Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Constitutional Constraints on Punitive Damages: Clarity, Consistency, and the Outlier Dilemma
View through CrossRef
A substantial amount of recent legal scholarship has been devoted to the pros and cons of the U.S. Supreme Court’s new constitutional jurisprudence designed to catch and correct arbitrary and/or excessive punitive damages awards. This constitututionalization of punitive damages law is expressly based on a substantive due process principle guaranteeing even egregious wrongdoers “fair notice” of the possible financial consequences of their misconduct. Virtually none of this scholarship, however, addresses the empirical question: How is the intended reform working – are lower American courts implementing the three constitutional guideposts effectively and in the way the Supreme Court contemplated? In this paper we examine the recent ten years of punitive damages decisions by state and federal courts (537 cases in all) to try to provide a tentative answer to this question.
Overall, we find that lower courts are doing a conscientious, and at times heroic, job in implementing the guideposts, which the Supreme Court deliberately left imprecise and open to justifiably different interpretations. We conclude that this new punitive damages jurisprudence, focused on the three guideposts, has unquestionably introduced a heretofore lacking degree of uniformity among U.S. courts in the framework and discipline with which they conduct reviews of punitive damages awards. This is a positive development. Not so clear, however, is whether this newly required constitutional review significantly reduces unpredictability in punitive damages awards. Wildly inconsistent punitive damages awards in cases with very similar facts greatly troubled the Court in the judicial run up to adoption of the constitutional guideposts. We examine the extent of continued unpredictability in the cases studied, and suggest reasons to explain why, given the indeterminacy of the guideposts, some inconsistency is to be expected. Finally, if the Supreme Court were to revisit punitive damages law, we suggest improvements that might be made to the guideposts that could help enhance the consistency of punitive damages awards in cases involving similar facts.
Title: Constitutional Constraints on Punitive Damages: Clarity, Consistency, and the Outlier Dilemma
Description:
A substantial amount of recent legal scholarship has been devoted to the pros and cons of the U.
S.
Supreme Court’s new constitutional jurisprudence designed to catch and correct arbitrary and/or excessive punitive damages awards.
This constitututionalization of punitive damages law is expressly based on a substantive due process principle guaranteeing even egregious wrongdoers “fair notice” of the possible financial consequences of their misconduct.
Virtually none of this scholarship, however, addresses the empirical question: How is the intended reform working – are lower American courts implementing the three constitutional guideposts effectively and in the way the Supreme Court contemplated? In this paper we examine the recent ten years of punitive damages decisions by state and federal courts (537 cases in all) to try to provide a tentative answer to this question.
Overall, we find that lower courts are doing a conscientious, and at times heroic, job in implementing the guideposts, which the Supreme Court deliberately left imprecise and open to justifiably different interpretations.
We conclude that this new punitive damages jurisprudence, focused on the three guideposts, has unquestionably introduced a heretofore lacking degree of uniformity among U.
S.
courts in the framework and discipline with which they conduct reviews of punitive damages awards.
This is a positive development.
Not so clear, however, is whether this newly required constitutional review significantly reduces unpredictability in punitive damages awards.
Wildly inconsistent punitive damages awards in cases with very similar facts greatly troubled the Court in the judicial run up to adoption of the constitutional guideposts.
We examine the extent of continued unpredictability in the cases studied, and suggest reasons to explain why, given the indeterminacy of the guideposts, some inconsistency is to be expected.
Finally, if the Supreme Court were to revisit punitive damages law, we suggest improvements that might be made to the guideposts that could help enhance the consistency of punitive damages awards in cases involving similar facts.
Related Results
From Constitutional Comparison to Life in the Biosphere
From Constitutional Comparison to Life in the Biosphere
From Constitutional Comparison to Life in the Biosphere is a monograph that argues for a fundamental reorientation of constitutional law around the realities of biospheric interdep...
Punitive Damages: Should Juries Decide?
Punitive Damages: Should Juries Decide?
How Juries Decide is a pathbreaking work of empirical scholarship based on experiments conducted with more than 8,000 jury-eligible citizens and more than 600 mock juries. Its basi...
Envisioning Originalism Applied to Bioethics Cases
Envisioning Originalism Applied to Bioethics Cases
Photo ID 123697425 © Alexandersikov | Dreamstime.com
Abstract
Originalism is an increasingly prevalent method for interpreting provisions of the US Constitution. It requires strict...
Constitutional Mobilization
Constitutional Mobilization
People around the world are mobilizing for constitutional change. This global phenomenon has been under-explored in comparative constitutional studies. This Article introduces the ...
Pricking the Lines: The Due Process Clause, Punitive Damages and Criminal Punishment
Pricking the Lines: The Due Process Clause, Punitive Damages and Criminal Punishment
The Supreme Court has recently devoted substantial attention to the question of what limits the Constitution places on the permissible amount of punishment. The Court has offered b...
Punitive Damages for Environmental Public Welfare: An Empirical StudyofLegal Attributes and Attribution
Punitive Damages for Environmental Public Welfare: An Empirical StudyofLegal Attributes and Attribution
As an important legal mechanism of local social governance, punitive damages forenvironmental public welfare can have a certain deterrent effect on regional environmentaldamage, so...
Punitive damages under Chinese patent law
Punitive damages under Chinese patent law
In today's society, when the perpetrator's malicious and intentional rights are violated, effective discipline is difficult with only compensatory damages. With the development of ...
Analysis of the Constitutional Court Cases in 2022
Analysis of the Constitutional Court Cases in 2022
The Constitutional Court received a total of 2,829 cases in 2022 alone. Among the decisions made by the Constitutional Court in 2022, this paper reviews major decisions centered on...

