Javascript must be enabled to continue!
A systematic review and meta‐analysis of post‐fire seeding and herbicide treatment effectiveness for controlling exotic annual grasses in the sagebrush biome
View through CrossRef
Abstract
Introduction
Outcomes of ecological restoration treatments can be highly variable and challenging to generalize, even for the same treatment type applied in similar ecological communities at different times and places. Notable examples are the herbicide and seeding treatments that have been extensively applied across the perennial sagebrush steppe of the United States to reduce impacts of fire‐promoting exotic annual grasses (EAGs) such as Cheatgrass (
Bromus tectorum
).
Objectives
We asked if statistically based generalizations about the effects of pre‐emergent herbicide and drill seeding of perennials, implemented following wildfires when threats of annual‐grass invasion are greatest, could be made from the available literature.
Methods
We conducted a meta‐analysis of these treatment effects for 1228 treatment‐control comparisons from 35 studies published from 1990 to 2023 that met basic criteria for topical relevance and repeatability.
Results
EAGs and forbs were each reduced by herbicides and by seeding perennial grasses. The combination of herbicide and seeding reduced annuals and led to the largest increases in perennials. Although these outcomes support the intended effects of the treatments, there was high variability in outcomes among studies.
Conclusions
Combined use of pre‐emergent herbicides and seeding can increase the success of restoration interventions that are aimed at reducing the invasion of exotic annual grasses and increasing perennials after fire in sagebrush steppe. Our analysis revealed, however, that the available literature was not suited to answering more specific questions, in spite of the massive amount of post‐fire herbicide and seedings that have been applied in burned sagebrush steppe. Specifically, there were too few topically relevant studies with adequate scientific reporting to properly evaluate differences among specific treatment methodologies, including specific herbicides, that affect restoration success.
Title: A systematic review and meta‐analysis of post‐fire seeding and herbicide treatment effectiveness for controlling exotic annual grasses in the sagebrush biome
Description:
Abstract
Introduction
Outcomes of ecological restoration treatments can be highly variable and challenging to generalize, even for the same treatment type applied in similar ecological communities at different times and places.
Notable examples are the herbicide and seeding treatments that have been extensively applied across the perennial sagebrush steppe of the United States to reduce impacts of fire‐promoting exotic annual grasses (EAGs) such as Cheatgrass (
Bromus tectorum
).
Objectives
We asked if statistically based generalizations about the effects of pre‐emergent herbicide and drill seeding of perennials, implemented following wildfires when threats of annual‐grass invasion are greatest, could be made from the available literature.
Methods
We conducted a meta‐analysis of these treatment effects for 1228 treatment‐control comparisons from 35 studies published from 1990 to 2023 that met basic criteria for topical relevance and repeatability.
Results
EAGs and forbs were each reduced by herbicides and by seeding perennial grasses.
The combination of herbicide and seeding reduced annuals and led to the largest increases in perennials.
Although these outcomes support the intended effects of the treatments, there was high variability in outcomes among studies.
Conclusions
Combined use of pre‐emergent herbicides and seeding can increase the success of restoration interventions that are aimed at reducing the invasion of exotic annual grasses and increasing perennials after fire in sagebrush steppe.
Our analysis revealed, however, that the available literature was not suited to answering more specific questions, in spite of the massive amount of post‐fire herbicide and seedings that have been applied in burned sagebrush steppe.
Specifically, there were too few topically relevant studies with adequate scientific reporting to properly evaluate differences among specific treatment methodologies, including specific herbicides, that affect restoration success.
Related Results
Evaluating the Science to Inform the Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans Midcourse Report
Evaluating the Science to Inform the Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans Midcourse Report
Abstract
The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans (Guidelines) advises older adults to be as active as possible. Yet, despite the well documented benefits of physical activi...
Status and trend of upland vegetation and soils at Dinosaur National Monument, 2010–2020
Status and trend of upland vegetation and soils at Dinosaur National Monument, 2010–2020
In 2009, the Northern Colorado Plateau Network began long-term monitoring of pinyon-juniper woodlands, high-elevation sagebrush, and low-elevation sagebrush shrublands in Dinosaur ...
Identifying Sources of Landscape Variation to Improve Predictions of Post-Fire Sagebrush Steppe Recovery
Identifying Sources of Landscape Variation to Improve Predictions of Post-Fire Sagebrush Steppe Recovery
Sagebrush steppe ecosystems are endangered landscapes, threated by the annual grass-fire cycle where invasion by annual grasses drives larger fires and larger fires drive invasion....
[RETRACTED] Keanu Reeves CBD Gummies v1
[RETRACTED] Keanu Reeves CBD Gummies v1
[RETRACTED]Keanu Reeves CBD Gummies ==❱❱ Huge Discounts:[HURRY UP ] Absolute Keanu Reeves CBD Gummies (Available)Order Online Only!! ❰❰= https://www.facebook.com/Keanu-Reeves-CBD-G...
Detecting shrub recovery in sagebrush steppe: comparing Landsat-derived maps with field data on historical wildfires
Detecting shrub recovery in sagebrush steppe: comparing Landsat-derived maps with field data on historical wildfires
Abstract
Background
The need for basic information on spatial distribution and abundance of plant species for research and management in semiarid ec...
Predicting Flower Stalk Production of a Native Shrub Using UAV
Structure-from-Motion Photogrammetry
Predicting Flower Stalk Production of a Native Shrub Using UAV
Structure-from-Motion Photogrammetry
Climate change is threatening rangeland ecosystems, including increasing
frequency of extreme weather, wildfire, and drought. Identifying which native
...
Evolution of Herbicide Resistance in Lolium rigidum under Low Herbicide Rates: An Australian Experience
Evolution of Herbicide Resistance in Lolium rigidum under Low Herbicide Rates: An Australian Experience
ABSTRACTRecent studies have shown the potential of lower than recommended herbicide rates to enhance the herbicide resistance level of a troublesome weed, annual ryegrass (Lolium r...
Relationship of greater sage‐grouse to natural and assisted recovery of key vegetation types following wildfire: insights from scat
Relationship of greater sage‐grouse to natural and assisted recovery of key vegetation types following wildfire: insights from scat
Megafires are creating severe conservation problems worldwide for wildlife that have obligate dependencies on plant species that are foundational but fire‐intolerant. Wildfire‐indu...

