Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Musical Evidence for Low Boundary Tones in Ancient Greek
View through CrossRef
Abstract
Several scholars have suggested that in ancient Greek there was a low boundary tone at the end of a relatively small prosodic constituent such as a clitic group or maximal prosodic word. The boundary tone may phonologically motivate some puzzling pitch-accentual phenomena in the language. One is the diachronic pitch-peak retraction that led to the circumflex pitch accent (HL) on penultimate syllables (the “sōtêra rule”). Another is the intonational phrase-internal downstepping or deletion of a word-final acute accent (H); that conversion of an acute to a grave accent is known as “lulling” or “koímēsis”. If such a low boundary tone existed, its effects should still be audible in ancient Greek non-strophic vocal music, where there is a significant correlation between the pitch movement of the text and the movement of the melody to which it is set, i.e. between tone and tune. Specifically, proponents of such a low boundary tone would predict that the turning point between falling and rising melody, the “musical trough”, should center around the word-final mora or syllable. The present study provides the first full description of troughs in the Delphic Hymns and finds that they are indeed closely aligned with word-end. Furthermore, once other factors that could lead to word-final troughs are set aside, i.e. once potential confounds are controlled for, the association of the trough with word-end remains strong, suggesting that we should in fact reconstruct the low boundary tone.
Title: Musical Evidence for Low Boundary Tones in Ancient Greek
Description:
Abstract
Several scholars have suggested that in ancient Greek there was a low boundary tone at the end of a relatively small prosodic constituent such as a clitic group or maximal prosodic word.
The boundary tone may phonologically motivate some puzzling pitch-accentual phenomena in the language.
One is the diachronic pitch-peak retraction that led to the circumflex pitch accent (HL) on penultimate syllables (the “sōtêra rule”).
Another is the intonational phrase-internal downstepping or deletion of a word-final acute accent (H); that conversion of an acute to a grave accent is known as “lulling” or “koímēsis”.
If such a low boundary tone existed, its effects should still be audible in ancient Greek non-strophic vocal music, where there is a significant correlation between the pitch movement of the text and the movement of the melody to which it is set, i.
e.
between tone and tune.
Specifically, proponents of such a low boundary tone would predict that the turning point between falling and rising melody, the “musical trough”, should center around the word-final mora or syllable.
The present study provides the first full description of troughs in the Delphic Hymns and finds that they are indeed closely aligned with word-end.
Furthermore, once other factors that could lead to word-final troughs are set aside, i.
e.
once potential confounds are controlled for, the association of the trough with word-end remains strong, suggesting that we should in fact reconstruct the low boundary tone.
Related Results
Low-high-low or high-low-high? Pattern effects on sequential auditory scene analysis
Low-high-low or high-low-high? Pattern effects on sequential auditory scene analysis
Sequential auditory scene analysis (ASA) is often studied using sequences of two alternating tones, such as ABAB or ABA_, with “_” denoting a silent gap, and “A” and “B” sine tones...
Surrogate Speech of the Asante Ivory Trumpeters of Ghana
Surrogate Speech of the Asante Ivory Trumpeters of Ghana
Surrogate speech is a phonological system by which word tones of a spoken language are represented in tones produced on a musical instrument. Ethnomusicologists regard this as a mu...
Multi-scale Modelling of Segmentation
Multi-scale Modelling of Segmentation
While listening to music, people often unwittingly break down musical pieces into constituent chunks such as verses and choruses. Music segmentation studies have suggested that som...
Estimates of Maize Plant Density from UAV RGB Images Using Faster-RCNN Detection Model: Impact of the Spatial Resolution
Estimates of Maize Plant Density from UAV RGB Images Using Faster-RCNN Detection Model: Impact of the Spatial Resolution
Early-stage plant density is an essential trait that determines the fate of a genotype under given environmental conditions and management practices. The use of RGB images taken fr...
Effects on Threshold Sensitivity of Exposing the Normal Ear to Pure Tones and White Noise over Sensation Levels of 10 db to 100 db
Effects on Threshold Sensitivity of Exposing the Normal Ear to Pure Tones and White Noise over Sensation Levels of 10 db to 100 db
By means of a modified Békésy Audiometer, with which it is possible to measure a temporary threshold shift (TTS) resulting from a sound exposure within a few seconds after terminat...
Revisiting “Color Names and Color Notions”
Revisiting “Color Names and Color Notions”
Employing the pioneering work of Charles Parrish as a basis of comparison, this study serves as a follow-up to “Color Names and Color Notions” by deconstructing the contemporary la...
Enacting the social relations of science: historical (anti-)boundary-work of Danish science journalist Børge Michelsen
Enacting the social relations of science: historical (anti-)boundary-work of Danish science journalist Børge Michelsen
This article investigates the writings of Danish science journalist Børge Michelsen from 1939 to 1956. As part of the international social relations of science movement in the peri...
Statistical evidence and the criminal verdict asymmetry
Statistical evidence and the criminal verdict asymmetry
AbstractEpistemologists have posed the following puzzle, known as the proof paradox: Why is it intuitively problematic for juries to convict on the basis of statistical evidence an...