Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

An Empirical Assessment of Climate Change in the Courts: A New Jurisprudence or Business as Usual?

View through CrossRef
While legal scholarship seeking to assess the impact of litigation on the direction of climate change policy is abundant and growing in leaps and bounds, to date it has relied on and examined only small, isolated pieces of the vast litigation landscape. Without a complete picture of what has and has not been within the sweep of climate change litigation, it is difficult to offer a robust evaluation of the past, present, and future of climate change jurisprudence. Based on a comprehensive empirical study of the status of all (201) climate change litigation matters filed through 2010, this Article is the first to fill those gaps and assess the state of play of climate change in the courts. We conclude that the story of climate change in the courts has not been one of courts forging a new jurisprudence, but rather of judicial business as usual. Part I of the Article outlines the scope of climate change litigation, explaining what qualifies as climate change litigation in our study, our methodology for identifying and coding case attributes, and our typology of the claims that have been or likely will be made as climate change moves relentlessly forward. Part II of the Article then presents and assesses the major theme revealed from our empirical study and largely missing from commentary on climate change litigation - that a siege-like battle between “pro” and “anti” regulation interests has led to an increasingly robust and complex litigation landscape but with mixed results for both sides. Drawing from those findings, Part III of the Article takes on a set of empirical and normative questions designed to summarize and assess the climate change litigation experience and its impacts on the content and institutions of climate policy. It is evident at all levels of inquiry that courts have taken a business as usual approach to climate change, resisting litigants’ attempts to make courts a locus of direct policy making, but the courts nevertheless have influenced the policy content and its institutional contours dramatically. We extract these themes from the full experience of climate change litigation and suggest fruitful paths of research to develop a better understanding of the role and impact of the courts in the climate change policy arena. In Part IV of the Article we stretch a bit from the confines of our empirical study and findings to speculate about the future of climate change litigation.
Title: An Empirical Assessment of Climate Change in the Courts: A New Jurisprudence or Business as Usual?
Description:
While legal scholarship seeking to assess the impact of litigation on the direction of climate change policy is abundant and growing in leaps and bounds, to date it has relied on and examined only small, isolated pieces of the vast litigation landscape.
Without a complete picture of what has and has not been within the sweep of climate change litigation, it is difficult to offer a robust evaluation of the past, present, and future of climate change jurisprudence.
Based on a comprehensive empirical study of the status of all (201) climate change litigation matters filed through 2010, this Article is the first to fill those gaps and assess the state of play of climate change in the courts.
We conclude that the story of climate change in the courts has not been one of courts forging a new jurisprudence, but rather of judicial business as usual.
Part I of the Article outlines the scope of climate change litigation, explaining what qualifies as climate change litigation in our study, our methodology for identifying and coding case attributes, and our typology of the claims that have been or likely will be made as climate change moves relentlessly forward.
Part II of the Article then presents and assesses the major theme revealed from our empirical study and largely missing from commentary on climate change litigation - that a siege-like battle between “pro” and “anti” regulation interests has led to an increasingly robust and complex litigation landscape but with mixed results for both sides.
Drawing from those findings, Part III of the Article takes on a set of empirical and normative questions designed to summarize and assess the climate change litigation experience and its impacts on the content and institutions of climate policy.
It is evident at all levels of inquiry that courts have taken a business as usual approach to climate change, resisting litigants’ attempts to make courts a locus of direct policy making, but the courts nevertheless have influenced the policy content and its institutional contours dramatically.
We extract these themes from the full experience of climate change litigation and suggest fruitful paths of research to develop a better understanding of the role and impact of the courts in the climate change policy arena.
In Part IV of the Article we stretch a bit from the confines of our empirical study and findings to speculate about the future of climate change litigation.

Related Results

“The Earth Is Dying, Bro”
“The Earth Is Dying, Bro”
Climate Change and Children Australian children are uniquely situated in a vast landscape that varies drastically across locations. Spanning multiple climatic zones—from cool tempe...
Climate and Culture
Climate and Culture
Climate is, presently, a heatedly discussed topic. Concerns about the environmental, economic, political and social consequences of climate change are of central interest in academ...
Ethics of climate change : a normative account
Ethics of climate change : a normative account
Consider, for instance, you and your family have lived around a place where you enjoyed the flora and fauna of the land as well as the natural environment. Fishing and farming were...
Adaptation of storm sewer systems to climate change
Adaptation of storm sewer systems to climate change
According to the United Nations (2017), more than the half of the world’s population lives in urban and semi-urban areas. As a result, urban areas are becoming larger, denser and m...
Response to Climate Crisis and the Role of Public Law
Response to Climate Crisis and the Role of Public Law
The state and local governments are implementing emissions trading systems and carbon neutral policies to reduce greenhouse gases. Nevertheless, the Earth is facing a climate crisi...
A Synergistic Imperative: An Integrated Policy and Education Framework for Navigating the Climate Nexus
A Synergistic Imperative: An Integrated Policy and Education Framework for Navigating the Climate Nexus
Climate change acts as a systemic multiplier of threats, exacerbating interconnected global crises that jeopardize food security, biodiversity, and environmental health. These chal...
The Political Economy of Climate Change Winners
The Political Economy of Climate Change Winners
Many people and businesses in the United States stand to receive market and nonmarket benefits from climate change as it moves forward over the next 100 years. Speaking of climate ...
“Lavender Haze” in the Airways
“Lavender Haze” in the Airways
Introduction Taylor Swift has dominated global press in recent years through the success of her Eras Tour, her use of authenticity in branding (Khanal 234), and her choreographed e...

Back to Top