras
Arian Lena
Dimitra Lepida
Evangelos Michos
Dimitrios Papadopoulos
Minas Paschopoulos
Vaia Aliki Rompou
Ioanna Siouti
Stavros Tsampalas
Ourania Ververidou
Georgios Zilis
Alexandra Charlalampidoy
Gregory Christodoulidis
Andreas Flossos
Konstantinos Stamoulis
Matthew Chan
Man Shing Caleb Tsang
Man Shing Tsang
Man Ling Lai
Chi Pang Yip
Hey Man Heymans Chan
Bassanio Law
Wing Sze Li
Hiu Man Chu
Emily Gar Yee Koo
Chi Cheong Joe Lam
Ka Ho Cheng
Matthew Chan
Tracy Lam
Susanna Chu
Man Ling Lai
Wing Yan Lam
Kin Wai Kevin Wong
Dilys Kwok
Ching Yue Janice Hung
Wai Kit Jacky Chan
Wing LamWong
Chun Kwong Eric Chung
Man Ling Lai
Shu Kai Ma
Shuchi Kaushik
Bhagyesh Shah
Dhiren Shah
Sanjay Shah
Praburaj Ar
Radhakrishnan Muthuchellappan
Vandana Agarwal
Jigeeshu Divatia
Atul Kulkarni
Sanghamitra Mishra
Ganesh Nimje
Swati Pande
Sukhada Savarkar
Aditi Shrivastava
Martin Thomas
Shashikant Yegnaram
Rahmat Hidayatullah
Susilo Chandra
Aida Tantri
Nasman Puar
Sumara Niman
Imai Indra
Zulkarnain Hamzah
Annika Yuliana
Ucu Nurhadiat Abidin
Ade Nurkacan Dursin
Andri Kurnia
Ade Susanti
Dini Handayani
Mahaalit Alit Aribawa
Aryabiantara Arya
Tjokorda Gde Agung Senapathi
Utara Hartawan Utara
Widnyana Made Wid
Semarawima Wima
Wiryana Made Wir
Brillyan Jehosua
Jonathan Kaunang
Eka Yudha Lantang
Rini Najoan
Neil Waworuntu
Hadi Awad
Akram Fuad
Emad Geddoa
Burair Geddoa
Abdel Razzaq Khalaf
Sabah Al Hussaini
Safauldeensalem Albaj
Maithem Kenber
Alessandra Bettinelli
Savino Spadaro
Carlo Alberto Volta
Luigi Giancarlo
Vicari Sottosanti
Giorgio Della Rocca
Lorenzo Spagnesi
Ilaria Toretti
Chiara Alloj
Silvano Cardellino
Livio Carmino
Eleonora Costanzo
Lucia Caterina Fanfani
Maria Teresa Novelli
Agostino Roasio
Mattia Bellandi
Luigi Beretta
Elena Bignami
Speranza Bocchino
Luca Cabrini
Daniele Corti
Giovanni Landoni
Roberta Meroni
Elena Moizo
Giacomo Monti
Margherita Pintaudi
Valentina Paola Plumari
Daiana Taddeo
Valentina Testa
Dario Winterton
Alberto Zangrillo
Luigi Maria Cloro
Chiara Colangelo
Antonio Colangelo
Giuseppe Rotunno
Miguel Paludi Angel
Cloro Paolo Maria
Antonio Pata
Vieri Parrini
Alessandro Gatta
Mauro Nastasi
Carla Tinti
Lorenzo Spagnesi
Mario Arrigo
Angelo Benevento
Corrado Bottini
Maurizio Cannavo
Christian Gastaldi
Alessandro Marchesi
Angelantonio Pascazio
Francesco Pata
Emilio Pozzi
Alberto Premoli
Gaetano Tessera
Luca Boschi
Rocco D'Andrea
Federico Ghignone
Gilberto Poggioli
Andrea Sibilio
Mario Taffurelli
Giampaolo Ugolini
Mohd Azuan Ab Majid
Rusnah Ab Rahman
James Joseph
Furquan Pathan
Mohammad Hafizshah Sybil Shah
Huey Ling Yap
Seleen Cheah
Im Im Chin
Ji Keon Looi
Siew Ching Tan
Sheshendrasurian Visvalingam
Fan Yin Kwok
Chew Kiok Lee
Tse Siang Tan
Sze Meng Wong
Noor Hairiza Abdullah
Chiat Fong Liew
Lovenia Luxuman
Nor Hafizah Mohd Zin
Muhamad Faiz Norddin
Raja Liza Raja Alias
Juan Yong Wong
Johnny Yong
Mohd Tarmimi Bin Mustapha
Weng Ken Chan
Norizawati Dzulkipli
Pei Xuan Kuan
Yew Ching Lee
Anita Alias
Eng Ching Guok
Chiun Chen Jee
Brian Rhadamantyne Ramon
Cheng Wong Weng
Fara Nur Idayu Abd Ghafar
Faizal Zuhri Aziz
Nabilah Hussain
Hooi Sean Lee
Ismawaty Sukawi
Yuan Liang Woon
Husni Zaeem Abd Hadi
Ummi Azmira Ahmad Azam
Abdul Hafiz Alias
Saiful Aizar Kesut
Jun May Lee
Dar Vin Ooi
Hetty Ayuni Sulaiman
Tengku Alini Tengku Lih
Marzida Mansor
Jeyaganesh Veerakumaran
Pastor Luna
Eder Rojas
Gerardo Esteban Alvarez Resendiz
Darcy Danitza Mari Zapata
Julio Cesar Jesús Aguilar López
Armando Adolfo Alvarez Flores
Juan Carlos Bravo Amador
Erendira Jocelin Dominguez Avila
Laura Patricia González Aquino
Ricardo Lopez Rodriguez
Mariana Torres Landa
Emma Urias
Markus Hollmann
Abraham Hulst
Osne Kirzner
Benedikt Preckel
Ankie Koopman-van Gemert
Arthur Bouwman
Marc Buise
Noortje Tolenaar
Eric Weber
Jennifer Fretes
Peter Houweling
Patricia Ormskerk
Jasper Van Bommel
Wolfgang Buhre
Marcus Lance
Valerie Smit-Fun
Tom Zundert
Peter Baas
Hans Donald Boer
Joost Sprakel
Renske Elferink-Vonk
Peter Noordzij
Laura Zeggeren
