Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Accounting information and shifting stakeholder salience: an industry level approach
View through CrossRef
Purpose
– The purpose of this research is to understand how accounting information mobilises stakeholder salience at an industry level.
Design/methodology/approach
– A case study method using an explanation building approach was applied to gather information surrounding dairy industry stakeholder uses of accounting information to communicate their salience, in the historical context, leading to, and the events surrounding the milk price “war” in Australia. The Mitchell et al. (1997) stakeholder salience framework was used to advance our understanding of the different ways accounting can be mobilized by stakeholders with different types of salience attributes, at an industry level.
Findings
– This empirical analysis produces two insights into the relation between accounting and stakeholder salience. First, there is evidence as to how accounting information impacted on stakeholder salience at an industry level by demonstrating how accounting information (in)directly communicated and justified the increase of a stakeholder’s level of salience. Second, the Mitchell et al. (1997) model is extended by attributing levels of importance to each stakeholder attribute. It was found that, in this setting, power was the most salient attribute of the three, usurping legitimacy and urgency, leading to the outcomes observed.
Research limitations/implications
– This paper acknowledged the usual method limitations related to this style of qualitative research, including investigator bias and lack of statistical generalization. In addition, a second set of limitations critiques the paper’s operating framework. While the Mitchell et al. (1997) stakeholder salience model proved to be a suitable choice for this research, it is limited in the way in which stakeholder attributes are presented and used to identify stakeholders. In addition, further light may be provided on the distinctions between the different magnitudes of power, legitimacy and urgency between stakeholders after suggesting that they are not equally weighted.
Practical implications
– The milk price “war” remains a high-profile discussion amongst the general public. This research contributes to a better understanding of how different players (stakeholders) have their salience claims mobilized through accounting information. Practitioners in the dairy industry might reflect on the findings to enhance their legitimacy pursuits in future negotiations with their counter-parties, and better deploy accounting to achieve the same.
Social implications
– The findings speak more broadly to notions of social equity in stakeholder relations, for the production and distribution of a product that is ubiquitously used in society (dairy – milk). The findings from this study therefore have potential to assist policymakers better understand the strategies adopted by stakeholders to impose their influence and defend their claims in a public forum, using accounting information.
Originality/value
– The authors contend that the article provides evidence at an industry level, that is lacking in extant management accounting research (Collier, 2000). To this extent, an original contribution is claimed. The paper is also valuable to management accounting and management researchers studying stakeholder salience, and is one of the first to investigate this issue at an industry level, as well as express how accounting mobilises this salience.
Title: Accounting information and shifting stakeholder salience: an industry level approach
Description:
Purpose
– The purpose of this research is to understand how accounting information mobilises stakeholder salience at an industry level.
Design/methodology/approach
– A case study method using an explanation building approach was applied to gather information surrounding dairy industry stakeholder uses of accounting information to communicate their salience, in the historical context, leading to, and the events surrounding the milk price “war” in Australia.
The Mitchell et al.
(1997) stakeholder salience framework was used to advance our understanding of the different ways accounting can be mobilized by stakeholders with different types of salience attributes, at an industry level.
Findings
– This empirical analysis produces two insights into the relation between accounting and stakeholder salience.
First, there is evidence as to how accounting information impacted on stakeholder salience at an industry level by demonstrating how accounting information (in)directly communicated and justified the increase of a stakeholder’s level of salience.
Second, the Mitchell et al.
(1997) model is extended by attributing levels of importance to each stakeholder attribute.
It was found that, in this setting, power was the most salient attribute of the three, usurping legitimacy and urgency, leading to the outcomes observed.
Research limitations/implications
– This paper acknowledged the usual method limitations related to this style of qualitative research, including investigator bias and lack of statistical generalization.
In addition, a second set of limitations critiques the paper’s operating framework.
While the Mitchell et al.
(1997) stakeholder salience model proved to be a suitable choice for this research, it is limited in the way in which stakeholder attributes are presented and used to identify stakeholders.
In addition, further light may be provided on the distinctions between the different magnitudes of power, legitimacy and urgency between stakeholders after suggesting that they are not equally weighted.
Practical implications
– The milk price “war” remains a high-profile discussion amongst the general public.
This research contributes to a better understanding of how different players (stakeholders) have their salience claims mobilized through accounting information.
Practitioners in the dairy industry might reflect on the findings to enhance their legitimacy pursuits in future negotiations with their counter-parties, and better deploy accounting to achieve the same.
Social implications
– The findings speak more broadly to notions of social equity in stakeholder relations, for the production and distribution of a product that is ubiquitously used in society (dairy – milk).
The findings from this study therefore have potential to assist policymakers better understand the strategies adopted by stakeholders to impose their influence and defend their claims in a public forum, using accounting information.
Originality/value
– The authors contend that the article provides evidence at an industry level, that is lacking in extant management accounting research (Collier, 2000).
To this extent, an original contribution is claimed.
The paper is also valuable to management accounting and management researchers studying stakeholder salience, and is one of the first to investigate this issue at an industry level, as well as express how accounting mobilises this salience.
Related Results
Analisis Stakeholder di Wilayah Operasional Perusahaan Pertambangan Migas
Analisis Stakeholder di Wilayah Operasional Perusahaan Pertambangan Migas
Mining companies, such as oil and gas mining, are categorized as having a very risky impact on the environment and surrounding communities. For this reason, mining companies are en...
Organization of equity accounting process technology
Organization of equity accounting process technology
Introduction. The lack of a clear organization of equity accounting in enterprises with foreign investment causes problems in the formation of accounting and analytical support for...
Cognitive and neural bases of salience-driven incidental learning
Cognitive and neural bases of salience-driven incidental learning
Abstract
Humans incidentally adjust their behavioral strategies along feedback dimensions even without explicit reasons to do so. How it occurs m...
The Role of Salience in Multialternative Multiattribute Choice
The Role of Salience in Multialternative Multiattribute Choice
Attention plays a central role in multi-alternative multiat- tribute decision-making but the cognitive mechanisms for it are elusive (Yang & Krajbich, 2023; Molter, Thomas,...
PERAN TATA KELOLA PERUSAHAAN DALAM MEMODERASI PENGARUH IMPLEMANTASI GREEN ACCOUNTING, CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY DAN FIRM SIZE TERHADAP KINERJA KEUANGAN
PERAN TATA KELOLA PERUSAHAAN DALAM MEMODERASI PENGARUH IMPLEMANTASI GREEN ACCOUNTING, CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY DAN FIRM SIZE TERHADAP KINERJA KEUANGAN
This study examines the role of corporate governance in moderating the influence of green accounting disclosure, corporate social responsibility (CSR), and firm size on the financi...
ACCOUNTІNG POLІCY AND ORGANІZATІON: ELEMENTS AND OBJECTS
ACCOUNTІNG POLІCY AND ORGANІZATІON: ELEMENTS AND OBJECTS
In the article is considered the problem of accounting policy of the enterprise, the organization of accounting, and the peculiarities of the impact on them of their objects and el...
Task Shifting: Need for a more Cautious and Nuanced Approach
Task Shifting: Need for a more Cautious and Nuanced Approach
Task shifting refers to the strategic redistribution and decentralization of health care tasks from one group to another(including lay workers), the latter usually deemed as having...
Development of accounting functionality in business management
Development of accounting functionality in business management
Purpose. Problems of the existing theory, methodology and organization of accounting need to be solved taking into account practical requirements of modern management. In turn, thi...

