Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Force Majeure and Excuses in Smart Contracts

View through CrossRef
A classic legal problem is whether breach of contract may give rise to a remedy. Under common law this is discussed under the doctrine of excuses. Its civil law equivalent is the attributability of causes of non-performance of an obligation, and its converse, force majeure. Despite the variety of approaches in various jurisdictions, the general outlines are roughly equivalent as far as translation into smart contracts is concerned: the main issue is what is the cause of non-performance and whether this cause can be attributed. <br><br>Smart contracts can deal with the general outline of this structure, but may in practice only approximate the refinement that contract law offers. The main problems are: determining the actual cause of the non-performance by means of automated oracles or the smart contract on its own (without relying on human judgement), dealing with multiple causality and impediments due to by the creditor, determining attributability of the cause of non-performance. Smart contracts may offer no more than an approximation of the detailed rules of contract law, by hard-and-fast rules. This may suffice for certain categories of contracts, but may need additional effort to obtain a closer approximation of contract law rules where larger interests are concerned. The related doctrine of withholding performance is similarly difficult to realise appropriately in smart contracts. As regards hardship or unforeseen circumstances, it is best to disallow this in smart contracts, which leaves open the question whether parties might go to court for relief. The reliance on oracles furthermore opens a weakness to the automatic performance of smart contracts, due to possible liability of oracles for perceived incorrect assessment.<br><br>The obstacles involved with excuses point to deeper-seated problems with smart contracts: these take an ex ante view instead of the common ex post judicial assessment view of law, while actual contracts are often not intended as a full description of obligation but rather as an element of the social relation between parties. Smart contracts implement only a part of the contractual relation. In particular cases, such as long-distance single transactions of sale, the benefit of secured performance may outweigh the disadvantages of partial loss of protection due to hard-and-fast rules. Even then, anecdotal evidence with dispute resolution rules in online marketplaces shows that such an approach is not entirely satisfactory.<br><br>This is the version presented at the Conference ‘Impact of Technology on International Contract Law: Smart Contracts and Blockchain Technologies’, 4-5 May 2018 Lyon (UCL). The published version will be uploaded after the embargo period has passed.
Title: Force Majeure and Excuses in Smart Contracts
Description:
A classic legal problem is whether breach of contract may give rise to a remedy.
Under common law this is discussed under the doctrine of excuses.
Its civil law equivalent is the attributability of causes of non-performance of an obligation, and its converse, force majeure.
Despite the variety of approaches in various jurisdictions, the general outlines are roughly equivalent as far as translation into smart contracts is concerned: the main issue is what is the cause of non-performance and whether this cause can be attributed.
<br><br>Smart contracts can deal with the general outline of this structure, but may in practice only approximate the refinement that contract law offers.
The main problems are: determining the actual cause of the non-performance by means of automated oracles or the smart contract on its own (without relying on human judgement), dealing with multiple causality and impediments due to by the creditor, determining attributability of the cause of non-performance.
Smart contracts may offer no more than an approximation of the detailed rules of contract law, by hard-and-fast rules.
This may suffice for certain categories of contracts, but may need additional effort to obtain a closer approximation of contract law rules where larger interests are concerned.
The related doctrine of withholding performance is similarly difficult to realise appropriately in smart contracts.
As regards hardship or unforeseen circumstances, it is best to disallow this in smart contracts, which leaves open the question whether parties might go to court for relief.
The reliance on oracles furthermore opens a weakness to the automatic performance of smart contracts, due to possible liability of oracles for perceived incorrect assessment.
<br><br>The obstacles involved with excuses point to deeper-seated problems with smart contracts: these take an ex ante view instead of the common ex post judicial assessment view of law, while actual contracts are often not intended as a full description of obligation but rather as an element of the social relation between parties.
Smart contracts implement only a part of the contractual relation.
In particular cases, such as long-distance single transactions of sale, the benefit of secured performance may outweigh the disadvantages of partial loss of protection due to hard-and-fast rules.
Even then, anecdotal evidence with dispute resolution rules in online marketplaces shows that such an approach is not entirely satisfactory.
<br><br>This is the version presented at the Conference ‘Impact of Technology on International Contract Law: Smart Contracts and Blockchain Technologies’, 4-5 May 2018 Lyon (UCL).
The published version will be uploaded after the embargo period has passed.

Related Results

Hashing Out Agreements: An Overview of 'Smart' Contracts under Canadian Law
Hashing Out Agreements: An Overview of 'Smart' Contracts under Canadian Law
Blockchain-based technologies are starting to permeate every aspect of the Canadian legal landscape. Blockchain is often solely associated with cryptocurrencies, such as Bitcoin; h...
Smart Contracts Security Application and Challenges: A Review
Smart Contracts Security Application and Challenges: A Review
There has been a rise in the demand for blockchain-based smart contract development platforms and language implementations. On the other hand, smart contracts and blockchain applic...
PERSPEKTIF FORCE MAJEURE DAN REBUS SIC STANTIBUS DALAM SISTEM HUKUM INDONESIA
PERSPEKTIF FORCE MAJEURE DAN REBUS SIC STANTIBUS DALAM SISTEM HUKUM INDONESIA
Peranan kontrak sangat penting dalam kehidupan sehari-hari. Kontrak adalah: Kesepakatan para pihak tentang sesuatu hal yang melahirkan perikatan/hubungan hukum, menimbulkan hak dan...
The Urgency of Establishing a Legal Entity Issuing Force Majeure Certificates Against Creditor Protection During the Covid-19 Pandemic
The Urgency of Establishing a Legal Entity Issuing Force Majeure Certificates Against Creditor Protection During the Covid-19 Pandemic
The Covid-19 that occurred in recent years has had an impact on public health as well as the economic sector. It has caused the Indonesian economy to experience a slump in the seco...
Generative AI-Driven Smart Contract Optimization for Secure and Scalable Smart City Services
Generative AI-Driven Smart Contract Optimization for Secure and Scalable Smart City Services
Smart cities use advanced infrastructure and technology to improve the quality of life for their citizens. Collaborative services in smart cities are making the smart city ecosyste...
Configuration of Incoterms into Smart Contracts: a View of International Sales Contracts through a Futuristic Periscope
Configuration of Incoterms into Smart Contracts: a View of International Sales Contracts through a Futuristic Periscope
Objective: to identify the prospects of international trade in the light of synchronizing Incoterms with smart contracts.Methods: the study is based on the general scientific metho...
THE LEGAL NATURE OF PUBLIC PROCUREMENT AGREEMENTS AND THE FEATURES OF CONTRACTING IN ELECTRONIC FORM
THE LEGAL NATURE OF PUBLIC PROCUREMENT AGREEMENTS AND THE FEATURES OF CONTRACTING IN ELECTRONIC FORM
In the article, based on the analysis of the contractual process, with the help of analytical, formal-logical and comparative legal methods, the legal nature of the peculiarities o...

Back to Top