Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Grounding and Reflexivity
View through CrossRef
Grounding is commonly assumed to induce a strict partial ordering: it is said to be asymmetric, transitive and irreflexive. Why it is that we ought to believe that grounding is irreflexive, in particular, appears to turn in large part on the impossibility of any instance of it being reflexive. But why is this? Indeed, how would things need to be such that anything could ground itself? And why is this so bad? This paper explores metaphysical and explanatory reasons for supposing that nothing can ground itself. The discussion centers on the thoughts that there are problems with bootstrapping, the priority ordering and necessary beings, and finds them wanting. A conclusion is reached that the best reasons we have for supposing that grounding is irreflexive are going to be epistemic rather than metaphysical.
Title: Grounding and Reflexivity
Description:
Grounding is commonly assumed to induce a strict partial ordering: it is said to be asymmetric, transitive and irreflexive.
Why it is that we ought to believe that grounding is irreflexive, in particular, appears to turn in large part on the impossibility of any instance of it being reflexive.
But why is this? Indeed, how would things need to be such that anything could ground itself? And why is this so bad? This paper explores metaphysical and explanatory reasons for supposing that nothing can ground itself.
The discussion centers on the thoughts that there are problems with bootstrapping, the priority ordering and necessary beings, and finds them wanting.
A conclusion is reached that the best reasons we have for supposing that grounding is irreflexive are going to be epistemic rather than metaphysical.
Related Results
From Nature to Grounding
From Nature to Grounding
Grounding is a powerful metaphysical concept; yet there is widespread scepticism about the intelligibility of the notion. This paper proposes an account of an entity’s nature or es...
Biology as Destiny or as Freedom? On Reflexivity, Collectivity, and the Realization of Human PotentialStephen Reicher
Biology as Destiny or as Freedom? On Reflexivity, Collectivity, and the Realization of Human PotentialStephen Reicher
This chapter adopts a broad perspective on the issue of social identity and the human essence. It first considers the unique capacity of reflexivity not only as a likely element of...
Learning to Pray
Learning to Pray
This chapter opens by reflecting on the prayer with which Augustine opens his incomplete Soliloquia. In this work, Augustine introduces the reflexivity of prayer: prayer is a desir...
Total Leaders 2.0
Total Leaders 2.0
Total Leaders 2.0 is the twenty-first-century's quick guide to leadership and successful change. It places the best thinking of several dozen, cutting-edge leadership and change gu...
Truthmaking and Grounding
Truthmaking and Grounding
In previous chapters, I’ve argued that all truths have a truthmaker, and I’ve developed an ontological account of what those truthmakers are. They’re states of affairs, and they in...
Hipster Culture
Hipster Culture
Twenty-first century popular culture has given birth to a peculiar cultural figure: the hipster. Stereotypically associated with nerd glasses, beards and buns, boho clothing, and i...

