Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Jekyll and Hyde revisited: Young people's constructions of feminism, feminists and the practice of “reasonable feminism”

View through CrossRef
It is a decade and a half since Nigel Edley and Margaret Wetherell's (2001) “Jekyll and Hyde: Men's constructions of feminism and feminists” called scholarly attention to men's discursive splitting of feminism and feminists into good and monstrous variants. In this article, we ask whether this double vision persists and how it operates in a cultural moment when feminism and feminist issues are (re)entering the mainstream. We draw from data collected in the course of a New Zealand study exploring how young people were making sense of sexism, feminism and gender (in)equality. Our analysis of participants' accounts suggests a binary discursive formulation of feminism is alive and well: “unreasonable feminism” damns and dismisses feminism, while “fair feminism” affirms it, aligning it with equality. Where previous research has shown how such pejorative and affirming accounts are worked together in ways that dilute or depoliticise feminism, we explore how teenagers who explicitly adopted a feminist identity drew on these discourses to justify a more politicised feminist position. Many participants adopted a practice of “reasonable feminism”, embodying and evidencing feminist reasonableness through their rhetorical and performative devices.
Title: Jekyll and Hyde revisited: Young people's constructions of feminism, feminists and the practice of “reasonable feminism”
Description:
It is a decade and a half since Nigel Edley and Margaret Wetherell's (2001) “Jekyll and Hyde: Men's constructions of feminism and feminists” called scholarly attention to men's discursive splitting of feminism and feminists into good and monstrous variants.
In this article, we ask whether this double vision persists and how it operates in a cultural moment when feminism and feminist issues are (re)entering the mainstream.
We draw from data collected in the course of a New Zealand study exploring how young people were making sense of sexism, feminism and gender (in)equality.
Our analysis of participants' accounts suggests a binary discursive formulation of feminism is alive and well: “unreasonable feminism” damns and dismisses feminism, while “fair feminism” affirms it, aligning it with equality.
Where previous research has shown how such pejorative and affirming accounts are worked together in ways that dilute or depoliticise feminism, we explore how teenagers who explicitly adopted a feminist identity drew on these discourses to justify a more politicised feminist position.
Many participants adopted a practice of “reasonable feminism”, embodying and evidencing feminist reasonableness through their rhetorical and performative devices.

Related Results

Jekyll and Hyde: Men's Constructions of Feminism and Feminists
Jekyll and Hyde: Men's Constructions of Feminism and Feminists
Research and commentary on men's responses to feminism have demonstrated the range of ways in which men have mobilized both for and against feminist principles. This article argues...
Young feminists, feminism and digital media
Young feminists, feminism and digital media
Over recent years, young feminist activism has assumed prominence in mainstream media where news headlines herald the efforts of schoolgirls in fighting sexism, sexual violence and...
Douglas Hyde's “share" In The Unicorn From The Stars
Douglas Hyde's “share" In The Unicorn From The Stars
ON FEBRUARY 12, 1908, W. B. Yeats wrote to A. H. Bullen refusing to allow the latter to include Where There Is Nothing in the Collected Edition of Yeats's works for the following r...
Experience, Identities and Alliances: Jewish Feminism and Feminist Psychology
Experience, Identities and Alliances: Jewish Feminism and Feminist Psychology
This article develops a theoretical perspective on identities as relational and produced through histories of oppression and resistance. The arguments are applied to their expressi...
Sexual Abuse and Troubled Feminism: A Reply to Camille Guy
Sexual Abuse and Troubled Feminism: A Reply to Camille Guy
In a recent issue of Feminist Review Camille Guy argued, focusing on selected controversies in New Zealand and Australia, that radical feminists have had a prescriptive hegemony in...
Feminism versus femininity? Exploring feminist dilemmas through cooperative inquiry research
Feminism versus femininity? Exploring feminist dilemmas through cooperative inquiry research
This article analyses the findings from a cooperative inquiry study with seven feminist identified women based in the UK. It explores the tensions participants experienced in negot...
Feminism, capitalism and the cunning of history
Feminism, capitalism and the cunning of history
Building on historical narrative and social-theoretical analysis, Fraser explores the place of second-wave feminism in relation to three specific moments in the history of capitali...
From the traditional to the contemporary Cycladic sustainable house
From the traditional to the contemporary Cycladic sustainable house
PurposeThe paper aims to compare traditional and contemporary architecture in terms of their environmental performance. It will demonstrate that the traditional constructions creat...

Recent Results

MEMOIRE DES BALKANS, MEMOIRES DES FRANCE(S) : VERS LA RECONNAISSANCE DE MEMOIRES PLURIELLES ET NON EXCLUSIVES
MEMOIRE DES BALKANS, MEMOIRES DES FRANCE(S) : VERS LA RECONNAISSANCE DE MEMOIRES PLURIELLES ET NON EXCLUSIVES
MEMORY OF THE BALKANS, MEMORIES OF FRANCE(ES): TOWARDS RECOGNITION OF MULTIPLE AND NON EXCLUSIVES MEMORIES The contemporary approach to memorial memory in France is quite different...
Icon exhibition in Joensuu
Icon exhibition in Joensuu
content description: The Mirror of Brightness -icon exhibition at North Karelian Museum in Joensuu 18.5.1993. The exhibition is presented by docent Aune Jääskinen....
Title Page: The Causes of Decay of Christian Piety, with vignette of St. Paul's Burning, (Lex ignea)
Title Page: The Causes of Decay of Christian Piety, with vignette of St. Paul's Burning, (Lex ignea)
Etching; post third state of three with the image of St. Paul's in flames replacing the image of the burning ship., Title pages (?)...
Free Jazz
Free Jazz
Free Jazz emerged in the late 1950s out of the ongoing negotiation of the American jazz tradition. By the mid-twentieth century, this African-American musical tradition had develop...

Back to Top