Bastiaan Brand
Rob Spanjersberg
Janneke Bokkel-Andela
Sandra Numan
Wilton Klei
Bas Zaane
Christa Boer
Yoni Duivenvoorde
Jens Peter Hering
Harry Zonneveldt
Doug Campbell
Siobhan Hoare
Sahayam Santa
Sara Jane Allen
Vanessa Beavis
Rachel Bell
Hyun-min David Choi
Matthew Drake
Helen Farrell
Kushlin Higgie
Kerry Holmes
Nicole Jenkins
Chang Joon Kim
Steven Kim
Kiew Chai Law
Davina McAllister
Karen Park
Karen Pedersen
Leesa Pfeifer
Timothy Salmond
Martin Steynor
Michael Tan
Ellen Waymouth
Ahmad Sufian Ab Rahman
John Armstrong
Rosie Dudson
Nia Jenkins
Jayashree Nilakant
Seigne Richard
Pardeep Virdi
Liane Dixon
Roana Donohue
Mehreen Farrow
Ross Kennedy
Henderson Marissa
Margie McKellow
Delany Nicola
Rebecca Pascoe
Stephen John Roberts
George Rowell
Matthew Sumner
Paul Templer
Shardha Chandrasekharan
Graham Fulton
Ib Jammer
Marlynn Ali
Richard More
Leona Wilson
Yuan Hsuan Chang
Julia Foley
Carolyn Fowler
Jonathan Panckhurst
Rachel Sara
Francois Stapelberg
Doug Campbell
Veronica Cherrett
Donna Louise Ganter
Davina McAllister
Lloyd McCann
Julia Foley
Fiona Gilmour
Rachelle Lumsden
Mark Moores
Sue Olliff
Elitza Sardareva
Francois Stapelberg
Joyce Tai
Matthew Wikner
Christopher Wong
Mark Chaddock
Carolyn Czepanski
Patrick McKendry
Daniel Polakovic
Daniel Polakovich
Axe Robert
Margarita Tormo Belda
Tracy Norton
Francois Stapelberg
Fadhel Alherz
Lisa Barneto
Alberto Ramirez
Ahmed Sayeed
Nicola Smith
Cambell Bennett
Shane McQuoid
Rachel Bell
Tracy-Lee Jansen
Zin Nico
John Scott
David Freschini
Angela Freschini
Brian Hopkins
Lara Manson
Deon Stoltz
Alexander Bates
Simon Davis
Victoria Freeman
Lynette McGaughran
Swarna Baskar Sharma
Tom Burrows
Kelly Byrne
Duane English
Robert Johnson
Kiew Chai Law
Brendon Manikkam
Davina McAllister
Shaun Naidoo
Margot Rumball
Nicola Whittle
Romilla Franks
Hannah Gibson-Lapsley
Davina McAllister
Ryan Salter
Dean Walsh
Richard Cooper
Katherine Perry
Amos Obobolo
Umar Musa Sule
Abdurrahman Ahmad
Mamuda Atiku
Alhassan Datti Mohammed
Adamu Muhammad Sarki
Oyebola Adekola
Olanrewaju Akanmu
Adekunle Durodola
Olusegun Olukoju
Victor Raji
Tokunbo Olajumoke
Emmanuel Oyebamiji
Anthony Adenekan
Adedapo Adetoye
Folayemi Faponle
Simeon Olateju
Afolabi Owojuyigbe
Ademola Talabi
Odewabi Adenike
Badru Adewale
Nwokoro Collins
Emmanuel Ezekiel
Oluwabunmi Motunrayo Fatungase
Anuforo Grace
Sotannde Sola
Ogunmuyiwa Stella
Adeyinka Ademola
Augustine A Adeolu
Tinuola Adigun
Mukaila Akinwale
Oluyemi Fasina
Olalere Gbolahan
Olusola Idowu
Rotimi Peter Olonisakin
Babatunde Babasola Osinaike
Felicia Asudo
Danladi Mshelia
Lukman Abdur-Rahman
Olayide Agodirin
Jibril Bello
Benjamin Bolaji
Olanrewaju Olubukola Oyedepo
Humphrey Ezike
Ikechukwu Iloabachie
Ikemefuna Okonkwo
Elias Onuora
Tonia Onyeka
Innocent Ugwu
Friday Umeh
Olubusola Alagbe-Briggs
Amabra Dodiyi-Manuel
Richard Echem
Bright Obasuyi
Bisola Onajin-Obembe
Maria Expedito Bandeira
Alda Martins
Miguel Tomé
Ana Cristina Miranda Martins Costa
Andriy Krystopchuk
Teresa Branco
Simao Esteves
Marco António Melo
Júlia Monte
Fernando Rua
Isabel Martins
Vítor Miguel Pinho-Oliveira
Carla Maria Rodrigues
Raquel Cabral
Sofia Marques
Sara Rêgo
Joana Sofia Teixeira Jesus
Maria Conceição Marques
Cristina Romao
Sandra Dias
Ana Margarida Santos
Maria Joao Alves
Cristina Salta
Salome Cruz
Célia Duarte
António Armando Furtado Paiva
Tiago Nascimento Cabral
Dionisio Faria E Maia
Rui Freitas Mendonça Correia Silva
Anuschka Langner
Hernâni Oliveira Resendes
Maria Conceição Soares
Alexandra Abrunhosa
Filomena Faria
Lina Miranda
Helena Pereira
Sofia Serra
Daniela Ionescu
Simona Margarit
Calin Mitre
Horatiu Vasian
Gratiela Manga
Andreea Stefan
Dana Tomescu
Daniela Filipescu
Marilena-Alina Paunescu
Mihai Stefan
Radu Stoica
Laura Gavril
Emilia PĂtrĂșcanu
Irina Ristescu
Daniel Rusu
Ciresica Diaconescu
Gabriel Florin Iosep
Dorin Pulbere
Irina Ursu
Andreea Balanescu
Ioana Grintescu
Liliana Mirea
Irina Rentea
Mihaela Vartic
Mary-Nicoleta Lupu
Dorin Stanescu
Lavinea Streanga
