Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Irritancy ranking of 31 cleansers in the Indian market in a 24‐h patch test

View through CrossRef
SynopsisCleansing trends promise freshness, sensory and health benefits but may also be accompanied by an increase in soap‐induced skin irritation. The aim of this study was to evaluate the irritant effect of 31 cleansers (28 bar soaps and 3 liquid cleansers) available in the Indian market. Eight percent w/v solutions of the soaps/cleansers were made and 30 μL of each of the solutions were applied to Finn chambers and occluded for 24 h along with distilled water (negative control) and 20% sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS) as positive control. The sites were graded for erythema and scaling 30 min after removing the patches. The pH of each of the soap solutions was determined. Mean with SD and ANOVA (F‐value) was computed separately for each soap/cleanser with respect to the two parameters, erythema and scaling. The total of the means for both the parameters, erythema and scaling was also computed. The cleansers were listed based on this total from the least irritant to the most irritant. The differences between soaps (F‐value) was significant for erythema and scaling [erythema = 4.106 (P = 0.000); scaling = 6.006 (P = 0.000)]. Cetaphil cleansing lotion had the lowest erythema score of 0.25. Lowest scaling score of zero was recorded for Cetaphil cleansing lotion and Elovera moisturizing body wash. Aquasoft and Lifebuoy soaps had the highest erythema score of 2.13. Acnex had the highest scaling score of 1.75; Aquasoft, Hamam scrub bath soap and Naturepower sandal soaps were the next with a scaling score of 1.63. Cetaphil cleansing lotion, Aquaderm liquid soap, Dove bar soap and Elovera moisturizing body wash proved to be the least irritant cleansers with a total score of less than 1. The four most irritant soaps/cleansers had an average score of 3.65. The irritant potential of the majority of the cleansers fell between these extremes. The pH of all the soap/cleanser solutions was neutral to alkaline (pH 7–9) except that of Dove bar, Cetaphil cleansing lotion, Aquaderm liquid soap and Elovera moisturizing body wash which tested acidic (pH 5–6). The pH of the positive control—20% SDS, was acidic (pH 6). The difference in the irritancy potential between soaps/cleansers as determined by the 24‐h patch test was significant. There were individual variations in the irritant potential of the soaps/cleansers in the volunteers, thus when the patient queries on what soap to use, it may be advisable to test each patient separately and educate him/her regarding the soaps/cleansers less likely to cause irritation. The limitations of the study was that it was single blind and non‐randomized as all the 14 soap solutions were applied on 15 volunteers in the first panel and subsequently all the 17 soap solutions were applied on eight volunteers in the second panel. However, we could compare the irritant potential of 31 cleansers. The results of 24‐h patch testing of 31 soaps/cleansers in the Indian market in two panels of 14 and 17 soaps/cleansers on 15 and eight volunteers, respectively, are presented.
Title: Irritancy ranking of 31 cleansers in the Indian market in a 24‐h patch test
Description:
SynopsisCleansing trends promise freshness, sensory and health benefits but may also be accompanied by an increase in soap‐induced skin irritation.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the irritant effect of 31 cleansers (28 bar soaps and 3 liquid cleansers) available in the Indian market.
Eight percent w/v solutions of the soaps/cleansers were made and 30 μL of each of the solutions were applied to Finn chambers and occluded for 24 h along with distilled water (negative control) and 20% sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS) as positive control.
The sites were graded for erythema and scaling 30 min after removing the patches.
The pH of each of the soap solutions was determined.
Mean with SD and ANOVA (F‐value) was computed separately for each soap/cleanser with respect to the two parameters, erythema and scaling.
The total of the means for both the parameters, erythema and scaling was also computed.
The cleansers were listed based on this total from the least irritant to the most irritant.
The differences between soaps (F‐value) was significant for erythema and scaling [erythema = 4.
106 (P = 0.
000); scaling = 6.
006 (P = 0.
000)].
Cetaphil cleansing lotion had the lowest erythema score of 0.
25.
Lowest scaling score of zero was recorded for Cetaphil cleansing lotion and Elovera moisturizing body wash.
Aquasoft and Lifebuoy soaps had the highest erythema score of 2.
13.
Acnex had the highest scaling score of 1.
75; Aquasoft, Hamam scrub bath soap and Naturepower sandal soaps were the next with a scaling score of 1.
63.
Cetaphil cleansing lotion, Aquaderm liquid soap, Dove bar soap and Elovera moisturizing body wash proved to be the least irritant cleansers with a total score of less than 1.
The four most irritant soaps/cleansers had an average score of 3.
65.
The irritant potential of the majority of the cleansers fell between these extremes.
The pH of all the soap/cleanser solutions was neutral to alkaline (pH 7–9) except that of Dove bar, Cetaphil cleansing lotion, Aquaderm liquid soap and Elovera moisturizing body wash which tested acidic (pH 5–6).
The pH of the positive control—20% SDS, was acidic (pH 6).
The difference in the irritancy potential between soaps/cleansers as determined by the 24‐h patch test was significant.
There were individual variations in the irritant potential of the soaps/cleansers in the volunteers, thus when the patient queries on what soap to use, it may be advisable to test each patient separately and educate him/her regarding the soaps/cleansers less likely to cause irritation.
The limitations of the study was that it was single blind and non‐randomized as all the 14 soap solutions were applied on 15 volunteers in the first panel and subsequently all the 17 soap solutions were applied on eight volunteers in the second panel.
However, we could compare the irritant potential of 31 cleansers.
The results of 24‐h patch testing of 31 soaps/cleansers in the Indian market in two panels of 14 and 17 soaps/cleansers on 15 and eight volunteers, respectively, are presented.

