Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Augustine’s Master Argument for the Incorporeality of the Mind
View through CrossRef
Abstract
In De Trinitate 10, Augustine offers an argument that seemingly proceeds from certain premises about self-knowledge to the conclusion that the mind is incorporeal. Although the argument has sometimes been compared to later Cartesian arguments, it has received relatively little philosophical attention. In this paper, I offer a detailed analysis and original interpretation of Augustine's argument and argue that it is not vulnerable to some of the main objections which have been raised against it. I go on to argue that while an important part of Augustine's argument does face several hitherto neglected objections, Augustine's ultimate case for the incorporeality of the mind is somewhat different and more successful than one might initially think.
Title: Augustine’s Master Argument for the Incorporeality of the Mind
Description:
Abstract
In De Trinitate 10, Augustine offers an argument that seemingly proceeds from certain premises about self-knowledge to the conclusion that the mind is incorporeal.
Although the argument has sometimes been compared to later Cartesian arguments, it has received relatively little philosophical attention.
In this paper, I offer a detailed analysis and original interpretation of Augustine's argument and argue that it is not vulnerable to some of the main objections which have been raised against it.
I go on to argue that while an important part of Augustine's argument does face several hitherto neglected objections, Augustine's ultimate case for the incorporeality of the mind is somewhat different and more successful than one might initially think.
Related Results
Every Word is a Name: Autonymy and Quotation in Augustine
Every Word is a Name: Autonymy and Quotation in Augustine
AbstractAugustine famously claims every word is a name. Some readers take Augustine to thereby maintain a purely referentialist semantic account according to which every word is a ...
The Roots of Occasionalism? Causation, Metaphysical Dependence, and Soul-Body Relations in Augustine
The Roots of Occasionalism? Causation, Metaphysical Dependence, and Soul-Body Relations in Augustine
Abstract
It has long been thought that Augustine holds that corporeal objects cannot act upon incorporeal souls. However, precisely how and why Augustine imposes limitations up...
Pseudo-Mysterianism of Colin McGinn
Pseudo-Mysterianism of Colin McGinn
Colin McGinn claims that there is a naturalistic solution of the mind-body problem, but it is not constructive. That is, according to him, there is a natural and simple explanation...
AUGUSTINE ON THE DANGERS OF FRIENDSHIP
AUGUSTINE ON THE DANGERS OF FRIENDSHIP
The philosophers of antiquity had much to say about the place of friendship in the good life and its role in helping us live virtuously. Augustine is unusual in giving substantial ...
Astrology, Astral Influences, and Occult Properties in the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Centuries
Astrology, Astral Influences, and Occult Properties in the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Centuries
The notion of natural “occult” is usually viewed by modern scholars as a tautological way of dealing with phenomena for which there was no current explanation. Consider how Molière...
The Creation of Eve
The Creation of Eve
Why was Eve created? In De Genesi ad litteram, Augustine notoriously gives the answer that it was only causa pariendi, “for the sake of childbearing.” Other late antique interprete...
Augustine on Active Perception, Awareness, and Representation
Augustine on Active Perception, Awareness, and Representation
Abstract
It is widely thought that Augustine thinks perception is, in some distinctive sense, an active process and that he takes conscious awareness to be constitutive of percepti...
The future‐like‐ours argument, animalism, and mereological universalism
The future‐like‐ours argument, animalism, and mereological universalism
AbstractWhich metaphysical theories are involved—whether presupposed or implied—in Marquis’ future‐like‐ours (FLO) argument against abortion? Vogelstein has recently argued that th...