Oana Antal
Natalia Hagau
Dumitru Patras
Cristina Petrisor
Flaviu Tosa
Sebastian Tranca
Sanda Maria Copotoiu
Liviu Lucian Ungureanu
Cristian Remus Harsan
Marius Papurica
Daniela Denisa Cernea
Nicoleta Alice Dragoescu
Laura Aflori
Carmen Vaida
Oana Roxana Ciobotaru
Mariana Aignatoaie
Cristina Paula Carp
Isabelle Cobzaru
Oana Mardare
Bianca Purcarin
Valentin Tutunaru
Victor Ionita
Mirela Arustei
Anisoara Codita
Mihai Busuioc
Ion Chilinciuc
Cristina Ciobanu
Ioana Belciu
Eugen Tincu
Mihaela Blaj
Ramona–Mihaela Grosu
Gigel Sandu
Dana Bruma
Dan Corneci
Madalina Dutu
Adriana Krepil
Elena Copaciu
Clementina Oana Dumitrascu
Ramona Jemna
Florentina Mihaescu
Raluca Petre
Cristina Tudor
Elena Ursache
Alexander Kulikov
Andrey Lubnin
Evgeny Grigoryev
Stanislav Pugachev
Denis Protsenko
Alexander Tolmasov
Ayyaz Hussain
Yana Ilyina
Mikhail Kirov
Anna Roshchina
Aleksandr Iurin
Elena Chazova
Artem Dunay
Alexey Karelov
Irina Khvedelidze
Olga Voldaeva
Vladislav Belskiy
Parvin Dzhamullaev
Elena Grishkowez
Vladimir Kretov
Valeriy Levin
Aleksandr Molkov
Sergey Puzanov
Aleksandr Samoilenko
Aleksandr Tchekulaev
Valentina Tulupova
Ivan Utkin
Nikki Leigh Allorto
David Gray Bishop
Pierre Monji Builu
Carel Cairns
Ashish Dasrath
Jacques Wet
Marielle Hoedt
Ben Grey
Morgan Philip Hayes
Belinda Senta Küsel
Nomcebo Shangase
Robert Wise
Sharon Cacala
Zane Farina
Vishendran Govindasamy
Carl-Heinz Kruse
Carolyn Lee
Leonard Marais
Thinagrin Dhasarthun Naidoo
Chantal Rajah
Reitze Nils Rodseth
Lisa Ryan
Richard Rhaden
Suwayba Adam
Christella Alphonsus
Yusuf Ameer
Frank Anderson
Sujith Basanth
Sudha Bechan
Chettan Bhula
Bruce M Biccard
Thuli Biyase
Ines Buccimazza
Jorge Cardosa
James Chen
Bhavika Daya
Leanne Drummond
Ali Elabib
Ehab Helmy Abdel Goad
Ismail E Goga
Riaz Goga
R Harrichandparsad
Richard E Hodgson
J Jordaan
Nicky Kalafatis
Christian Kampik
A T Landers
Emil Loots
Rajhmum Madansein
Anil Madaree
Thandinkosi E Madiba
Vukani T Manzini
Mbali Mbuyisa
Rajan Moodley
Mduduzi Msomi
Innocent Mukama
Desigan Naidoo
Rubeshan Naidoo
Tesuven K Naidu
Sindiswa Ntloko
Eneshia Padayachee
Lucelle Padayachee
Martijn Phaff
Bala Pillay
Desigan Pillay
Lutchmee Pillay
Anupa Ramnarain
Suren R Ramphal
Paul Ryan
Ahmed Saloojee
Motshedisi Sebitloane
Noluyolo Sigcu
Jenna L Taylor
Alexandra Torborg
Linda Visser
Philip Anderson
Alae Conradie
Mathew Swardt
Martin Villiers
Johan Eikman
Riaan Liebenberg
Johan Mouton
Abbey Paton
Louwrence Merwe
Candice Wilscott-Davids
Wendy Joan Barrett
Marlet Bester
Johan Beer
Jacques Geldenhuys
Hanni Gouws
Jan-Hendrik Potgieter
Magdel Strydom
Edwin Wilberforce-Turton
Rubendraj R Chetty
Subash Chirkut
Larissa Cronje
Kim Vasconcellos
Nokukhanya Z Dube
N Sibusiso Gama
Garyth M Green
Randolph Green-Thompson
Suman Mewa Kinoo
Prenolin Kistnasami
Kapil Maharaj
Manogaran S Moodley
Sibongile J Mothae
Ruvashni Naidoo
M Aslam
F Noorbhai
Vivesh Rughubar
Jenendhiran Reddy
Avesh Singh
David L Skinner
Murray J Smith
Bhagwan Singh
Ravi Misra
Maheshwar Naidoo
Pireshin Ramdharee
Yvonne Selibea
Selina Sewpersad
Shailendra Sham
Joseph D Wessels
Cucu Africander
Tarek Bejia
Stephen P Blakemore
Marisa Botes
Bimalshakth Bunwarie
Carlos B Hernandez
Mohammud A Jeeraz
Dagmara A Legutko
Acela G Lopez
Jenine N De Meyer
Tanaka Muzenda
Noel Naidoo
Maryam Patel
Rao Pentela
Marina Junge
Naj Mansoor
Lana Rademan
Pawel Scislowski
Ismail Seedat
Bianca Berg
Doreen Merwe
Steyn Wyk
Komalan Govender
Darshan Naicker
Rajesh Ramjee
Mueen Saley
Warren Paul Kuhn
Roel Matos-Puig
Zaheer Moolla
Alberto Lisi
Gisela Perez
Anna Valle Beltran
Angels Lozano
Carlos Delgado Navarro
Alejandro Duca
Ernesto Pastor Martinez
Carlos Ferrando
Isabel Fuentes
Maria Luisa García-Pérez
Estefania Gracia
Ana Izquierdo Palomares
Antonio Katime
Amanda Miñana
Raul Incertis
Esther Romero
Carolina Soledad Romero Garcia
Concepcion Rubio
Tania Socorro Artiles
Marina Soro
Paola Valls
Gisela Alaman Laguarda
Pau Benavent
Vicente Chisbert Cuenca
Andreu Cueva
Matilde Lafuente
