Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Hegel, Marxism and Mysticism

View through CrossRef
Marx's comments on Hegel's philosophy have left an ambiguous legacy for Marxism. One pervasive theme, though, is the interpretation of Hegel's idealist philosophy as being shrouded in mysticism. Marx's main contribution, according to this view, was to demystify Hegel's thought through a more materialist dialectical approach. At the same time, however, there have been those who have sought to rupture this Hegel-Marx connection and purge Hegelianism from Marxism altogether. Appropriate and expunge have therefore been the two main responses to Hegel's influence on Marxism. I will argue against these traditions, however, to assert a more direct relationship between Hegel's and Marx's dialectic. To do so, I want to identify some of the main Marxist thinkers that can be linked with the two main schools above. I will term these the Hegelian-Marxist Materialist Appropriators and the Idealist Expungers. In contrast I put forward the Hegelian-Marxist Materialist school which states that ultimately the dialectic of Hegel is the dialectic of Marx. Before this, I begin by considering some examples of Marx's critique of Hegel. The leitmotif of this critique is a depiction of Hegel's dialectic as mystical or idealistic in contrast to Marx's more materialist dialectic. As we shall see, such a criticism was begun by Marx, perpetuated by Engels as ‘orthodox’ Marxism and ultimately accepted even by those who sought to place themselves within an Hegelian-Marxist tradition.
Title: Hegel, Marxism and Mysticism
Description:
Marx's comments on Hegel's philosophy have left an ambiguous legacy for Marxism.
One pervasive theme, though, is the interpretation of Hegel's idealist philosophy as being shrouded in mysticism.
Marx's main contribution, according to this view, was to demystify Hegel's thought through a more materialist dialectical approach.
At the same time, however, there have been those who have sought to rupture this Hegel-Marx connection and purge Hegelianism from Marxism altogether.
Appropriate and expunge have therefore been the two main responses to Hegel's influence on Marxism.
I will argue against these traditions, however, to assert a more direct relationship between Hegel's and Marx's dialectic.
To do so, I want to identify some of the main Marxist thinkers that can be linked with the two main schools above.
I will term these the Hegelian-Marxist Materialist Appropriators and the Idealist Expungers.
In contrast I put forward the Hegelian-Marxist Materialist school which states that ultimately the dialectic of Hegel is the dialectic of Marx.
Before this, I begin by considering some examples of Marx's critique of Hegel.
The leitmotif of this critique is a depiction of Hegel's dialectic as mystical or idealistic in contrast to Marx's more materialist dialectic.
As we shall see, such a criticism was begun by Marx, perpetuated by Engels as ‘orthodox’ Marxism and ultimately accepted even by those who sought to place themselves within an Hegelian-Marxist tradition.

Related Results

Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich (1770–1831)
Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich (1770–1831)
Hegel was the last of the main representatives of a philosophical movement known as German Idealism, which developed towards the end of the eighteenth century primarily as a reacti...
Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich (1770–1831)
Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich (1770–1831)
Hegel was the last of the main representatives of a philosophical movement known as German Idealism, which developed towards the end of the eighteenth century primarily as a reacti...
The Hegel Archive and the Hegel Edition
The Hegel Archive and the Hegel Edition
The Hegel Archive was established in 1958 by Land Nordrhein-Westphalia as the workplace for the historical-critical edition of Hegel's works, originally commissioned by the Deutsch...
Marxism, Western
Marxism, Western
Western Marxism is used here as an umbrella term for the various schools of Marxist thought that have flourished in Western Europe since Marx’s death in 1883. It is sometimes used ...
Thom Brooks and the ‘Systematic’ Reading of Hegel
Thom Brooks and the ‘Systematic’ Reading of Hegel
Hegel was a systematic philosopher, who grounded his system on a speculative logic. But his greatest philosophical contributions lie in his reflections on human culture: ethics, so...
De-Mystifying Mysticism: A Critical Realist Perspective on Ambivalences in the Study of Mysticism
De-Mystifying Mysticism: A Critical Realist Perspective on Ambivalences in the Study of Mysticism
The study of mysticism has been at an impasse for many years, wavering between naïve realism around a common core hypothesis and critical questioning of the category of mysticism a...
TASAWUF KOTA
TASAWUF KOTA
The development of Islamic mysticism faces the neiv era cifter it is merely found at villagers. Nowadays, Islamic mysticism goes on urban society and has irifluenced the society. D...
1. Marxism
1. Marxism
Chapter One ("Marxism") argues that among all contesting social theories now, only Orthodox Marxism has been able to produce an integrated knowledge of the existing social totality...

Back to Top