Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Kantian apriorism in the debate between empiricists and nativists in cognitive science
View through CrossRef
In the second half of the 20th century, N. Chomsky gave a new impetus to the debate between empiricism and nativism by proposing the concept of a universal grammar. Today this discussion is unfolding within the framework of cognitive science and consists in determining the peculiarities of cognitive mechanisms necessary to create a cognitive agent. The disagreement between the proponents of empiricism and nativism is whether these mechanisms are domain-general or domain-specific. At the same time, modern scientific literature on this issue does not take into account, on the one hand, Kantian intuitions about a priori cognition and, on the other hand, the results of the discussion between philosophers and physiologists in the second half of the 19th century. The aim of this article is to actualize the potential of the Kantian concept of apriorism in modern discussions between empiricism and nativism, for this purpose the concept of Kantian apriorism is analyzed and its influence on different stages of the discussion between empiricists and nativists is considered. The study concludes that Kantian apriorism allows us to adjust the strategy of realization of a cognitive agent, which cannot leave out the idea of conditioning of experience by a priory cognitive mechanisms and their peculiarities as innate potencies, as well as the specificity of their development in direct interaction with experience.
Title: Kantian apriorism in the debate between empiricists and nativists in cognitive science
Description:
In the second half of the 20th century, N.
Chomsky gave a new impetus to the debate between empiricism and nativism by proposing the concept of a universal grammar.
Today this discussion is unfolding within the framework of cognitive science and consists in determining the peculiarities of cognitive mechanisms necessary to create a cognitive agent.
The disagreement between the proponents of empiricism and nativism is whether these mechanisms are domain-general or domain-specific.
At the same time, modern scientific literature on this issue does not take into account, on the one hand, Kantian intuitions about a priori cognition and, on the other hand, the results of the discussion between philosophers and physiologists in the second half of the 19th century.
The aim of this article is to actualize the potential of the Kantian concept of apriorism in modern discussions between empiricism and nativism, for this purpose the concept of Kantian apriorism is analyzed and its influence on different stages of the discussion between empiricists and nativists is considered.
The study concludes that Kantian apriorism allows us to adjust the strategy of realization of a cognitive agent, which cannot leave out the idea of conditioning of experience by a priory cognitive mechanisms and their peculiarities as innate potencies, as well as the specificity of their development in direct interaction with experience.
Related Results
The Vacuity of Ludwig von Mises’ Apriorism
The Vacuity of Ludwig von Mises’ Apriorism
Ludwig von Mises’ methodological apriorism is often attributed to the broader Austrian School of economics. However, there is considerable controversy concerning the meaning of Mis...
Russian neo-Kantian philosophy of music in the early 20th century in the context of symbolic forms
Russian neo-Kantian philosophy of music in the early 20th century in the context of symbolic forms
In the expanding space of philosophical knowledge, in particular, aesthetics, epistemology, philosophical anthropology, and philosophy of culture, the philosophy of music, which is...
UNDER AN UNSTARRY SKY: KANTIAN ETHICS AND RADICAL EVIL
UNDER AN UNSTARRY SKY: KANTIAN ETHICS AND RADICAL EVIL
Kantian ethics and concept concerning “radical evil” represent one of the most interesting facets of moral reflection of German philosopher. Using anthropological and philosophical...
The Social Sciences and the A Priori
The Social Sciences and the A Priori
The paper makes a novel case to vindicate social sciences as substantially a priori, against the mainstream view that rejects apriorism as unscientific. After a brief review of the...
Midlife Marital Status and Subsequent Cognitive Decline over 20 Years: Discovery from ARIC
Midlife Marital Status and Subsequent Cognitive Decline over 20 Years: Discovery from ARIC
Background — Recent studies show that marriage is associated with a protective effect against cognitive decline among older adults. However, definite evidence from large prospectiv...
Conscious cognitive effort in cognitive control
Conscious cognitive effort in cognitive control
AbstractCognitive effort is thought to be familiar in everyday life, ubiquitous across multiple variations of task and circumstance, and integral to cost/benefit computations that ...
Cognitive Science Approaches in Biblical Studies
Cognitive Science Approaches in Biblical Studies
Since the mid-2000s, cognitive science approaches have been used in biblical studies. Cognitive science came into existence in the 1950s as a reaction to the psychological behavior...
C-PLACID - Computational PLatform for Assessment of Cognition In Dementia - EPSRC
C-PLACID - Computational PLatform for Assessment of Cognition In Dementia - EPSRC
Cognitive impairment is the hallmark of dementia. Cognitive problems, such as difficulties with memory, language and reasoning, are the most obvious, frustrating and debilitating a...