Asuncion Marques Parra
Alejandra Romero Rodrigo
Silvia Sanchez-Morcillo
Sergi Tormo
Francisco Javier Redondo
Jose De Andres
Lorena Gómez Diago
Maria José Hernández Cádiz
Granell Gil Manuel
Raquel Peris
Cristina Saiz
Jose Tatay
Maria Teresa Tebar Soto
Tamara Brunete
David Cancho
David R Delgado García
Diana Zamudio
Santiago Garcia Del Valle
M Luz Serrano
Eduardo Alonso
Victor Anillo
Emilio Maseda
Patricia Salgado
Luis Suarez
Alejandro Suarez-de-la-Rica
María José Villagrán
Cesar Aldecoa
José Ignacio Alonso
Estefania Cabezuelo
Irene Garcia-Saiz
Olga Lopez Moral
Silvia Martín
Alba Perez Gonzalez
Sherezade Tovar Doncel
Martin Agüero Vera
Francisco José Ávila Sánchez
Beatriz Castaño
Beatriz Castaño Moreira
Sahely Flores Risco
Daniel Paz Martín
Fernando Pérez Martín
Paloma Poza
Adela Ruiz
Wilson Fabio Serna Martínez
Bárbara Vázquez Vicente
Saul Velaz Dominguez
Salvador Fernández
Alfonso Munoz-López
Maria Jose Bernat
Arantxa Mas
Kenneth Planas
Monir Jawad
Yousif Saeed
Annika Hedin
Helena Levander
Michelle Chew
Sandra Holmström
David Lönn
Frank Zoerner
Irene åkring
Carl Widmark
Jan Zettergren
Victor Aspelund Liljequist
Lena Nystrom
Suzanne Odeberg-Wernerman
Anders Oldner
Patrik Reje
Sara Lyckner
Jesper Sperber
Anne Adolfsson
Bengt Klarin
Annika Hedin
Katrin Ögren
Jean-Pierre Barras
Thomas Bührer
Vasileios Despotidis
Naeder Helmy
Stephan Holliger
Dimitri Aristotle Raptis
Roger Schmid
Antoine Meyer
Yves Jaquet
Ulf Kessler
Mirza Muradbegovic
Solange R Nahum
Teresa Rotunno
Boris Schiltz
François Voruz
Marc Worreth
Dimitri Christoforidis
Sotirios Georgios Popeskou
Markus Furrer
Gian Andrea Prevost
Andrea Stocker
Klaus Lang
Stefan Breitenstein
Michael T Ganter
Martin Geisen
Christopher Soll
Michelle Korkmaz
Iris Lubach
Michael Schmitz
Moritz Meyer Zu Schwabedissen
Urs Zingg
Thomas Hillermann
Stefan Wildi
Christoph Hofer
Bernardo Bollen Pinto
Bernhard Walder
Martin Hübner
Giustina Mariotti
Ksenija Slankamenac
Mirioce Namuyuga
Edward Kyomugisha
Olivia Kituuka
Anne Wesonga Shikanda
Nasser Kakembo
Charles Otim Tom
Antonina Webombesa
Emmanuel Bua
James Ditai
Eden Michael Ssettabi
Joseph Epodoi
Fiona Kabagenyi
Fred Kirya
Ged Dempsey
Colette Seasman
Raja Basit Nawaz Khan
Claire Kurasz
Mark Macgregor
Burhan Shawki
Vimal Hariharan
Simon Chau
Kate Ellis
Georgina Butt
Dennis-Wayne Chicken
Natasha Christmas
Samantha Allen
Gayatri Daniel Daniel
Angie Dempster
Juliette Kemp
Lewis Matthews
Philip Mcglone
Joanne Tambellini
Dawn Trodd
Katie Freitas
Atul Garg
Shilpaja Karpate
Aditi Kulkarni
Chloe O'Hara
Jtroko Troko
Kirsty Angus
Jacqueline Bradley
Emma Brennan
Carolyn Brooks
Janette Brown
Gemma Brown
Amanda Finch
Karen Gratrix
Sue Hesketh
Gillian Hill
Carol Jeffs
Maureen Morgan
Chris Pemberton
Nicola Slawson
Helen Spickett
Gemma Swarbrick
Megan Thomas
Greta Van Duyvenvoorde
Andrew Brennan
Richard Briscoe
Sarah Cooper
Tom Lawton
Martin Northey
Rashmi Senaratne
Helen Stanworth
Lorna Burrows
Helen Cain
Rachael Craven
Keith Davies
Attila Jonas
Marcin Pachucki
Graham Walkden
Helen Davies
Mariethel Gudaca
Maria Hobrok
Dilshan Arawwawala
Lauren Fergey
Matthew Gardiner
Jacqueline Gunn
Lyndsay Johnson
Amanda Lofting
Amanda Lyle
Fiona Mc Neela
Susan Smolen
Joanne Topliffe
Sarah Williams
Martin Bland
Vikas Kaura
Prasad Lanka
Chardé Naylor
Neil Smith
Ahmed Ahmed
John Myatt
Ravikiran Shenoy
Wai Cheong Soon
Jessica Tan
Sunny Karadia
James Self
Emma Durant
Shiva Tripathi
Clare Bullock
Debbie Campbell
Alison Ghosh
Thomas Hughes
Lajos Zsisku
Sheshagiri Bengeri
Amanda Cowton
Mohammed Shazad Khalid
James Limb
Colin McAdam
Mandy Porritt
M Amir Rafi
Priya Shekar
Catherine Harden
Heidi Hollands
Angela King
Linda March
Gary Minto
Abigail Patrick
Darren Waugh
Paramesh Kumara
Karen Simeson
Jamie Yarwood
Julie Browning
Jonathan Hatton
Howes Julian
Atideb Mitra
Maria Newton
Pawan Kootelu Pernu
Alison Wilson
Thelma Commey
Helen Foot
Lyn Glover
Ajay Gupta
Nicola Lancaster
Jill Levin
Felicity Mackenzie
Claire Mestanza
Emma Nofal
Lauren Pout
