Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Rivers as persons: intrinsic value, capabilities and representation

View through CrossRef
Purpose This paper aims to examine whether and why rivers should be recognised as legal persons from an ecocentric perspective grounded in intrinsic value. It argues that the key challenge is not only whether legal personhood can be extended to rivers, but how river personhood can be designed so that representatives genuinely defend rivers’ own interests. By focusing on rivers’ “capabilities” (to hold rights, have interests, possess a representable will, and stand in court), this paper clarifies what river-focused personhood must achieve in practice. Design/methodology/approach This paper adopts a doctrinal and conceptual methodology. It reassesses classic and contemporary theories of legal personhood (legalist and metaphysical; interest and will theories) alongside recent Rights of Nature and “rights of rivers” scholarship. These conceptual debates are tested against leading examples of river personhood and related initiatives, including Ganga/Yamuna, Whanganui, Ecuador’s constitutional Rights of Nature and litigation concerning the Niger Delta. A capabilities-based framework is developed to connect foundations of river personhood with questions of representation, standing and enforcement. Findings The paper finds that river personhood is best justified by rivers’ intrinsic value and capabilities. Properly understood, rivers can be rights-holders because they have morally significant interests and a will that can be represented. However, the effectiveness of river personhood depends on how representatives and institutional arrangements are designed. Without mandates tied to rivers’ intrinsic value, personhood risks remaining symbolic, reproducing anthropocentric, extractive patterns rather than transforming relationships with rivers. Research limitations/implications The analysis is primarily doctrinal and theoretical. Future research should examine how different guardian models, governance arrangements and community-led practices function in particular river contexts, and how they interact with existing property, resource and administrative regimes. The capabilities-based framework proposed here can guide such empirical work and comparative studies across river systems. Practical implications This paper has practical implications for legislators, courts and policymakers. The paper provides a structured way to design river personhood regimes. It shows that guardians and representatives must be selected, authorised and resourced in ways that reflect rivers’ intrinsic value and identified interests, rather than merely reproducing existing priorities. The analysis highlights the importance of clear standing rules, independent guardianship, training for judges and representatives. These can inform the drafting, interpretation and reform of Rights of Nature and river statutes. Social implications Recognising rivers as legal persons reshapes social relationships between human and nature. This paper suggests that river personhood can enhance environmental justice by making rivers’ interests visible in law and opening spaces for communities, including Indigenous peoples and river-dependent groups, to act as custodial representatives. At the same time, it warns that poorly designed charters or laws may entrench existing power imbalances or sideline local knowledges. A capabilities and intrinsic-value approach supports more inclusive and relational models of decision-making about rivers. Originality/value This paper shifts the debate from the question of whether rivers can be legal persons to how river personhood should be grounded and structured. Its originality lies in combining an ecocentric account of intrinsic value with a capabilities-based framework (rights, interests, representable will, standing) that directly informs the design of representation and guardianship. By systematically linking personhood theory, Rights of Nature practice and the practicalities of enforcement, the paper offers a distinctive, river-focused contribution to ongoing legal and socio-legal debates.
Title: Rivers as persons: intrinsic value, capabilities and representation
Description:
Purpose This paper aims to examine whether and why rivers should be recognised as legal persons from an ecocentric perspective grounded in intrinsic value.
It argues that the key challenge is not only whether legal personhood can be extended to rivers, but how river personhood can be designed so that representatives genuinely defend rivers’ own interests.
By focusing on rivers’ “capabilities” (to hold rights, have interests, possess a representable will, and stand in court), this paper clarifies what river-focused personhood must achieve in practice.
Design/methodology/approach This paper adopts a doctrinal and conceptual methodology.
It reassesses classic and contemporary theories of legal personhood (legalist and metaphysical; interest and will theories) alongside recent Rights of Nature and “rights of rivers” scholarship.
These conceptual debates are tested against leading examples of river personhood and related initiatives, including Ganga/Yamuna, Whanganui, Ecuador’s constitutional Rights of Nature and litigation concerning the Niger Delta.
A capabilities-based framework is developed to connect foundations of river personhood with questions of representation, standing and enforcement.
Findings The paper finds that river personhood is best justified by rivers’ intrinsic value and capabilities.
Properly understood, rivers can be rights-holders because they have morally significant interests and a will that can be represented.
However, the effectiveness of river personhood depends on how representatives and institutional arrangements are designed.
Without mandates tied to rivers’ intrinsic value, personhood risks remaining symbolic, reproducing anthropocentric, extractive patterns rather than transforming relationships with rivers.
Research limitations/implications The analysis is primarily doctrinal and theoretical.
Future research should examine how different guardian models, governance arrangements and community-led practices function in particular river contexts, and how they interact with existing property, resource and administrative regimes.
The capabilities-based framework proposed here can guide such empirical work and comparative studies across river systems.
Practical implications This paper has practical implications for legislators, courts and policymakers.
The paper provides a structured way to design river personhood regimes.
It shows that guardians and representatives must be selected, authorised and resourced in ways that reflect rivers’ intrinsic value and identified interests, rather than merely reproducing existing priorities.
The analysis highlights the importance of clear standing rules, independent guardianship, training for judges and representatives.
These can inform the drafting, interpretation and reform of Rights of Nature and river statutes.
Social implications Recognising rivers as legal persons reshapes social relationships between human and nature.
This paper suggests that river personhood can enhance environmental justice by making rivers’ interests visible in law and opening spaces for communities, including Indigenous peoples and river-dependent groups, to act as custodial representatives.
At the same time, it warns that poorly designed charters or laws may entrench existing power imbalances or sideline local knowledges.
A capabilities and intrinsic-value approach supports more inclusive and relational models of decision-making about rivers.
Originality/value This paper shifts the debate from the question of whether rivers can be legal persons to how river personhood should be grounded and structured.
Its originality lies in combining an ecocentric account of intrinsic value with a capabilities-based framework (rights, interests, representable will, standing) that directly informs the design of representation and guardianship.
By systematically linking personhood theory, Rights of Nature practice and the practicalities of enforcement, the paper offers a distinctive, river-focused contribution to ongoing legal and socio-legal debates.