Related Results

Evaluation of skin irritancy of sodium lauryl sulphate: a comparative study between the replica method and visual evaluation
Evaluation of skin irritancy of sodium lauryl sulphate: a comparative study between the replica method and visual evaluation
For 20 years, using the replica method, we have evaluated the Stun irritancy of about 10.0UO commercial products which come into contact with the skin. In this method, test substan...
The impact of patch encounter rate on patch residence time of female parasitoids increases with patch quality
The impact of patch encounter rate on patch residence time of female parasitoids increases with patch quality
Abstract 1. For animal species that forage on patchily distributed resources, patch time allocation is of prime importance to their reproductive success. Accord...
Refining intra-patch connectivity measures in landscape fragmentation and connectivity indices
Refining intra-patch connectivity measures in landscape fragmentation and connectivity indices
Abstract Context. Measuring intra-patch connectivity, i.e. the connectivity within a habitat patch, is important to evaluate landscape fragmentation and connectivity. Howev...
Reducing Computational Complexity in Vision Transformers Using Patch Slimming
Reducing Computational Complexity in Vision Transformers Using Patch Slimming
Vision Transformers (ViTs) have emerged as a dominant class of deep learning models for image recognition tasks, demonstrating superior performance compared to traditional Convolut...
Rigless Well Intervention Using Tubing Patch Technology Helps Restore Inactive Wells
Rigless Well Intervention Using Tubing Patch Technology Helps Restore Inactive Wells
Abstract This paper provides in-depth analysis of a low-cost solution to economically sustain production and avoid high workover costs. This paper conducts the techn...
Provocative Tests in Diagnosis of Thoracic Outlet Syndrome: A Narrative Review
Provocative Tests in Diagnosis of Thoracic Outlet Syndrome: A Narrative Review
Abstract Thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) is a group of conditions caused by the compression of the neurovascular bundle within the thoracic outlet. It is classified into three main ...
Human Resource Practices In The Organised Retail Sectors
Human Resource Practices In The Organised Retail Sectors
Indian organized retail market is growing at a fast pace due to the boom in the India retail industry. In 2005, the retail industry in India amounted to Rs 10,000 billion accountin...
Water Isolation and Sand Control: Breaking Barriers with Expandable Steel Patch Technology
Water Isolation and Sand Control: Breaking Barriers with Expandable Steel Patch Technology
Abstract This paper describes the design, planning, and successful installation of a fit-for-purpose casing patch to isolate a water producing zone, the subsequent p...

Back to Top