Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Assessing the effectiveness of compulsory community treatment
View through CrossRef
This chapter initially considers methodological issues that arise in assessing the effectiveness of compulsory community treatment. It then reviews the evidence from uncontrolled, controlled, and randomized studies of various types of intervention. Although uncontrolled studies suggest some reduction in health service use following compulsory community treatment, this is not generally confirmed in studies with matched or randomized controls. Although proponents of compulsory community treatment argue that it is less coercive than the alternatives of compulsory admission to hospital or arrest, research findings suggest that it remains an unproven way of reducing either procedure. Even where changes in outcome have been shown, such as decreased criminal victimization, it is not clear whether these are due to the legislative framework or to a greater intensity of contact.
Title: Assessing the effectiveness of compulsory community treatment
Description:
This chapter initially considers methodological issues that arise in assessing the effectiveness of compulsory community treatment.
It then reviews the evidence from uncontrolled, controlled, and randomized studies of various types of intervention.
Although uncontrolled studies suggest some reduction in health service use following compulsory community treatment, this is not generally confirmed in studies with matched or randomized controls.
Although proponents of compulsory community treatment argue that it is less coercive than the alternatives of compulsory admission to hospital or arrest, research findings suggest that it remains an unproven way of reducing either procedure.
Even where changes in outcome have been shown, such as decreased criminal victimization, it is not clear whether these are due to the legislative framework or to a greater intensity of contact.
Related Results
Coercion in Community Mental Health Care
Coercion in Community Mental Health Care
The use of coercion is one of the defining issues of mental health care and has been intensely controversial since the very earliest attempts to contain and treat the mentally ill....
Creating a Civil Community
Creating a Civil Community
Bullying, also known as horizontal workplace violence, is pervasive in the nursing community. The nursing community must respond by creating a civil community. A civil community is...
Cultural Work of Community Radio
Cultural Work of Community Radio
Community radio is an established and key site for negotiations of social and political issues for marginalised communities. Given its inherently local nature (both geographically ...
Leading the Way
Leading the Way
There are numerous leadership opportunities and a great need for more effective leadership in the nonprofit sector. While community leadership is one of the 18 community psychology...
Community Colleges
Community Colleges
This book addresses various federal, state, and institutional policies affecting community colleges and speculates about future policy options within the current policy context. Wh...
The Unseen Politics of Public Housing
The Unseen Politics of Public Housing
The Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) emphasizes the word “community” for building economic development, citizen participations, and revitalization of facilities an...
Health economics
Health economics
The economic burden of rheumatic diseases for society, various payers, and last but not least the individual patient has been increasingly recognized. In addition to the well-known...
Compulsory community mental health care: Oceania
Compulsory community mental health care: Oceania
Oceania is characterized by the diversity of countries and by highly variable provision of mental health services and community mental health care. Countries such as Australian and...

