From replica symmetry to metastability in random constraint satisfaction problems

This thesis concerns three specific constraint satisfaction problems: the k-SAT problem, random linear equations and the Potts model. We investigated a phenomenon called replica symmetry, its consequences and its limitation. For the $k$-SAT problem, we were able to show that replica symmetry holds up to a threshold $d^{*}$. However, after another critical threshold $d^{**}$, we discovered that replica symmetry could not hold anymore, which enabled us to establish the existence of a replica symmetry breaking region. For the random linear problem, a peculiar phenomenon occurs. We observed that a more robust version of replica symmetry (strong replica symmetry) holds up to a threshold $d=e$ and ceases to hold after. This phenomenon is linked to the fact that before the threshold $d=e$, the fraction of frozen variables, i.e. variable forced to take the same value in all solutions, is concentrated around a deterministic value but vacillates between two values with equal probability for $d>e$. Lastly, for the Potts model, we show that a phenomenon called metastability occurs. The latter phenomenon can be understood as a consequence of trivial replica symmetry breaking scheme. This metastability phenomenon further produces slow mixing results for two famous Markov chains, the Glauber and the Swendsen-Wang dynamics.