Rosanna Varden
Jonathan Wild
Stephanie Jones
Sarah Moreton
Mark Pulletz
Charlotte Davies
Matthew Martin
Sian Thomas
Karen Burns
Carol McArthur
Panna Patel
Gary Lau
Natalie Rich
Fiona Davis
James Self
Rachel Lyons
Beth Port
Rachel Prout
Christopher Smith
Yemi Adelaja
Victoria Bennett
Heena Bidd
Alexandra Dumitrescu
Jacqui Fox Murphy
Abigail Keen
Nhlanhla Mguni
Cheng Ong
George Adams
Piers Boshier
Richard Brown
Izabella Butryn
Jayanta Chatterjee
Alexander Freethy
Geoffrey Lockwood
Maria Tsakok
Sophia Tsiligiannis
William Peat
Lorraine Stephenson
Mike Bradburn
Sara Pick
Pedro Cunha
Olufemi Olagbaiye
Salim Tayeh
Caroline Abernethy
Madhu Balasubramaniam
Rachael Bennett
David Bolton
Victoria Martinson
Charde Naylor
Neil Smith
Stephanie Bell
Blaylock Heather
Vlad Kushakovsky
Liam Alcock
Hazel Alexander
Colette Anderson
Paul Baker
Morag Brookes
Louise Cawthorn
Emanuel Cirstea
Kerry Colling
Ian Coulter
Suparna Das
Kathryn Haigh
Alhafidz Hamdan
Keith Hugill
Lucksy Kottam
Emily Lisseter
Matthew Mawdsley
Julie McGivern
Krishnaveni Padala
Victoria Phelps
Vineshykaa Ramesh Kumar
Kirsten Stewart
Kayley Towse
Julie Tregonning
Ali Vahedi
Alycon Walker
Duncan Baines
Anjali Bilolikar
Shiv Chande
Edward Copley
Nigel Dunk
Raghavendra Kulkarni
Pawan Kumar
Yavor Metodiev
Dumisani Ncomanzi
Bhavesh Raithatha
Parizade Raymode
Jan Szafranski
Linda Twohey
Philip Watt
Lucie Weatherall
J Weatherill
Zoe Whitman
Elinor Wighton
Chamika Abayasinghe
Alexander Chan
Sharif Darwish
James Gill
Emma Glasgow
Daniel Hadfield
Clair Harris
Arun Kochhar
Clare Mellis
Andrew Pool
Paul Riozzi
Andrew Selman
Emma-Jane Smith
Liana Vele
Yuksel Gercek
Kramer Guy
Douglas Holden
Nicholas Watson
Karen Whysall
Prematie Andreou
Dawn Hales
Jonathan Thompson
Sarah Bowrey
Shara McDonald
Jonathan Thompson
Jemma Gilmore
Vicky Hills
Chan Kelly
Sinead Kelly
Geraint Lloyd
Tom Abbott
Lewis Gall
Hew Torrance
Mark Vivian
Emer Berntsen
Tracey Nolan
Angus Turner
Akbar Vohra
Andrew Brown
Richard Clark
Elaine Coughlan
Conway Daniel
Chinmay Patvardhan
Rachel Pearson
Sheba Predeep
Hesham Saad
Mohanakrishnan Shanmugam
Simon Varley
Akbar Vohra
Katharine Wylie
Lucy Cooper
Arystarch Makowski
Beata Misztal
Eliza Moldovan
Claire Pegg
Andrew Donovan
Jayne Foot
Simon Large
Andrew Claxton
Bhagyashree Netke
Richard Armstrong
Claire Calderwood
Andy Kwok
Otto Mohr
Peter Oyeniyi
Lisa Patnaik
Benjamin Post
Sarah Ali
Homa Arshad
Gerard Baker
Laura Brenner
Maximilian Brincat
Annemarie Brunswicker
Hannah Cox
Octavian Ionut Cozar
Alexander Durst
Lior Fengas
Jim Flatt
Georgina Glister
Vishal Narwani
Evangelos Photi
Adeline Rankin
Melissa Rosbergen
Mark Tan
Ceri Beaton
Rachel Horn
Jane Hunt
Guy Rousseau
Lucia Stancombe
Mohammed Absar
Joanne Allsop
Zoe Drinkwater
Tracey Hodgkiss
Kirsty Smith
Jamie Brown
Sara Pick
Farhad Alexander-Sefre
Lorraine Campey
Lucy Dudgeon
Kathryn Hall
Rachael Hitchcock
Lynne James
Kate Smith
Ulrika Winstone
Norfaizan Ahmad
Kris Bauchmuller
Jonathan Harrison
Holly Jeffery
Duncan Miller
Angela Pinder
Sailaja Pothuneedi
Jonathan Rosser
Sumayer Sanghera
Diane Swift
Rachel Walker
Delia Bester
Sarah Cavanagh
Heather Cripps
Harvey Daniel
Julie Lynch
Alison Paton
Shirley Pyke
John Scholefield
Helen Whitworth
Fiona Bottrill
Ganesh Ramalingam
Stephen Webb
Nik Akerman
Philip Antill
Lynsey Bourner
Sarah Buckley
Gail Castle
Rob Charles
Christopher Eggleston
Rebecca Foster
Satwant Gill
Kate Lindley
Mohamed Lklouk
Tracey Lowery
Oliver Martin
David Milne
Patrick O'Connor
Andrew Ratcliffe
Alastair Rose
Karen Simeson
Annie Smith
Sandeep Varma
Jackie Ward
Karen Simeson
Helena Barcraft-Barnes
Julie Camsooksai
Carolyn Colvin
Henrik Reschreiter
Lee Tbaily
Nicola Venner
Caroline Hamilton
Lewis Kelly
Piroska Toth-Tarsoly
Kerry Dodsworth
Denise Foord
Paul Gordon
Elizabeth Hawes
Nikki Lamb
Johanna Mouland
Jeremy Nightingale
Steve Rose
Joe Schrieber
Khalid Al Amri
Hafiz Aladin
Mohammed Asif Arshad
James Barraclough
Conor Bentley
Colin Bergin
Ronald Carrera
