Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Burckhardt, Religion, and the ‘Principle of Correction’: From Renaissance to Reformation
View through CrossRef
As a young man, Jacob Burckhardt, son of the highest-ranking Protestant preacher in Basel, started studying theology but then suffered a religious crisis and became a historian. Throughout his life, Burckhardt reflected on the relationships among religion, secularisation, politics, and culture. These thoughts were expressed in his Civilisation of the Renaissance in Italy, but also in his lectures on early modern history. His presentation of the Reformation went strongly against the blueprint of optimistic Protestant historiography. Applying what has been labelled as a ‘principle of correction’, Burckhardt painted a gloomy picture of both the Lutheran Reformation and Calvinism; they were violent and destructive. In addition, Burckhardt also corrected prevalent notions about the Italian Reformation. The Reformation failed in Italy, not because it was suppressed by the Catholic authorities—as was usually assumed—but because Renaissance Italians possessed a mentality that was too ‘modern’ to be able to create new dogmas.
Title: Burckhardt, Religion, and the ‘Principle of Correction’: From Renaissance to Reformation
Description:
As a young man, Jacob Burckhardt, son of the highest-ranking Protestant preacher in Basel, started studying theology but then suffered a religious crisis and became a historian.
Throughout his life, Burckhardt reflected on the relationships among religion, secularisation, politics, and culture.
These thoughts were expressed in his Civilisation of the Renaissance in Italy, but also in his lectures on early modern history.
His presentation of the Reformation went strongly against the blueprint of optimistic Protestant historiography.
Applying what has been labelled as a ‘principle of correction’, Burckhardt painted a gloomy picture of both the Lutheran Reformation and Calvinism; they were violent and destructive.
In addition, Burckhardt also corrected prevalent notions about the Italian Reformation.
The Reformation failed in Italy, not because it was suppressed by the Catholic authorities—as was usually assumed—but because Renaissance Italians possessed a mentality that was too ‘modern’ to be able to create new dogmas.
Related Results
The Reformation
The Reformation
The Reformation of the 16th century, sometimes known as “Protestant Reformation” in order to distinguish it from a Catholic “Reformation,” was a pan-European movement that called f...
Burckhardt’s Beliefs and Renaissance Religions
Burckhardt’s Beliefs and Renaissance Religions
When Jacob Burckhardt framed the Renaissance as an age with a distinct and secularising character it was perhaps inevitable that religion would be seen as marginal, superstitious, ...
The Luther Renaissance
The Luther Renaissance
Abstract
The Luther Renaissance is the most important international network for Luther research, as well as an ecclesial, ecumenical and cultural reform movement ...
The Renaissance
The Renaissance
The whole of the Oxford Bibliographies Renaissance and Reformation module has grown since its inception to embrace the period 1350–1750. That time span includes the period scholars...
Expressions of the Self in Burckhardt’s Renaissance
Expressions of the Self in Burckhardt’s Renaissance
This chapter revisits Jacob Burckhardt’s seminal contention that the Italian Renaissance witnessed the birth of the modern individual. It does so by examining both the book’s genes...
Catholic/Counter-Reformation
Catholic/Counter-Reformation
The traditional terms for the religious changes and upheavals centered in the 16th century were the Reformation and the Counter-Reformation, the first referring to the Protestant R...
‘Renaissance’ and ‘fossilization’: Michelet, Burckhardt, and Huizinga
‘Renaissance’ and ‘fossilization’: Michelet, Burckhardt, and Huizinga
From its very first use, the term ‘Renaissance’ indicated change and renewal. Michelet, in his lectures at the Collège de France in 1840–1841, represented the Renaissance as ‘the f...
A Renaissance Reclaimed: Burckhardt’s Civilisation of the Renaissance Reconsidered
A Renaissance Reclaimed: Burckhardt’s Civilisation of the Renaissance Reconsidered
The conference that led to this volume was convened in 2018 to mark the 200th anniversary of the birth of Jacob Burckhardt, the ‘father of cultural history’. The contributors were ...

