Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Going digital: challenges in monitoring marine megafauna when comparing results from visual and digital aerial surveys

View through CrossRef
Since the first plans to develop offshore wind farms (OWFs), concerns have been raised about the impacts on marine megafauna. Today, it is required to assess these impacts over the whole lifecycle of the OWF. Before construction, initial assessments are often conducted by visual surveys, but subsequent monitoring over the lifecycle of the OWF has to be digital due to safety requirements, leading to challenges in data comparability. The aim of this study was to attempt to establish generalizable intercalibration factors for this transition between visual and digital monitoring methods. To this end, intercalibration surveys were conducted at five different sites and at different times of the year within a site, using both visual monitoring at low-altitude and digital monitoring at both low and high altitudes. We tested the potential for intercalibration of the results based on the ratio of abundance estimated from data collected by the different methods. We explored factors such as the species under study and site-specific conditions that may influence intercalibration. We computed more than 100 intercalibration factors and found that, on average, abundance estimates from digital methods were higher than those from visual methods and that flight altitude for digital monitoring did not significantly influence abundance estimates. Aside from divergent abundance estimates depending on monitoring method, the findings also revealed significant heterogeneity, only one-third of which was explained by contextual factors such as taxonomy or the sea conditions. This outcome presents a pessimistic outlook on the prospect for the intercalibration of results between an initial assessment carried out with visual observations and subsequent monitoring with digital methods after OWF construction and until decommissioning. The high heterogeneity prevents seamless transferability of intercalibration factors and highlights the importance of local context.
Title: Going digital: challenges in monitoring marine megafauna when comparing results from visual and digital aerial surveys
Description:
Since the first plans to develop offshore wind farms (OWFs), concerns have been raised about the impacts on marine megafauna.
Today, it is required to assess these impacts over the whole lifecycle of the OWF.
Before construction, initial assessments are often conducted by visual surveys, but subsequent monitoring over the lifecycle of the OWF has to be digital due to safety requirements, leading to challenges in data comparability.
The aim of this study was to attempt to establish generalizable intercalibration factors for this transition between visual and digital monitoring methods.
To this end, intercalibration surveys were conducted at five different sites and at different times of the year within a site, using both visual monitoring at low-altitude and digital monitoring at both low and high altitudes.
We tested the potential for intercalibration of the results based on the ratio of abundance estimated from data collected by the different methods.
We explored factors such as the species under study and site-specific conditions that may influence intercalibration.
We computed more than 100 intercalibration factors and found that, on average, abundance estimates from digital methods were higher than those from visual methods and that flight altitude for digital monitoring did not significantly influence abundance estimates.
Aside from divergent abundance estimates depending on monitoring method, the findings also revealed significant heterogeneity, only one-third of which was explained by contextual factors such as taxonomy or the sea conditions.
This outcome presents a pessimistic outlook on the prospect for the intercalibration of results between an initial assessment carried out with visual observations and subsequent monitoring with digital methods after OWF construction and until decommissioning.
The high heterogeneity prevents seamless transferability of intercalibration factors and highlights the importance of local context.

Related Results

Climate change, not human population growth, correlates with late Quaternary megafauna declines in North America
Climate change, not human population growth, correlates with late Quaternary megafauna declines in North America
<p>The late Quaternary saw the extinction of a great number of the world’s megafauna (those animals >44 kg), an event unprecedented in 65 million...
Thresholds for the presence of glacial megafauna in central Europe during the last 60,000 years
Thresholds for the presence of glacial megafauna in central Europe during the last 60,000 years
Abstract Lake sediment records from Holzmaar and the infilled maar of Auel (Eifel, Germany) are used to reconstruct landscape changes and meg...
Mechanisms of hunting native megafauna to extinction by Palaeolithic humans on Cyprus
Mechanisms of hunting native megafauna to extinction by Palaeolithic humans on Cyprus
Abstract The hypothesised main drivers of megafauna extinctions in the late Quaternary have wavered between over-exploitation by humans and environmental change, with recen...
Low Genetic Variability in the Geographically Widespread Andean Condor
Low Genetic Variability in the Geographically Widespread Andean Condor
Abstract We characterized DNA sequence variation in the mitochondrial control region and 12S ribosomal subunit for a sample of Andean Condors (Vultur gryphus) rep...
Using recent baselines as benchmarks for megafauna restoration places an unfair burden on the Global South
Using recent baselines as benchmarks for megafauna restoration places an unfair burden on the Global South
Abstract The potential for megafauna restoration is unevenly distributed across the world, along with the socio-political capacity of countries to support these res...
Access Denied
Access Denied
Introduction As social-distancing mandates in response to COVID-19 restricted in-person data collection methods such as participant observation and interviews, researchers turned t...
Typical Marine Ecological Disasters in China Attributed to Marine Organisms and Their Significant Insights
Typical Marine Ecological Disasters in China Attributed to Marine Organisms and Their Significant Insights
Owing to global climate change or the ever-more frequent human activities in the offshore areas, it is highly probable that an imbalance in the offshore ecosystem has been induced....
Research on the dynamic co-evolution of the complex system of economy-innovation-environment of the marine industry in China
Research on the dynamic co-evolution of the complex system of economy-innovation-environment of the marine industry in China
IntroductionIn the context of accelerating the construction of a marine power, relying on scientific and technological innovation to drive the high-quality growth of the marine eco...

Back to Top