Aisling Clarkson
Michelle Collins
Lauren Cooper
Samuel Denham
Ewen Griffiths
Peter Ip
Somasundaram Jeyanthan
Kavita Joory
Satwant Kaur
Paul Marriott
Natalie Mitchell
Sukumar Nagaiah
Annette Nilsson
Nilesh Parekh
Martin Pope
Joseph Seager
Hosam Serag
Alifia Tameem
Anna Thomas
Joanne Thunder
Andrew Torrance
Ravinder Vohra
Arlo Whitehouse
Tony Wong
Mark Blunt
Kate Wong
Julian Giles
Isabelle Reed
Debbie Weller
Gillian Bell
Julie Birch
Rose Damant
Jane Maiden
Clare Mewies
Claire Prince
Jane Radford
Birender Balain
Robin Banerjee
Andrew Barnett
Ben Burston
Kirsty Davies
Jayne Edwards
Chris Evans
David Ford
Pete Gallacher
Simon Hill
David Jaffray
Sudheer Karlakki
Cormac Kelly
Julia Kennedy
Nigel Kiely
Simon Lewthwaite
Chris Marquis
Matthew Ockendon
Stephen Phillips
Simon Pickard
James Richardson
Richard Roach
Tony Smith
Richard Spencer-Jones
Niall Steele
Julie Steen
Marck Van Liefland
Steve White
Matthew Faulds
Meredyth Harris
Carrie Kelly
Scott Nicol
Sally Anne Pearson
Srikanth Chukkambotla
Alyson Andrew
Elizabeth Attrill
Graham Campbell
Amanda Datson
Anna Fouracres
Juan Graterol
Lynne Graves
Bosun Hong
Alexander Ishimaru
Arvind Karthikeyan
Helen King
Tom Lawson
Gregory Lee
Saoirse Lyons
Andrew Macalister Hall
Sophie Mathoulin
Eilidh Mcintyre
Danny Mclaughlin
Kathleen Mulcahy
Anna Ratcliffe
James Robbins
Weilin Sung
Adeoluwa Tayo
Lisa Trembath
Suneetha Venugopal
Robert Walker
Geoffrey Wigmore
Catherine Boereboom
Charlotte Downes
Ryan Humphries
Susan Melbourne
Coral Smith
Samson Tou
Shafa Ullah
Nick Batchelor
Leigh Boxall
Rupert Broomby
Tariq Deen
Alistair Hellewell
Laurence Helliwell
Melanie Hutchings
David Hutchins
Samantha Keenan
Donna Mackie
Alison Potter
Frances Smith
Lucy Stone
Kevin Thorpe
Richard Wassall
Andrew Woodgate
Shelley Baillie
Tara Campbell
Sarah James
Chris King
Daniela Marques Araujo
Daniel Martin
Clare Morkane
Julia Neely
Rajkumar Rajendram
Megan Burton
Kathryn James
Edward Keevil
Orsolya Minik
Jenna Morgan
Anna Musgrave
Harish Rajanna
Tracey Roberts
Tamas Szakmany
Michael Adamson
Sandra Jumbe
Jennie Kendall
Mohan Babu Muthuswamy
Charlotte Anderson
Andrew Cruikshanks
Sailaja Pothuneedi
Rachel Walker
Ian Wrench
Lisa Zeidan
Diane Ardern
Benjamin Harris
Johanna Hellstrom
Jane Martin
Richard Thomas
Nimu Varsani
Caroline Wrey Brown
Philip Docherty
Michael Gillies
Euan McGregor
Helen Usher
Jayne Craig
Andrew Smith
Tahania Ahmad
Phoebe Bodger
Thais Creary
Kirsty Everingham
Alexander Fowler
Russ Hewson
Eke Ijuo
Marta Januszewska
Timothy Jones
Ilya Kantsedikas
Sumitra Lahiri
Aaron Lawson McLean
Edyta Niebrzegowska
Mandeep Phull
Difei Wang
Nadine Wickboldt
Jacqueline Baldwin
Donna Doyle
Sean Mcmullan
Michelle Oladapo
Thomas Owen
Shiva Tripathi
Alexandra Williams
Hull Daniel
Peter Gregory
Tauqeer Husain
Justin Kirk-Bayley
Edward Mathers
Laura Montague
Stuart White
Joanne Avis
Tim Cook
Lola Dali-Kemmery
Ian Kerslake
Victoria Lambourne
Annabel Pearson
Christine Boyd
Mark Callaghan
Cathy Lawson
Roopa McCrossan
Vanessa Nesbitt
Laura O'connor
Julia Scott
Rhona Sinclair
Nahla Farid
Ciro Morgese
Kailash Bhatia
Swati Karmarkar
Akbar Vohra
Jamil Ahmed
Graham Branagan
Monica Hutton
Andrew Swain
Jamie Brookes
Jonathan Cornell
Rachael Dolan
Jonathan Hulme
Amanda Jansen Vuuren
Tom Jowitt
Gunasheela Kalashetty
Fran Lloyd
Kiran Patel
Nicholas Sherwood
Lynne Brown
Ben Chandler
Kerry Deighton
Temlett Emma
Kirsty Haunch
Michelle Cheeseman
Kathy Dent
Sanjeev Garg
Carol Gray
Marion Hood
Dawn Jones
Joanne Juj
Atideb Mitra
Roshan Rao
Tara Walker
Mashel Al Anizi
Clarissa Cheah
Yushio Cheing
Francisco Coutinho
Prisca Gondo
Bernard Hadebe
Mazvangu Onie Hove
Ahamed Khader
Bobby Krishnachetty
Karen Rhodes
Jagdish Sokhi
Katie-Anne Baker
Wendy Bertram
Alex Looseley
Ronelle Mouton
Glenn Arnold
Shobhit Arya
Danai Balfoussia
Linden Baxter
James Harris
Craig Jones
Alison Knaggs
Sheraz Markar
Anisha Perera
Alasdair Scott
Asako Shida
Ravneet Sirha
Sally Wright
Victoria Frost
Catherine Gray
Mark MacGregor
Emma Andrews
