Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Aesthetic attitude
View through CrossRef
It is undeniable that there are aesthetic and non-aesthetic attitudes. But is there such a thing as the aesthetic attitude? What is meant by the aesthetic attitude is the particular way in which we regard something when and only when we take an aesthetic interest in it. This assumes that on all occasions of aesthetic interest the object attended to is regarded in an identical fashion, unique to such occasions; and this assumption is problematic. If an attitude’s identity is determined by the features it is directed towards; if an aesthetic interest in an object is (by definition) an interest in its aesthetic qualities; and if the notion of aesthetic qualities can be explained in a uniform manner; then there is a unitary aesthetic attitude, namely an interest in an item’s aesthetic qualities. But this conception of the aesthetic attitude would be unsuitable for achieving the main aim of those who have posited the aesthetic attitude. This aim is to provide a definition of the aesthetic, but the aesthetic attitude, understood as any attitude focused upon an object’s aesthetic qualities, presupposes the idea of the aesthetic, and cannot be used to analyse it. So the question is whether there is a characterization of the aesthetic attitude that describes its nature without explicitly or implicitly relying on the concept of the aesthetic. There is no good reason to suppose so. Accordingly, there is no such thing as the aesthetic attitude, if this is an attitude that is both necessary and sufficient for aesthetic interest and that can be characterized independently of the aesthetic.
Title: Aesthetic attitude
Description:
It is undeniable that there are aesthetic and non-aesthetic attitudes.
But is there such a thing as the aesthetic attitude? What is meant by the aesthetic attitude is the particular way in which we regard something when and only when we take an aesthetic interest in it.
This assumes that on all occasions of aesthetic interest the object attended to is regarded in an identical fashion, unique to such occasions; and this assumption is problematic.
If an attitude’s identity is determined by the features it is directed towards; if an aesthetic interest in an object is (by definition) an interest in its aesthetic qualities; and if the notion of aesthetic qualities can be explained in a uniform manner; then there is a unitary aesthetic attitude, namely an interest in an item’s aesthetic qualities.
But this conception of the aesthetic attitude would be unsuitable for achieving the main aim of those who have posited the aesthetic attitude.
This aim is to provide a definition of the aesthetic, but the aesthetic attitude, understood as any attitude focused upon an object’s aesthetic qualities, presupposes the idea of the aesthetic, and cannot be used to analyse it.
So the question is whether there is a characterization of the aesthetic attitude that describes its nature without explicitly or implicitly relying on the concept of the aesthetic.
There is no good reason to suppose so.
Accordingly, there is no such thing as the aesthetic attitude, if this is an attitude that is both necessary and sufficient for aesthetic interest and that can be characterized independently of the aesthetic.
Related Results
Extending Post-Interpretive Criticism: Additional Diagnostic Indices for Enhanced Phenomenological Fidelity in Art Criticism
Extending Post-Interpretive Criticism: Additional Diagnostic Indices for Enhanced Phenomenological Fidelity in Art Criticism
This paper extends Post-Interpretive Criticism (PIC) by introducing a second layer of diagnostic indices designed to evaluate the phenomenological fidelity of art criticism. While ...
A Study on the Innovative Development Path of Higher Aesthetic Education in Greater Bay Area from the Perspective of Cultural Confidence
A Study on the Innovative Development Path of Higher Aesthetic Education in Greater Bay Area from the Perspective of Cultural Confidence
To build the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area into an international education demonstration plot is inseparable from the innovative development of higher aesthetic educat...
Grammer of Grief
Grammer of Grief
This essay investigates the relationship between mourning and linguistic structure, proposing that grief produces not merely emotional disruption but a reconfiguration of grammar i...
Integrating the UMA and CM Models to Explain Aesthetic Judgement in Closed-Category Product Design: A Laptop Product Study
Integrating the UMA and CM Models to Explain Aesthetic Judgement in Closed-Category Product Design: A Laptop Product Study
Background Aesthetic design significantly influences user perception and purchasing decisions, increasingly shaping market competitiveness. However, most studies on aesthetic prefe...
Peran Impulsive Behavior dan E-Marketing Exposure Terhadap Post Purchase Regret Saat Berbelanja Online
Peran Impulsive Behavior dan E-Marketing Exposure Terhadap Post Purchase Regret Saat Berbelanja Online
Post purchase regret is of particular concern to companies or sellers because it can be a reason for giving negative reviews of products or stores, not wanting to shop again and ...
I. Kant: How is aesthetic possible?
I. Kant: How is aesthetic possible?
The subject of the research is the ways of substantiating the fundamental concept of aesthetic science -- the category of aesthetic in Kant's philosophy. The author examines such a...
Measuring Proximity: A Post-Interpretive Diagnostic Experiment in Art Criticism A Diagnostic Lens on Ethical Witnessing in Art Criticism
Measuring Proximity: A Post-Interpretive Diagnostic Experiment in Art Criticism A Diagnostic Lens on Ethical Witnessing in Art Criticism
Contemporary art criticism often advances by way of interpretive extraction. Works are translated into meanings, themes, intentions, and arguments, which then circulate with remark...
Explaining Aesthetic Judgement in Closed-Category Product Design through the Unified Model of Aesthetics and the Categorical-Motivation Model: A Laptop Product Study
Explaining Aesthetic Judgement in Closed-Category Product Design through the Unified Model of Aesthetics and the Categorical-Motivation Model: A Laptop Product Study
Background Aesthetic design significantly influences user perception and purchasing decisions, increasingly shaping market competitiveness. However, most studies on aesthetic prefe...

