Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Sentinels guarding the grail: Value-added measurement and the quest for education reform
View through CrossRef
Over the past three years, Value-Added Measurement (VAM) has captured the attention of the American public through high-profile media representations of the tool and the controversy that surrounds it. In this paper, we build upon investigations of constructions of VAM in the media and present a discourse analysis of the policymaking process within the meetings of Tennessee’s Teacher Evaluation Advisory Committee (TEAC), a 15-member panel appointed by the Tennessee governor to develop a new teacher evaluation policy under Race to the Top. The data included audiorecordings of public meetings from March, 2010 through the end of the committee’s work in April, 2011. As we analyzed the talk of the TEAC, we oriented to the particular version of VAM worked up within these conversations in relation to a descriptive metaphor in which VAM is compared to a “sentinel of trust.” We present examples to illustrate three patterns in the construction of VAM as the sentinel of trust within teacher evaluation: (1) VAM alone defines effectiveness; (2) VAM is the only objective option; and (3) concerns about VAM are minimized. We discuss the implications of this way of thinking and talking about VAM and contrast it with other possibilities, including those constructed by teachers, researchers, and the media.
Mary Lou Fulton College for Teaching and Learning Innovation
Title: Sentinels guarding the grail: Value-added measurement and the quest for education reform
Description:
Over the past three years, Value-Added Measurement (VAM) has captured the attention of the American public through high-profile media representations of the tool and the controversy that surrounds it.
In this paper, we build upon investigations of constructions of VAM in the media and present a discourse analysis of the policymaking process within the meetings of Tennessee’s Teacher Evaluation Advisory Committee (TEAC), a 15-member panel appointed by the Tennessee governor to develop a new teacher evaluation policy under Race to the Top.
The data included audiorecordings of public meetings from March, 2010 through the end of the committee’s work in April, 2011.
As we analyzed the talk of the TEAC, we oriented to the particular version of VAM worked up within these conversations in relation to a descriptive metaphor in which VAM is compared to a “sentinel of trust.
” We present examples to illustrate three patterns in the construction of VAM as the sentinel of trust within teacher evaluation: (1) VAM alone defines effectiveness; (2) VAM is the only objective option; and (3) concerns about VAM are minimized.
We discuss the implications of this way of thinking and talking about VAM and contrast it with other possibilities, including those constructed by teachers, researchers, and the media.
Related Results
The relationship between guarding, pain, and emotion
The relationship between guarding, pain, and emotion
Abstract
Introduction:
Pain-related behavior in people with chronic pain is often overlooked in a focus on increasing the amount of activity, yet...
The mate-guarding behaviour of male kokanee oncorhynchus nerka
The mate-guarding behaviour of male kokanee oncorhynchus nerka
AbstractThe patterns of mate-guarding in kokanee (non-anadromous Oncorhynchus nerka) are analysed and discussed in relation to existing theory of precopulatory mate-guarding. Male ...
Competition over guarding in the Arabian babbler (Turdoides squamiceps), a cooperative breeder
Competition over guarding in the Arabian babbler (Turdoides squamiceps), a cooperative breeder
Observations on 12 groups comprised of two adult males and one adult female (some included one or two fledglings), tame, individually marked, Arabian babblers (
...
Competition over guarding in the Arabian babbler (Turdoides squamiceps), a cooperative breeder
Competition over guarding in the Arabian babbler (Turdoides squamiceps), a cooperative breeder
Observations on 12 groups comprised of two adult males and one adult female (some included one or two fledglings), tame, individually marked, Arabian babblers (
...
Investigating Lunar Ionosphere Using GRAIL Radio Science Signals
Investigating Lunar Ionosphere Using GRAIL Radio Science Signals
The nature of the dense lunar ionosphere is controversial; the maximum electron density values in observed vertical profiles obtained from previous Lunar missions vary by two order...
Gemstone of Paradise
Gemstone of Paradise
Abstract
The story of the Grail, usually identified as some kind of mystical vessel, has gripped the imaginations of millions since it first appeared in several medi...
Effect of frequency difference deviation on full-field heterodyne measurement accuracy
Effect of frequency difference deviation on full-field heterodyne measurement accuracy
With the advantages of high precision and great environmental adaptability, laser heterodyne interferometry has been successfullyused in some areas, such as measuring distance and ...