Lindsay Arrandale
Stephen Barrett
Heena Bidd
Elna Cifra
Mariese Cooper
Dragos Dragnea
Cifra Elna
Jennifer Maclean
Sonja Meier
Donald Milliken
Christopher Munns
Nadir Ratanshi
Abegail Salvana
Anthony Watson
Hani Ali
Gill Campbell
Rebecca Critchley
Catherine Hicks
Alison Liddle
Marc Pass
Charlotte Ritchie
Charlotte Thomas
Lingxi Too
Sarah Welsh
Talvinder Gill
Joanne Johnson
Joanne Reed
Edward Davis
Sam Papadopoullos
Clare Attwood
Andrew Biffen
Kerenza Boulton
Sophie Gray
David Hay
Sarah Mills
Jane Montgomery
Rory Riddell
James Simpson
Neeraj Bhardwaj
Elaine Paul
Nosakhare Uwubamwen
Akbar Vohra
Emer Berntsen
Tracey Nolan
Angus Turner
Maini Alexander
James Arrich
Swarna Arumugam
Douglas Blackwood
Victoria Boggiano
Robyn Brown
Yik Lam Chan
Devnandan Chatterjee
Ashok Chhabra
Rachel Christian
Hannah Costelloe
Madeline Coxwell Matthewman
Emma Dalton
Julia Darko
Maria Davari
Tejal Dave
Matthew Deacon
Shantal Deepak
Holly Edmond
Jessica Ellis
Ahmed El-Sayed
Philip Eneje
Rose English
Renee Ewe
William Foers
John Franklin
Laura Gallego
Emily Garrett
Olivia Goldberg
Harry Goss
Rosanna Greaves
Rudy Harris
Charles Hennings
Eleanor Jones
Nelson Kamali
Naomi Kokkinos
Carys Lewis
Leda Lignos
Evaleen Victoria Malgapo
Rizwana Malik
Andrew Milne
John-Patrick Mulligan
Philippa Nicklin
Natasha Palipane
Thomas Parsons
Rebecca Piper
Rohan Prakash
Byron Ramesh
Sarah Rasip
Jacob Reading
Mariam Rela
Anna Reyes
Stephens Robert
Martin Rooms
Karishma Shah
Henry Simons
Shalil Solanki
Emma Spowart
Amy Stevens
Christopher Thomas
Helena Waggett
Arrash Yassaee
Anthony Kennedy
Sara Scott
Sameer Somanath
Andrew Berg
Miguel Hernandez
Rajesh Nanda
Ghanshyambhai Tank
Natalie Wilson
Debbie Wilson
Yassr Al-Soudaine
Matthew Baldwin
Julie Cornish
Zoe Davies
Leigh Davies
Marc Edwards
Natasha Frewer
Sian Gallard
James Glasbey
Rhiannon Harries
Luke Hopkins
Taeyang Kim
Vilavan Koompirochana
Simon Lawson
Megan Lewis
Zaid Makzal
Sarah Scourfield
Yousra Ahmad
Sarah Bates
Clare Blackwell
Helen Bryant
Suzanne Coulter
Ross Cruickshank
Sonya Daniel
Thomas Daubeny
Mark Edwards
Kim Golder
Lesley Hawkins
Bryant Helen
Honor Hinxman
Denny Levett
Ben Skinner
Joseph Walsgrove
Mike Bradburn
Jane Dickson
Kathryn Constantin
Markwell Karen
Peter O'Brien
Lynn O'Donohoe
Hannah Payne
Saul Sundayi
Elaine Walker
Jenny Brooke
Jon Cardy
Sally Humphreys
Laura Kessack
Christiane Kubitzek
Suhas Kumar
Donna Cotterill
Emil Hodzovic
Gurunath Hosdurga
Edward Miles
Glenn Saunders
Marta Campbell
Peter Chan
Kim Jemmett
Ashok Raj
Aditi Naik
Rajarajan Ramamoorthy
Nimesh Shah
Axel Sylvan
Katharine Blyth
Andrew Burtenshaw
David Freeman
Emily Johnson
Philip Lo
Terry Martin
Emma Plunkett
Julie Wollaston
Joanna Allison
Christine Carroll
Nicholas Craw
Sarah Craw
Tressy Pitt-Kerby
Rebecca Rowland-Axe
Katie Spurdle
Andrew McDonald
Davies Simon
Vivek Sinha
Thomas Smith
Valerie Banner-Goodspeed
Myles Boone
Kathleen Campbell
Fengxin Lu
Joseph Scannell
Julia Sobol
Naraida Balajonda
Karen Clemmons
Carlos Conde
Bonita Funk
Roger Hall
Thomas Hopkins
Omowunmi Olaleye
Omer Omer
Michelle Pender
Angelo Porto
Alice Stevens
Peter Waweru
Erlinda Yeh
Daniella Bodansky
Adam Evans
Steven Kleopoulos
Robert Maril
Edward Mathney
Angela Sanchez
Elizabeth Tinuoye
Brian Bateman
Kristen Eng
Ning Jiang
Karim Ladha
Joseph Needleman
Lee-lynn Chen
Lee-lynn Chen
Rondall Lane
David Robinowitz
Neil Ghushe
Mariam Irshad
Samir Patel
Steven Takemoto
Art Wallace
Michael Mazzeffi
Peter Rock
Karin Wallace
Xiaomao Zhu
Pandora Chua
Lee Fleisher
Matthew Mattera
Rebecca Sharar
Stephan Thilen
Miriam Treggiari
Angela Morgan
Iwan Sofjan
Kathirvel Subramaniam
Michael Avidan
Hannah Maybrier
Maxwell Muench
Troy Wildes
Title: Prospective observational cohort study on grading the severity of postoperative complications in global surgery research
Description:
AbstractBackgroundThe Clavien–Dindo classification is perhaps the most widely used approach for reporting postoperative complications in clinical trials.
