Parental Decision Regret after Consenting to or Refusing Hypospadias Repair: an Australian Survey

Abstract Background: Parental decision regret in hypospadias surgery is a recognised source of long-lasting psycho-social morbidity. Its reported prevalence is high but until now, it has not been studied in Australasian context or among parents who declined the repair for their son. The aim of this study is to report on decision regret in an Australian cohort of parents, including parents who accepted or who declined repair for their son and explore underlying factors for decision-making, satisfaction, and regret. Methods: An online anonymous survey was administered to three groups: 1) parents who consented for hypospadias repair, 2) parents who declined repair and 3) a control group who requested circumcision for their child. Operations occurred between 2010 and 2020. The survey included a validated decision regret assessment tool and additional questions to explore the possible basis of the opinions. Results: One hundred and eighteen parents (eligible 381, response rate 31%) participated. Decision regret was present in group 1 (n=89) – 55% (moderate-to-severe 15%), in group 2 (n= 14) – 71% (moderate-to-severe 57%), and in the control group (n=15) – 15% (moderate-to-severe 8%) of parents. There was a significant difference in the median decision regret score between all three groups. Parents who chose hypospadias repair were mostly concerned about function. They named the direction of the urine from the tip of the penis as the most satisfying outcome, and the appearance of the foreskin and the need for several operations as the least satisfying outcomes of the repair. Conclusions: The prevalence of decision regret among Australian parents who consented for their son’s hypospadias repair was lower compared with the mean decision regret reported in the literature to date (55% vs 65%). Decision regret and its severity were highest among parents who declined hypospadias repair. New strategies are needed to reduce decision regret in parents whether or not they elect for surgery.