Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Authorship diversity among systematic reviews in eyes and vision
View through CrossRef
Abstract
Importance : The inclusion of people from diverse backgrounds, and with different lived experiences is critical to ensuring the questions addressed in systematic reviews (SRs). The subsequent conclusions and recommendations made, are relevant and sensitive to the setting.Objective : To assess the gender and geographic diversity of authors among all Cochrane SRs in eyes and vision as compared with a random sample of non-Cochrane SRs of interventions in the field of eyes and vision.Design : The Cochrane Eyes and Vision United States Satellite maintains a database of SRs in the field of eyes and vision. We selected all (n = 313) Cochrane Library intervention SRs and a random sample of 313 non-Cochrane Library intervention SRs for this study. We extracted gender (‘woman,’ ‘man,’ or ‘unknown’) using a previously developed algorithm and location based on country and the World Health Organization region – of the first and corresponding authors using their full names and affiliations.Results : From the 626 reviews included in our sample, we identified 756 unique authors who comprised 887 author positions (i.e., first and/or corresponding authors). We were able to ascertain the gender of 652/756 (86%) authors: 279 women, and 373 men. Among Cochrane reviews, the proportions of women in first and/or corresponding author positions were consistent and approximately equal to men. Among non-Cochrane reviews, the representation of women was markedly lower as corresponding authors than other positions. We identified a location for each author and found most authors of Cochrane reviews were from the United Kingdom (31%) and United States of America (26%), whereas most authors of non-Cochrane reviews were from China (34%).Conclusions and relevance : Cochrane SRs in eyes and vision appear to have equal representation of women and men among the first and corresponding authors. Compared with non-Cochrane SRs in eyes and vision, Cochrane SRs appear to have a greater concentration of authors who are based in European and North American countries, possibly due to the locations of the Cochrane editorial teams. Cochrane Eyes and Vision should continue to recruit authors from around the world in locations that reflect the global burden of eye disease.
Springer Science and Business Media LLC
Title: Authorship diversity among systematic reviews in eyes and vision
Description:
Abstract
Importance : The inclusion of people from diverse backgrounds, and with different lived experiences is critical to ensuring the questions addressed in systematic reviews (SRs).
The subsequent conclusions and recommendations made, are relevant and sensitive to the setting.
Objective : To assess the gender and geographic diversity of authors among all Cochrane SRs in eyes and vision as compared with a random sample of non-Cochrane SRs of interventions in the field of eyes and vision.
Design : The Cochrane Eyes and Vision United States Satellite maintains a database of SRs in the field of eyes and vision.
We selected all (n = 313) Cochrane Library intervention SRs and a random sample of 313 non-Cochrane Library intervention SRs for this study.
We extracted gender (‘woman,’ ‘man,’ or ‘unknown’) using a previously developed algorithm and location based on country and the World Health Organization region – of the first and corresponding authors using their full names and affiliations.
Results : From the 626 reviews included in our sample, we identified 756 unique authors who comprised 887 author positions (i.
e.
, first and/or corresponding authors).
We were able to ascertain the gender of 652/756 (86%) authors: 279 women, and 373 men.
Among Cochrane reviews, the proportions of women in first and/or corresponding author positions were consistent and approximately equal to men.
Among non-Cochrane reviews, the representation of women was markedly lower as corresponding authors than other positions.
We identified a location for each author and found most authors of Cochrane reviews were from the United Kingdom (31%) and United States of America (26%), whereas most authors of non-Cochrane reviews were from China (34%).
Conclusions and relevance : Cochrane SRs in eyes and vision appear to have equal representation of women and men among the first and corresponding authors.
Compared with non-Cochrane SRs in eyes and vision, Cochrane SRs appear to have a greater concentration of authors who are based in European and North American countries, possibly due to the locations of the Cochrane editorial teams.
Cochrane Eyes and Vision should continue to recruit authors from around the world in locations that reflect the global burden of eye disease.
Related Results
[RETRACTED] Keanu Reeves CBD Gummies v1
[RETRACTED] Keanu Reeves CBD Gummies v1
[RETRACTED]Keanu Reeves CBD Gummies ==❱❱ Huge Discounts:[HURRY UP ] Absolute Keanu Reeves CBD Gummies (Available)Order Online Only!! ❰❰= https://www.facebook.com/Keanu-Reeves-CBD-G...
Do evidence summaries increase health policy‐makers' use of evidence from systematic reviews? A systematic review
Do evidence summaries increase health policy‐makers' use of evidence from systematic reviews? A systematic review
This review summarizes the evidence from six randomized controlled trials that judged the effectiveness of systematic review summaries on policymakers' decision making, or the most...
Searching and reporting in Campbell Collaboration systematic reviews: A systematic assessment of current methods
Searching and reporting in Campbell Collaboration systematic reviews: A systematic assessment of current methods
Abstract
The search methods used in systematic reviews provide the foundation for establishing the body of literature from which conclusions ...
Retinitis Pigmentosa
Retinitis Pigmentosa
In studying the cases with typical and atypical pigmentary degeneration of the retina we strived to analyse in the clinical material all ophthalmoscopic and ocular changes together...
Evaluating the Science to Inform the Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans Midcourse Report
Evaluating the Science to Inform the Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans Midcourse Report
Abstract
The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans (Guidelines) advises older adults to be as active as possible. Yet, despite the well documented benefits of physical activi...
The Ideology of Authorship Revisited
The Ideology of Authorship Revisited
This paper reexamines the historical narrative of copyright law and the ideology of authorship. This strand of copyright scholarship that emerged in the 1990s highlighted the ways ...
A simple form could prevent authorship issues in Cochrane manuscripts: A cohort study
A simple form could prevent authorship issues in Cochrane manuscripts: A cohort study
Abstract
Aim
We aimed to investigate authorship issues after the implementation of an authorship declaration form in a Co...
Gift, guest & ghost authorship in biomedical publications: definitions, prevalence, impacts, detection and prevention. Scoping review
Gift, guest & ghost authorship in biomedical publications: definitions, prevalence, impacts, detection and prevention. Scoping review
Abstract
Introduction Inappropriate authorship practices, including gift, guest, and ghost authorship, are a recognized problem in biomedical and basic science publishing. ...