This system classifies complication severity by the treatment provided.
However, it is unclear whether the Clavien–Dindo system can be used internationally in studies across differing healthcare systems in high- (HICs) and low- and middle-income countries (LMICs).
MethodsThis was a secondary analysis of the International Surgical Outcomes Study (ISOS), a prospective observational cohort study of elective surgery in adults.
Data collection occurred over a 7-day period.
Severity of complications was graded using Clavien–Dindo and the simpler ISOS grading (mild, moderate or severe, based on guided investigator judgement).
Severity grading was compared using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC).
Data are presented as frequencies and ICC values (with 95 per cent c.
i.
).
The analysis was stratified by income status of the country, comparing HICs with LMICs.
ResultsA total of 44 814 patients were recruited from 474 hospitals in 27 countries (19 HICs and 8 LMICs).
Some 7508 patients (16·8 per cent) experienced at least one postoperative complication, equivalent to 11 664 complications in total.
Using the ISOS classification, 5504 of 11 664 complications (47·2 per cent) were graded as mild, 4244 (36·4 per cent) as moderate and 1916 (16·4 per cent) as severe.
Using Clavien–Dindo, 6781 of 11 664 complications (58·1 per cent) were graded as I or II, 1740 (14·9 per cent) as III, 2408 (20·6 per cent) as IV and 735 (6·3 per cent) as V.
Agreement between classification systems was poor overall (ICC 0·41, 95 per cent c.
i.
0·20 to 0·55), and in LMICs (ICC 0·23, 0·05 to 0·38) and HICs (ICC 0·46, 0·25 to 0·59).
ConclusionCaution is recommended when using a treatment approach to grade complications in global surgery studies, as this may introduce bias unintentionally.
Related Results
619. Pharmacokinetic-Pharmacodynamic (PK-PD) Target Attainment Analyses to Support Epetraborole Dose Selection for the Treatment of Patients with Mycobacterium avium Complex (MAC) Lung Disease
619. Pharmacokinetic-Pharmacodynamic (PK-PD) Target Attainment Analyses to Support Epetraborole Dose Selection for the Treatment of Patients with Mycobacterium avium Complex (MAC) Lung Disease
Abstract
Background
Epetraborole (EBO) is an orally available, bacterial leucyl transfer RNA synthetase inhibitor that concentra...
Current therapeutic strategies for erectile function recovery after radical prostatectomy – literature review and meta-analysis
Current therapeutic strategies for erectile function recovery after radical prostatectomy – literature review and meta-analysis
Radical prostatectomy is the most commonly performed treatment option for localised prostate cancer. In the last decades the surgical technique has been improved and modified in or...
LB2306. Population Pharmacokinetic (PPK), Pharmacokinetic/Pharmacodynamic attainment (PTA), and Clinical Pharmacokinetic/Pharmacodynamic (PK/PD) Analyses for Sulbactam-Durlobactam (SUL-DUR) to Support Dose Selection for the Treatment of Acinetobacter baum
LB2306. Population Pharmacokinetic (PPK), Pharmacokinetic/Pharmacodynamic attainment (PTA), and Clinical Pharmacokinetic/Pharmacodynamic (PK/PD) Analyses for Sulbactam-Durlobactam (SUL-DUR) to Support Dose Selection for the Treatment of Acinetobacter baum
Abstract
Background
SUL-DUR is a β-lactam/β-lactamase inhibitor combination in development for the treatment of ABC infections, ...
Cohort studies
Cohort studies
A cohort study is one in which the outcome (usually disease status) is ascertained for groups of individuals defined on the basis of their exposure. At the time exposure status is ...
593. Population Pharmacokinetic Model Development for Epetraborole and Mycobacterium avium Complex (MAC) Lung Disease Patients Using Data from Phase 1 and 2 Studies
593. Population Pharmacokinetic Model Development for Epetraborole and Mycobacterium avium Complex (MAC) Lung Disease Patients Using Data from Phase 1 and 2 Studies
Abstract
Background
Epetraborole (EBO), an orally available bacterial leucyl transfer RNA synthetase inhibitor with potent activ...
Microwave Ablation with or Without Chemotherapy in Management of Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer: A Systematic Review
Microwave Ablation with or Without Chemotherapy in Management of Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer: A Systematic Review
Abstract
Introduction
Microwave ablation (MWA) has emerged as a minimally invasive treatment for patients with inoperable non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). However, whether it i...
Global Surgery Research: An Overview and the Role of Medical Students and Surgical Trainees in Advancing Global Surgery Research in LMICs
Global Surgery Research: An Overview and the Role of Medical Students and Surgical Trainees in Advancing Global Surgery Research in LMICs
Global surgery research is a critical area of study aimed at enhancing access to safe and effective surgical care for patients in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). It is es...
Pediatric Pilonidal Sinus Disease: A Single-Center Cohort Study of Clinical and Surgical Outcomes
Pediatric Pilonidal Sinus Disease: A Single-Center Cohort Study of Clinical and Surgical Outcomes
Abstract
Introduction: Pilonidal sinus disease is increasingly recognized in the pediatric population, yet evidence on its clinical characteristics and surgical outcomes in childre...

