Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Handing IRB an Unloaded Gun
View through CrossRef
The author's autoethnographic article was accepted for publication and then blocked by her Institutional Review Board (IRB). The overt reasons for the “denial of approval” differ from accounts given behind closed doors. By weaving experience, excerpts from her article, and the responses of others into a narrative, the author creates an ongoing performance ethnography that resists the “tacit norm of silence” regarding discussions of incest and student/teacher attraction. Framing autoethnography as a “breach” of the academic norms regarding scientific inquiry helps her make sense of how IRB as a committee used the resources at hand—the existing religious/political context, their identities, their formal roles, and the written rules they had before them—to coconstruct a narrative that rendered her manuscript unpublishable. It is the author's hope that this performance of resistance will help facilitate the creation of a safe, defined space (similar to that of oral history) for autoethnography to occur.
Title: Handing IRB an Unloaded Gun
Description:
The author's autoethnographic article was accepted for publication and then blocked by her Institutional Review Board (IRB).
The overt reasons for the “denial of approval” differ from accounts given behind closed doors.
By weaving experience, excerpts from her article, and the responses of others into a narrative, the author creates an ongoing performance ethnography that resists the “tacit norm of silence” regarding discussions of incest and student/teacher attraction.
Framing autoethnography as a “breach” of the academic norms regarding scientific inquiry helps her make sense of how IRB as a committee used the resources at hand—the existing religious/political context, their identities, their formal roles, and the written rules they had before them—to coconstruct a narrative that rendered her manuscript unpublishable.
It is the author's hope that this performance of resistance will help facilitate the creation of a safe, defined space (similar to that of oral history) for autoethnography to occur.
Related Results
Targeted advertising: documenting the emergence of Gun Culture 2.0 in Guns magazine, 1955–2019
Targeted advertising: documenting the emergence of Gun Culture 2.0 in Guns magazine, 1955–2019
AbstractThis study replicates Yamane, Ivory, and Yamane’s (Gun studies: interdisciplinary approaches to politics, policy, and practice, Routledge, New York, pp. 9–27, 2019) earlier...
School Shootings, Protests, and the Gun Culture in the United States
School Shootings, Protests, and the Gun Culture in the United States
AbstractScholars document that attitudes toward guns and gun policy reflect deeply entrenched cultures that overlap with ideological affiliations and party politics. Does exposure ...
Speaking of trauma: the race talk, the gun violence talk, and the racialization of gun trauma
Speaking of trauma: the race talk, the gun violence talk, and the racialization of gun trauma
AbstractThis paper considers the intersection of race and gun violence through the lens of trauma. We focus on two high-profile cases of gun violence: the state-deemed justifiable ...
The importance of virtue ethics in the IRB
The importance of virtue ethics in the IRB
Institutional review boards have a dual goal: first, to protect the rights and welfare of human research subjects, and second, to support and facilitate the conduct of valuable res...
Calvin’s Problem: Racial Identity and Gun Ownership
Calvin’s Problem: Racial Identity and Gun Ownership
Calvin Mitchell is a gun-loving conservative black man who hates when people “play the race card.” And yet as he tries to participate in the gun world, he is constantly confronted ...
From Gun Politics to Self-Defense Politics
From Gun Politics to Self-Defense Politics
This article calls attention to a problematic binary produced by public debates surrounding gun rights and gun control—namely, that women must choose armed self-protection or no se...
Transmettre la terre. Origines et inflexions récentes d'une problématique de la différence
Transmettre la terre. Origines et inflexions récentes d'une problématique de la différence
Handing down the land : Origins and recent shifts in the problem of the Other, Bernard Derouet
The problem of the Other is at the heart of the study of family reproduction. B...
Loaded objects: addressing gun violence through art in the gallery and beyond
Loaded objects: addressing gun violence through art in the gallery and beyond
AbstractGun violence impacts our experience of public spaces, including how we represent and memorialize tragic events stemming from guns in public ways. Immediate memorials, compl...