Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Data-Centric Versus Algorithm-Centric Machine Learning Approaches: A Systematic Review of Comparative Effectiveness and Evaluation Frameworks
View through CrossRef
Machine learning research has traditionally emphasised algorithmic innovation as the main driver of performance improvement, with advances in model architecture, optimisation, and hyperparameter tuning shaping progress in computer vision, natural language processing, healthcare, and industrial automation. Recent work, however, has increased attention to data-centric artificial intelligence, which treats training data quality, quantity, and preparation as central determinants of model performance. Despite this growing interest, there remains limited agreement on how data-centric approaches compare with algorithm-centric methods across domains and evaluation settings. This systematic review synthesised evidence from 44 peer-reviewed studies published between January 2021 and February 2026 to compare the effectiveness of data-centric and algorithm-centric machine learning approaches, identify dominant data engineering techniques, evaluate domain-specific performance outcomes, and assess frameworks used to measure data quality improvements. Following PRISMA guidance, studies were selected from major academic databases and examined through narrative synthesis. The findings indicate that data-centric techniques, including data augmentation, synthetic data generation, preprocessing, feature engineering, and annotation refinement, consistently improved model performance, particularly in low-data settings and highly imbalanced datasets. Several studies reported that data-centric interventions equalled or exceeded algorithm-centric modifications while requiring fewer computational resources. Healthcare showed the most frequent and substantial benefits from data-centric approaches, followed by manufacturing, environmental science, and cybersecurity. The review also identified an important methodological gap, as relatively few studies used standardised frameworks or rigorous statistical validation to evaluate data quality improvements directly. The study concludes that data-centric and algorithm-centric approaches should be understood as complementary rather than competing paradigms and that standardised evaluation methods are needed to clarify the contribution of data quality to machine learning performance.
Sciencedomain International
Title: Data-Centric Versus Algorithm-Centric Machine Learning Approaches: A Systematic Review of Comparative Effectiveness and Evaluation Frameworks
Description:
Machine learning research has traditionally emphasised algorithmic innovation as the main driver of performance improvement, with advances in model architecture, optimisation, and hyperparameter tuning shaping progress in computer vision, natural language processing, healthcare, and industrial automation.
Recent work, however, has increased attention to data-centric artificial intelligence, which treats training data quality, quantity, and preparation as central determinants of model performance.
Despite this growing interest, there remains limited agreement on how data-centric approaches compare with algorithm-centric methods across domains and evaluation settings.
This systematic review synthesised evidence from 44 peer-reviewed studies published between January 2021 and February 2026 to compare the effectiveness of data-centric and algorithm-centric machine learning approaches, identify dominant data engineering techniques, evaluate domain-specific performance outcomes, and assess frameworks used to measure data quality improvements.
Following PRISMA guidance, studies were selected from major academic databases and examined through narrative synthesis.
The findings indicate that data-centric techniques, including data augmentation, synthetic data generation, preprocessing, feature engineering, and annotation refinement, consistently improved model performance, particularly in low-data settings and highly imbalanced datasets.
Several studies reported that data-centric interventions equalled or exceeded algorithm-centric modifications while requiring fewer computational resources.
Healthcare showed the most frequent and substantial benefits from data-centric approaches, followed by manufacturing, environmental science, and cybersecurity.
The review also identified an important methodological gap, as relatively few studies used standardised frameworks or rigorous statistical validation to evaluate data quality improvements directly.
The study concludes that data-centric and algorithm-centric approaches should be understood as complementary rather than competing paradigms and that standardised evaluation methods are needed to clarify the contribution of data quality to machine learning performance.
Related Results
Evaluating the Science to Inform the Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans Midcourse Report
Evaluating the Science to Inform the Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans Midcourse Report
Abstract
The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans (Guidelines) advises older adults to be as active as possible. Yet, despite the well documented benefits of physical activi...
Non-Recommended Publishing Lists: Strategies for Detecting Deceitful Journals
Non-Recommended Publishing Lists: Strategies for Detecting Deceitful Journals
Abstract
The rapid growth of open access publishing (OAP) has significantly improved the accessibility and dissemination of scientific knowledge. However, this expansion has also c...
Primerjalna književnost na prelomu tisočletja
Primerjalna književnost na prelomu tisočletja
In a comprehensive and at times critical manner, this volume seeks to shed light on the development of events in Western (i.e., European and North American) comparative literature ...
Cash‐based approaches in humanitarian emergencies: a systematic review
Cash‐based approaches in humanitarian emergencies: a systematic review
This Campbell systematic review examines the effectiveness, efficiency and implementation of cash transfers in humanitarian settings. The review summarises evidence from five studi...
Selection of Injectable Drug Product Composition using Machine Learning Models (Preprint)
Selection of Injectable Drug Product Composition using Machine Learning Models (Preprint)
BACKGROUND
As of July 2020, a Web of Science search of “machine learning (ML)” nested within the search of “pharmacokinetics or pharmacodynamics” yielded over 100...
Do evidence summaries increase health policy‐makers' use of evidence from systematic reviews? A systematic review
Do evidence summaries increase health policy‐makers' use of evidence from systematic reviews? A systematic review
This review summarizes the evidence from six randomized controlled trials that judged the effectiveness of systematic review summaries on policymakers' decision making, or the most...
CREATING LEARNING MEDIA IN TEACHING ENGLISH AT SMP MUHAMMADIYAH 2 PAGELARAN ACADEMIC YEAR 2020/2021
CREATING LEARNING MEDIA IN TEACHING ENGLISH AT SMP MUHAMMADIYAH 2 PAGELARAN ACADEMIC YEAR 2020/2021
The pandemic Covid-19 currently demands teachers to be able to use technology in teaching and learning process. But in reality there are still many teachers who have not been able ...
A meta-evaluation of sustainable land management Initiatives in Senegal
A meta-evaluation of sustainable land management Initiatives in Senegal
Evaluation is the systematic determination of the merit, worth and significance of a programme, initiative or intervention. As a young discipline, its empirical study is still limi...

