Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Suicide in the U.S. army: stressor-strain hypothesis among deployed and nondeployed Army National Guard soldiers
View through CrossRef
Purpose
– Study samples, having responded to similar survey content, allowed examination of suicide risk factors for deployed soldiers relative to nondeployed or home station soldiers. Specific research questions addressed by this study are: First, what is the prevalence of suicidal behaviors among Army National Guard (ARNG) soldiers – deployed or not, and how do these rates compare with known US national and international rates? Second, what are stressful life events associated with suicidal risk? How do these compare between deployed and nondeployed soldiers? Third, what specifically about combat exposure makes soldiers at risk for suicide? And fourth, is there any evidence of stress-buffering effect between risk factors and suicidal behaviors? The paper aims to discuss these issues.
Design/methodology/approach
– Three data sources were used. First, the responding sample for the Unit Risk Inventory consisted of 180 company-sized units with a total of 12,567 responding soldiers. Second, the responding sample for the Unit Risk Inventory-Reintegration consisted of 50 company-sized units with a total of 4,567 soldiers. The third data source was all ARNG suicides for calendar years 2007 through 2012. For each calendar year, a random sample of 1,000 ARNG soldiers was drawn to represent nonsuicides. This resulted in a study sample size of 6,523, including the 523 suicides for the years 2007 through 2012 plus 1,000 nonsuicide cases for each calendar year.
Findings
– Prevalence of suicidal behaviors among soldiers was higher (for thoughts, plans, and attempts, respectively, 4-6, 1.3-2.2, and 0.7-0.08 percent) than among civilian populations (respectively, 2.6, 0.7, and 0.4 percent). Risk was highest among home station than deployed soldiers. Stressful life events associated with suicide risk included personal feelings of loneliness, anger, and frustration, followed by interpersonal behavioral problems, such as aggressive behavior toward a significant other and having committed a crime. Also evident are the beneficial effects (as a main effect and buffering effect) of feelings of cohesiveness, quality leaderships, and job satisfaction on suicidal behaviors.
Research limitations/implications
– Findings here were consistent with the stressor-strain hypothesis. Stressful life events were associated with suicide risk, especially, personal feelings of loneliness, anger, and frustration, followed by interpersonal behavioral problems, such as aggressive behavior toward a significant other and having committed a crime. Evident, too, were the beneficial effects of feelings of cohesiveness, quality leaderships, and job satisfaction on suicidal behaviors. Soldiers reporting these events were less likely to report suicidal behaviors and social support lessened the cumulative effect of risk factors on suicidal behaviors. Given these findings, it seems that suicide risk in the military is not uniquely different from that observed in civilian populations. The higher prevalence of suicides in the military likely has to do with proportionally more individuals who have historically shown to be at risk for suicide, namely, young males.
Practical implications
– Strong association of individual-level attributes with suicidal behaviors, such as age, gender, and race, suggest individual-level vulnerability to suicidal behaviors. This expectation is consistent with the stress/suicide vulnerability theory (Bryan, 2014; Nock et al., 2013). Such vulnerabilities may include negative affectivity (one of the Big Five personality dimensions) and early childhood trauma to suicidal behaviors (Griffith, 2012a, 2014).
Social implications
– Suicide, related constructs, and their underlying processes need to be further examined in future research. Their understanding would be useful in screening individuals most at risk for suicidal behaviors, with referral and treatment, if needed. Practically, such vulnerabilities in relation to what specific experiences could be determined, potentially describing which individuals are suited best to adapt to which environments.
Originality/value
– There has been much research on the increased suicides in the military, and to date, studies have focussed primarily on traumatic events, such as, deployments and combat exposure associated with suicidal behaviors. Yet, studies have almost exclusively examined the combat-suicide connection without reference to suicide risk factors among nondeployed or home station soldiers. This study fills this gap by examining survey responses to standardized questionnaires administered to ARNG soldiers during calendar year 2010 – one sample of deployed units either to Iraq or to Afghanistan and another sample of nondeployed or home station units.
Title: Suicide in the U.S. army: stressor-strain hypothesis among deployed and nondeployed Army National Guard soldiers
Description:
Purpose
– Study samples, having responded to similar survey content, allowed examination of suicide risk factors for deployed soldiers relative to nondeployed or home station soldiers.
Specific research questions addressed by this study are: First, what is the prevalence of suicidal behaviors among Army National Guard (ARNG) soldiers – deployed or not, and how do these rates compare with known US national and international rates? Second, what are stressful life events associated with suicidal risk? How do these compare between deployed and nondeployed soldiers? Third, what specifically about combat exposure makes soldiers at risk for suicide? And fourth, is there any evidence of stress-buffering effect between risk factors and suicidal behaviors? The paper aims to discuss these issues.
Design/methodology/approach
– Three data sources were used.
First, the responding sample for the Unit Risk Inventory consisted of 180 company-sized units with a total of 12,567 responding soldiers.
Second, the responding sample for the Unit Risk Inventory-Reintegration consisted of 50 company-sized units with a total of 4,567 soldiers.
The third data source was all ARNG suicides for calendar years 2007 through 2012.
For each calendar year, a random sample of 1,000 ARNG soldiers was drawn to represent nonsuicides.
This resulted in a study sample size of 6,523, including the 523 suicides for the years 2007 through 2012 plus 1,000 nonsuicide cases for each calendar year.
Findings
– Prevalence of suicidal behaviors among soldiers was higher (for thoughts, plans, and attempts, respectively, 4-6, 1.
