Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Links between distance learning technologies in L2 classes and students’ motivation in New Zealand universities
View through CrossRef
This PhD research examines how individual, social, and contextual factors influence L2 motivation in New Zealand university second language (L2) courses, focusing on on-campus, hybrid, and online delivery. Using a mixed-methods design, it addresses two main questions. The first concerns the general motivational profile of New Zealand university L2 students, including their motivation levels, changes over a trimester, the balance of instrumental versus integrative motives, and the influence of factors like proficiency and prior experience. The second concerns how motivation is shaped by instructional modality and distance-learning features (such as synchronous vs asynchronous instruction, instructor feedback, and learner agency).
To investigate these questions, 51 university students studying five different languages (Chinese, Japanese, Russian, French, and Spanish) completed a modified Gardner (1985) Attitude/Motivation questionnaire at the beginning and end of the second trimester of 2024. Participants varied in proficiency, background, and programme. The first survey measured initial motivation, anxiety, and attitudes; the second measured changes in motivation by the trimester’s end. Ten students who took part in both surveys, as well as eight additional participants who did not complete the survey (four language lecturers from three New Zealand universities, two former online L2 students who had recently completed their courses, and two current online students), then participated in semi-structured interviews.
Quantitative analysis showed high motivation at the outset, with no significant decline or increase in motivation and anxiety by the trimester’s end. Higher-proficiency students reported greater motivation, whereas beginners showed lower motivation and more anxiety. Students of Chinese were somewhat less motivated than those studying other languages. Students who engaged in their studies for a longer period demonstrated higher levels of motivation. No significant correlations were found between motivation and delivery mode, demographics, or course satisfaction.
Qualitative data confirmed these patterns and revealed additional themes. Advanced learners described high confidence and enjoyment, while novices often felt intimidated or discouraged. Synchronous sessions provided valuable interaction and feedback, but rigid schedules, technical issues, and varying learner confidence limited their benefits. Asynchronous aspects offered flexibility but led to procrastination and/or isolation; students combining self-paced study with structured deadlines reported better engagement. Instructor presence and feedback were critical to motivation, and learner agency (goal-setting, self-monitoring, seeking support) emerged as pivotal for success in hybrid and online settings.
Together, these findings confirm consistently high, stable motivation across modalities. Both quantitative and qualitative results indicate that integrative and personal motives dominate students’ reasons for studying languages, with instrumental (career-oriented) motives playing a much smaller role. Proficiency and study duration contributed to motivation. Delivery mode and class format had no significant effect on motivation, suggesting equal motivation across settings. However, students studying in a hybrid mode felt more connected and supported than fully online peers; synchronous classes were engaging but sometimes logistically challenging; and asynchronous work, while flexible, could lead to overload or disengagement without sufficient structure.
In sum, this research highlights that L2 motivation remains robust in blended and online environments when integrative goals and autonomy are supported. It contributes to L2 motivation theory by emphasizing the interplay of learner agency and contextual affordances in online learning. The findings suggest that university L2 programmes can sustain high motivation by promoting cultural and personal growth goals, ensuring strong online instructor presence, and supporting learner autonomy as online and blended programmes expand.
Title: Links between distance learning technologies in L2 classes and students’ motivation in New Zealand universities
Description:
This PhD research examines how individual, social, and contextual factors influence L2 motivation in New Zealand university second language (L2) courses, focusing on on-campus, hybrid, and online delivery.
Using a mixed-methods design, it addresses two main questions.
The first concerns the general motivational profile of New Zealand university L2 students, including their motivation levels, changes over a trimester, the balance of instrumental versus integrative motives, and the influence of factors like proficiency and prior experience.
The second concerns how motivation is shaped by instructional modality and distance-learning features (such as synchronous vs asynchronous instruction, instructor feedback, and learner agency).
To investigate these questions, 51 university students studying five different languages (Chinese, Japanese, Russian, French, and Spanish) completed a modified Gardner (1985) Attitude/Motivation questionnaire at the beginning and end of the second trimester of 2024.
Participants varied in proficiency, background, and programme.
The first survey measured initial motivation, anxiety, and attitudes; the second measured changes in motivation by the trimester’s end.
Ten students who took part in both surveys, as well as eight additional participants who did not complete the survey (four language lecturers from three New Zealand universities, two former online L2 students who had recently completed their courses, and two current online students), then participated in semi-structured interviews.
Quantitative analysis showed high motivation at the outset, with no significant decline or increase in motivation and anxiety by the trimester’s end.
