Imputation

Abstract This chapter underscores the importance of being able to the norms of practical philosophy in concrete circumstances, particularly as relevant to Kant’s moral theory as expounded in the Groundwork and second Critique. Notably absent in these works is a comprehensive theory or even reflection on the application of moral laws, posing a challenge for interpreters. While Kant briefly introduces the concept of imputation in the Metaphysics of Morals, this move resembles Baumgarten’s earlier work, emphasizing duty and certitude rather than empirical reasoning. Kant’s apparent neglect of physical imputation suggests a reluctance to confront the complexities of moral judgments in everyday situations, while Baumgarten embraces the practicality of moral philosophy, acknowledging the subjective nature of human judgments. Baumgarten’s approach allows for the establishment of a provisional yet functional moral philosophy, emphasizing the importance of practical application. The chapter suggests the possibility of reconciling Kant’s theoretical purity with Baumgarten’s practical approach, leaving room for further discussion.