Javascript must be enabled to continue!
ESG Rating Agency Incentives
View through CrossRef
Despite growing investor reliance on environmental, social, and governance (ESG) ratings, we know relatively little about how such ratings are constructed. Recent evidence of disagreement across ESG ratings raises concerns about their credibility. We note that while reputational concerns likely motivate ESG raters to issue credible and accurate ratings, several leading ESG raters also construct index products based on their ESG ratings. We examine whether the incentives associated with deriving revenue from ESG rating-based indices contribute to the variation in ESG ratings. Consistent with this notion, we find that raters with strong index licensing incentives issue higher ESG ratings for firms with better stock return performance relative to raters with weaker licensing incentives, after controlling for the firm's fundamental ESG performance. We also find that raters that construct ESG-based indices more often include and place greater weight on stocks with better stock return performance in the ESG-based indices. Overall, our findings suggest that index construction incentives affect the construction of ESG ratings, highlighting the need for greater transparency in the production of ESG ratings.
Title: ESG Rating Agency Incentives
Description:
Despite growing investor reliance on environmental, social, and governance (ESG) ratings, we know relatively little about how such ratings are constructed.
Recent evidence of disagreement across ESG ratings raises concerns about their credibility.
We note that while reputational concerns likely motivate ESG raters to issue credible and accurate ratings, several leading ESG raters also construct index products based on their ESG ratings.
We examine whether the incentives associated with deriving revenue from ESG rating-based indices contribute to the variation in ESG ratings.
Consistent with this notion, we find that raters with strong index licensing incentives issue higher ESG ratings for firms with better stock return performance relative to raters with weaker licensing incentives, after controlling for the firm's fundamental ESG performance.
We also find that raters that construct ESG-based indices more often include and place greater weight on stocks with better stock return performance in the ESG-based indices.
Overall, our findings suggest that index construction incentives affect the construction of ESG ratings, highlighting the need for greater transparency in the production of ESG ratings.
Related Results
Assessing Environmental Social Governance in Zambia's Banking Sector
Assessing Environmental Social Governance in Zambia's Banking Sector
Environmental Social Governance (ESG) has taken centre stage in the global financial sector due to pressing global challenges such as natural disasters and climate change, governan...
Environmental, social and governance (ESG) performance in the context of multinational business research
Environmental, social and governance (ESG) performance in the context of multinational business research
PurposeThis paper aims to examine the state of research on environmental, social and governance (ESG) performance in the context of multinational business research. This paper disc...
Is There A Risk Premium in ESG Investing in India?
Is There A Risk Premium in ESG Investing in India?
Research Question: To check whether the ESG scores of Indian companies impact their share prices and risk-adjusted returns. Motivation: Increased awareness about sustainability has...
The Effect of ESG Assurance on Audit Quality: An Empirical Analysis
The Effect of ESG Assurance on Audit Quality: An Empirical Analysis
Abstract
Against the backdrop of continuous advancement of the "dual carbon" goals and strengthening requirements for sustainable information disclosure in capital ...
Cost of Capital for ESG and Non-ESG Stocks: Regression- versus Theory-based Approaches
Cost of Capital for ESG and Non-ESG Stocks: Regression- versus Theory-based Approaches
Cost of capital is the most important aspect for investors when deciding to invest in ESG stocks. Against this background there is a puzzle in the ESG literature. When formulating ...
UNCOVERING DIVERSIFICATION BENEFITS: RETURN SPILLOVERS IN USA ESG AND NON-ESG ORIENTED BANKS
UNCOVERING DIVERSIFICATION BENEFITS: RETURN SPILLOVERS IN USA ESG AND NON-ESG ORIENTED BANKS
The balance sheet is a source of interconnectedness among financial products and affect the overall system of economics. Due to interest of investors in the market’s connectedness,...
Sustainable Investing - Does ESG Induce a Virtuous Circle?
Sustainable Investing - Does ESG Induce a Virtuous Circle?
A környezeti, társadalmi és gazdasági rendszerek fenntarthatóságának szavatolása jelentős kihívás elé állítja korunk társadalmát. A klímaváltozás mérséklésére 2016-ban megkötött pá...
The Impact of ESG Investing on Portfolio Performance: An Empirical Study of Emerging Markets
The Impact of ESG Investing on Portfolio Performance: An Empirical Study of Emerging Markets
ESG investment, which stands for environmental, social, and governance investing, has become an important strategy in the global financial markets, and its applications are becomin...