3-2.
2, and 0.
7-0.
08 percent) than among civilian populations (respectively, 2.
6, 0.
7, and 0.
4 percent).
Risk was highest among home station than deployed soldiers.
Stressful life events associated with suicide risk included personal feelings of loneliness, anger, and frustration, followed by interpersonal behavioral problems, such as aggressive behavior toward a significant other and having committed a crime.
Also evident are the beneficial effects (as a main effect and buffering effect) of feelings of cohesiveness, quality leaderships, and job satisfaction on suicidal behaviors.
Research limitations/implications
– Findings here were consistent with the stressor-strain hypothesis.
Stressful life events were associated with suicide risk, especially, personal feelings of loneliness, anger, and frustration, followed by interpersonal behavioral problems, such as aggressive behavior toward a significant other and having committed a crime.
Evident, too, were the beneficial effects of feelings of cohesiveness, quality leaderships, and job satisfaction on suicidal behaviors.
Soldiers reporting these events were less likely to report suicidal behaviors and social support lessened the cumulative effect of risk factors on suicidal behaviors.
Given these findings, it seems that suicide risk in the military is not uniquely different from that observed in civilian populations.
The higher prevalence of suicides in the military likely has to do with proportionally more individuals who have historically shown to be at risk for suicide, namely, young males.
Practical implications
– Strong association of individual-level attributes with suicidal behaviors, such as age, gender, and race, suggest individual-level vulnerability to suicidal behaviors.
This expectation is consistent with the stress/suicide vulnerability theory (Bryan, 2014; Nock et al.
, 2013).
Such vulnerabilities may include negative affectivity (one of the Big Five personality dimensions) and early childhood trauma to suicidal behaviors (Griffith, 2012a, 2014).
Social implications
– Suicide, related constructs, and their underlying processes need to be further examined in future research.
Their understanding would be useful in screening individuals most at risk for suicidal behaviors, with referral and treatment, if needed.
Practically, such vulnerabilities in relation to what specific experiences could be determined, potentially describing which individuals are suited best to adapt to which environments.
Originality/value
– There has been much research on the increased suicides in the military, and to date, studies have focussed primarily on traumatic events, such as, deployments and combat exposure associated with suicidal behaviors.
Yet, studies have almost exclusively examined the combat-suicide connection without reference to suicide risk factors among nondeployed or home station soldiers.
This study fills this gap by examining survey responses to standardized questionnaires administered to ARNG soldiers during calendar year 2010 – one sample of deployed units either to Iraq or to Afghanistan and another sample of nondeployed or home station units.
Related Results
Macroeconomic and Social Precursors of Suicide Rates in the Philippines: A Quantitative Analysis (Preprint)
Macroeconomic and Social Precursors of Suicide Rates in the Philippines: A Quantitative Analysis (Preprint)
BACKGROUND
Suicide is a complex, serious and multifaceted public health issue that poses significant challenges to societies worldwide. In fact, it represen...
Po koncu: žalovanje in reintegracija bližnjih po samomoru
Po koncu: žalovanje in reintegracija bližnjih po samomoru
Suicide is one of the biggest social and public health problems. Every year about 450 Slovenians and about 800,000 people around the world die by suicide. Suicide represents a sign...
Mental Health and Suicide Decriminalization: Connecting the Dots
Mental Health and Suicide Decriminalization: Connecting the Dots
Suicide is a current public health crisis as every year, more than 800,000 individuals die by suicide worldwide. According to World Health Organization (WHO) estimates, 77% of thes...
Suicide and all-cause mortality in Swedish deployed military veterans: a population-based matched cohort study
Suicide and all-cause mortality in Swedish deployed military veterans: a population-based matched cohort study
Objective
To investigate suicide and mortality risk in deployed military veterans versus non-deployed comparators who had gone through military conscription tes...
Trend and gender-based association of the Bangladeshi student suicide during the COVID-19 pandemic: a GIS-based nationwide distribution
Trend and gender-based association of the Bangladeshi student suicide during the COVID-19 pandemic: a GIS-based nationwide distribution
Background:
Students are one of the most vulnerable groups to suicide. Before the COVID-19 pandemic, a Bangladeshi study was conducted assessing their suicide p...
DEVELOPMENT OF LOGISTICS SUPPORT OF THE NATIONAL GUARD OF UKRAINE ON THE BASIS OF ONTOLOGICAL APPROACH
DEVELOPMENT OF LOGISTICS SUPPORT OF THE NATIONAL GUARD OF UKRAINE ON THE BASIS OF ONTOLOGICAL APPROACH
The article shows that in the context of repulsing the full-scale aggression of the Russian Federation against Ukraine, the National Guard of Ukraine does not have an information a...
Tingkat Stres Berdasarkan Jenis Stresor Pada Mahasiswa Tingkat Akhir Tahap Akademik Fakultas Kedokteran Unisba
Tingkat Stres Berdasarkan Jenis Stresor Pada Mahasiswa Tingkat Akhir Tahap Akademik Fakultas Kedokteran Unisba
Abstract. Stress is a common phenomenon and cannot be avoided by everyone. Stress is an unpleasant condition and can elicit a response be it mental, physical, emotional, and spirit...
Rimska obitelj na grobnim natpisima iz Donje Panonije tijekom principata
Rimska obitelj na grobnim natpisima iz Donje Panonije tijekom principata
This thesis is a study of the Roman family in the province of Lower Pannonia. It investigates the importance of familial and non-familial relationships attested on funerary inscrip...