Higher-proficiency students reported greater motivation, whereas beginners showed lower motivation and more anxiety.
Students of Chinese were somewhat less motivated than those studying other languages.
Students who engaged in their studies for a longer period demonstrated higher levels of motivation.
No significant correlations were found between motivation and delivery mode, demographics, or course satisfaction.
Qualitative data confirmed these patterns and revealed additional themes.
Advanced learners described high confidence and enjoyment, while novices often felt intimidated or discouraged.
Synchronous sessions provided valuable interaction and feedback, but rigid schedules, technical issues, and varying learner confidence limited their benefits.
Asynchronous aspects offered flexibility but led to procrastination and/or isolation; students combining self-paced study with structured deadlines reported better engagement.
Instructor presence and feedback were critical to motivation, and learner agency (goal-setting, self-monitoring, seeking support) emerged as pivotal for success in hybrid and online settings.
Together, these findings confirm consistently high, stable motivation across modalities.
Both quantitative and qualitative results indicate that integrative and personal motives dominate students’ reasons for studying languages, with instrumental (career-oriented) motives playing a much smaller role.
Proficiency and study duration contributed to motivation.
Delivery mode and class format had no significant effect on motivation, suggesting equal motivation across settings.
However, students studying in a hybrid mode felt more connected and supported than fully online peers; synchronous classes were engaging but sometimes logistically challenging; and asynchronous work, while flexible, could lead to overload or disengagement without sufficient structure.
In sum, this research highlights that L2 motivation remains robust in blended and online environments when integrative goals and autonomy are supported.
It contributes to L2 motivation theory by emphasizing the interplay of learner agency and contextual affordances in online learning.
The findings suggest that university L2 programmes can sustain high motivation by promoting cultural and personal growth goals, ensuring strong online instructor presence, and supporting learner autonomy as online and blended programmes expand.
Related Results
[Papers on marine fossils of various periods]
[Papers on marine fossils of various periods]
<p dir="ltr">Works submitted by Norcott de Bisson Hornibrook to Victoria University of Wellington for a Doctor of Science degree.</p><ol><li>Hornibrook, N. ...
Disentangling the Motivation-Achievement Paradox of Immigrant Students
Disentangling the Motivation-Achievement Paradox of Immigrant Students
Students with an immigration background tend to show similar or sometimes even higher intrinsic motivation compared to their native peers (Kigel, McElvany, & Becker, 2015, Miya...
The Influence of the Children Learning in Science (CLIS) Learning Model and Students' Learning Styles on Improving Students' Conceptual Understanding and Motivation to Learn Mathematics
The Influence of the Children Learning in Science (CLIS) Learning Model and Students' Learning Styles on Improving Students' Conceptual Understanding and Motivation to Learn Mathematics
The Children Learning in Science (CLIS) learning model emphasizes the process of reconstructing students' understanding by directing changes in initial misconceptions towards a mor...
Teaching and Engaging International Students
Teaching and Engaging International Students
International student mobility has been increasingly subject to turbulences in politics, culture, economics, natural disasters, and public health. The new decade has witnessed an u...
CREATING LEARNING MEDIA IN TEACHING ENGLISH AT SMP MUHAMMADIYAH 2 PAGELARAN ACADEMIC YEAR 2020/2021
CREATING LEARNING MEDIA IN TEACHING ENGLISH AT SMP MUHAMMADIYAH 2 PAGELARAN ACADEMIC YEAR 2020/2021
The pandemic Covid-19 currently demands teachers to be able to use technology in teaching and learning process. But in reality there are still many teachers who have not been able ...
Actually or Potentially Within Reach: The Place of China in New Zealand’s Grand Strategy 1965-1972
Actually or Potentially Within Reach: The Place of China in New Zealand’s Grand Strategy 1965-1972
<p>In 1965 New Zealand was an active member of alliances designed to contain the People’s Republic of China in South East Asia. Late the previous year, the Defence Council ha...
New Zealand Plant Protection Medal 2017
New Zealand Plant Protection Medal 2017
This medal is awarded by the New Zealand Plant Protection Society to honour those who have made exceptional contributions to plant protection in New Zealand in the widest sense. Th...
[Published works on New Zealand's foreign relations]
[Published works on New Zealand's foreign relations]
<p dir="ltr">Works submitted by Ian Callum McGibbon to Victoria University of Wellington for a Doctor of Literature degree.</p><ol><li>McGibbon, I. (1977a)....