Related Results

Młodociani sprawcy przestępstw przeciwko mieniu
Młodociani sprawcy przestępstw przeciwko mieniu
The new Polish penal legislation of 1969 introduced special rules of criminal liability of young adult offenders' aged 17-20. In 1972 criminological research was undertaken in orde...
Disentangling the Motivation-Achievement Paradox of Immigrant Students
Disentangling the Motivation-Achievement Paradox of Immigrant Students
Students with an immigration background tend to show similar or sometimes even higher intrinsic motivation compared to their native peers (Kigel, McElvany, & Becker, 2015, Miya...
Water Trash Collector
Water Trash Collector
In today day to day life, approximately 71% of the Earth's surface is covered by Without affecting significant role that technology plays in our modern world, environmental and wat...
Work Values
Work Values
Research has identified TV series and, also more recently social media, as different actors in vocational socialization, providing individuals with career-related information (Levi...
Determining the microbial and chemical contamination in Ecuador’s main rivers
Determining the microbial and chemical contamination in Ecuador’s main rivers
AbstractOne major health issue is the microbial and chemical contamination of natural freshwater, particularly in Latin American countries, such as Ecuador, where it is still lacki...
Fluvial geomorphology of Indian rivers: an overview
Fluvial geomorphology of Indian rivers: an overview
The rivers of India reveal certain special characteristics because they undergo large seasonal fluctuations in flow and sediment load. The rivers are adjusted to an array of discha...
The role of rivers and lakes in damping flow variability introduced by hydropower
The role of rivers and lakes in damping flow variability introduced by hydropower
Hydropower regulations may significantly increase the variability of flow at especially short time scales when compared with the natural hydrological regime to which river ecosyste...

Back to Top