Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Putting down the revolt: Enactivism as a philosophy of nature
View through CrossRef
Enactivists frequently argue their account heralds a revolution in cognitive science: enactivism will unseat cognitivism as the dominant paradigm. We examine the lines of reasoning enactivists employ in stirring revolt, but show that none of these prove compelling reasons for cognitivism to be replaced by enactivism. First, we examine thehard sellof enactivism: enactivism reveals a critical explanatory gap at the heart of cognitivism. We show that enactivism does not meet the requirements to incite a paradigm shift in the Kuhnian sense—there is no internal crisis in cognitivism. Nor does it provide inherently better explanations of cognition as some have claimed. Second, we consider thesoft sellof enactivism: enactivism provides a more attractive, parsimonious, or clear-eyed lens on cognition. This move proves to boil down to a misunderstanding of how theories are selected in science. Instead we lend support to a broader and more desirable way to conceive of enactivism, the recent proposal that enactivism is aphilosophy of nature. We explain how a philosophy of nature does more than support a single research paradigm by integrating scientific questions into a cohesive picture.
Title: Putting down the revolt: Enactivism as a philosophy of nature
Description:
Enactivists frequently argue their account heralds a revolution in cognitive science: enactivism will unseat cognitivism as the dominant paradigm.
We examine the lines of reasoning enactivists employ in stirring revolt, but show that none of these prove compelling reasons for cognitivism to be replaced by enactivism.
First, we examine thehard sellof enactivism: enactivism reveals a critical explanatory gap at the heart of cognitivism.
We show that enactivism does not meet the requirements to incite a paradigm shift in the Kuhnian sense—there is no internal crisis in cognitivism.
Nor does it provide inherently better explanations of cognition as some have claimed.
Second, we consider thesoft sellof enactivism: enactivism provides a more attractive, parsimonious, or clear-eyed lens on cognition.
This move proves to boil down to a misunderstanding of how theories are selected in science.
Instead we lend support to a broader and more desirable way to conceive of enactivism, the recent proposal that enactivism is aphilosophy of nature.
We explain how a philosophy of nature does more than support a single research paradigm by integrating scientific questions into a cohesive picture.
Related Results
What is Analytic Philosophy
What is Analytic Philosophy
Special Issue: What is Analytic PhilosophyReferencesHaaparantaG. P. Baker and P. M. S. Hacker. Frege: Logical Excavations. Oxford, Blackwell, 1984.M. Dummett. The Interpretation of...
/r/philosophy 2016-2017 AMA Series Recap + Survey!
/r/philosophy 2016-2017 AMA Series Recap + Survey!
This past academic year the moderators of /r/philosophy organised an
ongoing AMA series with 18 different philosophers working on a variety
of different topics, from metaphysics to...
Escaping the Shadow
Escaping the Shadow
Photo by Karl Raymund Catabas on Unsplash
The interests of patients at most levels of policymaking are represented by a disconnected patchwork of groups … “After Buddha was dead, ...
Enactive Cognition and the Other: Enactivism and Levinas Meet Halfway
Enactive Cognition and the Other: Enactivism and Levinas Meet Halfway
This paper makes a comparison between enactivism and Levinas’ philosophy. Enactivism is a recent development in philosophy of mind and cognitive science that generally defines cogn...
Artificial Intelligence and Engineering: Philosophical and Scientific Perspectives in the New Era
Artificial Intelligence and Engineering: Philosophical and Scientific Perspectives in the New Era
In this work, a general definition, meaning, and importance of engineering are expressed generally, and the main branches of engineering are briefly discussed. The concept of techn...
Natural philosophy, medieval
Natural philosophy, medieval
Medieval Latin natural philosophy falls into two main periods, before the rise of the universities (mainly in the twelfth century, when works were produced in connection with arist...
Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich (1770–1831)
Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich (1770–1831)
Hegel was the last of the main representatives of a philosophical movement known as German Idealism, which developed towards the end of the eighteenth century primarily as a reacti...
Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich (1770–1831)
Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich (1770–1831)
Hegel was the last of the main representatives of a philosophical movement known as German Idealism, which developed towards the end of the eighteenth century primarily as a reacti...

