Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Challenges to Amish Settlement
View through CrossRef
This chapter talks about how not all the Amish who have come to New York have been successful in their attempt to settle there. At least six Amish settlements in New York State alone have become extinct since 1950, namely the settlements in Sinclairville (Chautauqua County, 1950–1960); Clyde (Wayne County, 1979–1999); Newport (Herkimer County, 1979–2003); Dundee (Yates County, 1981–1988); Albion (Orleans County, 1986–1996); and Poland (Herkimer County, 2002–2007). Amish settlements are, for the most part, individual enterprises, undertaken by families acting in concert rather than by groups organized in advance. Ultimately, the success and failure of a settlement is due to circumstances that are peculiar to the group.
Title: Challenges to Amish Settlement
Description:
This chapter talks about how not all the Amish who have come to New York have been successful in their attempt to settle there.
At least six Amish settlements in New York State alone have become extinct since 1950, namely the settlements in Sinclairville (Chautauqua County, 1950–1960); Clyde (Wayne County, 1979–1999); Newport (Herkimer County, 1979–2003); Dundee (Yates County, 1981–1988); Albion (Orleans County, 1986–1996); and Poland (Herkimer County, 2002–2007).
Amish settlements are, for the most part, individual enterprises, undertaken by families acting in concert rather than by groups organized in advance.
Ultimately, the success and failure of a settlement is due to circumstances that are peculiar to the group.
Related Results
New York Amish, 2nd Edition
New York Amish, 2nd Edition
Tracing Amish settlement in New York from the nineteenth century to the twenty-first century, this book draws on more than thirty years of participant-observation, interviews, and ...
The Future of New York’s Amish
The Future of New York’s Amish
This chapter reviews the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Wisconsin v. Yoder et al. and argues that it not only empowered Amish communities, but also encouraged Amish diversity by ...
From Lancaster County to Lowville
From Lancaster County to Lowville
This chapter traces the arrival of four Old Order Amish families from the Path Valley in Pennsylvania to Lowville in Lewis County. More progressive than Swartzentruber and less pro...
Who Are the Amish?
Who Are the Amish?
This chapter discusses how the Amish have been a part of the New York scene for nearly two hundred years. The first Amish settlers to the Empire State came from the French province...
Challenging the Non-Amish Neighbors
Challenging the Non-Amish Neighbors
This chapter describes how, although the majority of Amish settlers have been successful, integration into local life has not always been easy. To this day, many persist in believi...
On Franklin County’s Western Border
On Franklin County’s Western Border
This chapter analyzes how two of the more recent Amish settlements in New York—the Burke settlement in Franklin County and the nearby Swartzentruber settlement founded near Hopkint...
St. Lawrence County’s Swartzentruber Amish
St. Lawrence County’s Swartzentruber Amish
This chapter explores how the Swartzentruber Amish families who began to arrive in New York State in 1974 came because there was affordable land available. Although the availabilit...
The Mohawk Valley Amish
The Mohawk Valley Amish
This chapter examines how other Amish began to think about settling in the Mohawk Valley region—they were motivated primarily by the need for farmland, but were partly attracted by...

