Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Academic Economic Espionage?

View through CrossRef
In 2018 then-Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced that Chinese espionage was occurring in university research labs, and the Department of Justice subsequently made it a high priority to prosecute economic espionage in academia. The DOJ’s grave concerns about espionage in academia have continued, and even more recently the Director of the FBI has lamented that American taxpayers are footing the bill for China’s technological development. This geopolitical concern about espionage has had real world and personal consequences in academia. Since 2019, over a dozen high profile criminal prosecutions have put prominent professors at major research universities across the country in handcuffs and almost all the professors have been convicted of a crime.<br><br>Yet, my investigation and analysis of these cases reveals much ambiguity about the very concept of academic economic espionage. Most telling, although labelled as spies, not one of the professors was actually charged with economic espionage. Even one district court judge in granting a lighter sentence to one professor observed that contrary to the prosecution’s framing, the case was not one of espionage. Unlike in the corporate arena, there are fundamental questions surrounding the feasibility of prosecuting espionage in the university context. I theorize that this is because academia is grounded not in a culture of ownership, but of openness and sharing. Accordingly, this Article posits that while there is no de jure exceptionalism for universities when it comes to espionage, there may be de facto exceptionalism due to the lack of a proprietary culture that is typically at the heart of espionage cases. The academic prosecutions and other signals suggest that may be shifting, however, as the legal structure and larger incentives are directed toward greater recognition of proprietary interests in academia.
Elsevier BV
Title: Academic Economic Espionage?
Description:
In 2018 then-Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced that Chinese espionage was occurring in university research labs, and the Department of Justice subsequently made it a high priority to prosecute economic espionage in academia.
The DOJ’s grave concerns about espionage in academia have continued, and even more recently the Director of the FBI has lamented that American taxpayers are footing the bill for China’s technological development.
This geopolitical concern about espionage has had real world and personal consequences in academia.
Since 2019, over a dozen high profile criminal prosecutions have put prominent professors at major research universities across the country in handcuffs and almost all the professors have been convicted of a crime.
<br><br>Yet, my investigation and analysis of these cases reveals much ambiguity about the very concept of academic economic espionage.
Most telling, although labelled as spies, not one of the professors was actually charged with economic espionage.
Even one district court judge in granting a lighter sentence to one professor observed that contrary to the prosecution’s framing, the case was not one of espionage.
Unlike in the corporate arena, there are fundamental questions surrounding the feasibility of prosecuting espionage in the university context.
I theorize that this is because academia is grounded not in a culture of ownership, but of openness and sharing.
Accordingly, this Article posits that while there is no de jure exceptionalism for universities when it comes to espionage, there may be de facto exceptionalism due to the lack of a proprietary culture that is typically at the heart of espionage cases.
The academic prosecutions and other signals suggest that may be shifting, however, as the legal structure and larger incentives are directed toward greater recognition of proprietary interests in academia.

Related Results

Cyber Espionage
Cyber Espionage
Cyberspace gives rise to risks as well as opportunities, and a prominent threat emerging from this domain is cyber espionage. Because no internationally and legally recognized defi...
The Legality of Espionage in Peacetime
The Legality of Espionage in Peacetime
Background: This research paper examines the legality of espionage during peacetime under the rules of international law. To address this issue, the paper focuses on several releva...
Theoretical and Conceptual Approaches to Defining the Concept of Economic Intelligence in the Ukrainian Scientific Practice
Theoretical and Conceptual Approaches to Defining the Concept of Economic Intelligence in the Ukrainian Scientific Practice
This contribution is dedicated to the study of theoretical and conceptual aspects of economic intelligence. The goal of the research is to theoretically define the notion of econom...
Contemporary Forms of Espionage and Their Legal Rulings: An Analytical Study in Islamic Law
Contemporary Forms of Espionage and Their Legal Rulings: An Analytical Study in Islamic Law
This study investigates the phenomenon of espionage as a fundamental component of state security in the contemporary world. Modern nation-states, particularly developed powers, emp...
CHINESE ESPIONAGE ACTIVITIES AGAINST THE UNITED STATES MILITARY INDUSTRY
CHINESE ESPIONAGE ACTIVITIES AGAINST THE UNITED STATES MILITARY INDUSTRY
This research aims to analyze China's espionage activities against the United States, especially in the military industry. In analyzing the case the author uses the concepts of the...
Industrial espionage revisited: Host country–foreign multinational corporation legal disputes and the postcolonial imagery
Industrial espionage revisited: Host country–foreign multinational corporation legal disputes and the postcolonial imagery
In this article, we take a postcolonial management approach to exploring the lingering significance of postcolonial imagery in shaping legal disputes between host country and forei...
Emerging Challenges and Future Directions of Cyber Espionage and National Security
Emerging Challenges and Future Directions of Cyber Espionage and National Security
Cyber espionage is evolving rapidly in today's highly interconnected, digitalized world. Equipped with sophisticated tools and techniques, cyber espionage is posing formidable thre...

Back to Top