Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Nudge and bias in subjective ratings? The role of icon sets in determining ratings of icon characteristics
View through CrossRef
AbstractSubjective ratings have been central to the evaluation of icon characteristics. The current study examined biases in ratings in relation to the context in which icons are presented. Context was manipulated between participants, with some groups rating icon sets with limited variability, and others rating icon sets with wide variability. It was predicted that the context created by the icon set would influence participants’ ratings; when the range of icons was limited, this would create bias given participants’ expectation that a full range of icon values was being presented. Six key icon characteristics were rated, which were visual (visual complexity, appeal), affective (valence, feelings), and semantic (concreteness, semantic distance). Some icon characteristics were susceptible to rating bias while others were not. Where subjective judgements were being made of visual icon characteristics (appeal/complexity) and highly concrete icons which were very pictorial, there was clear evidence of substantial bias in ratings. The same susceptibility to bias was not evident when ratings relied solely on learned semantic associations or were associated with the emotional attributions made to icons. The dynamic nature of the ratings bias was demonstrated when the rating context was changed without participants’ knowledge. When participants rated further blocks of icons providing a different range of the to-be-rated characteristic, this resulted in rapid and dramatic changes in rating behaviour. These findings demonstrate the need for representative sampling of icon characteristics to avoid ratings bias. Practically, this is important when determining the usability of newly designed icon sets in order to avoid over-valuing or under-valuing of key characteristics.
Springer Science and Business Media LLC
Title: Nudge and bias in subjective ratings? The role of icon sets in determining ratings of icon characteristics
Description:
AbstractSubjective ratings have been central to the evaluation of icon characteristics.
The current study examined biases in ratings in relation to the context in which icons are presented.
Context was manipulated between participants, with some groups rating icon sets with limited variability, and others rating icon sets with wide variability.
It was predicted that the context created by the icon set would influence participants’ ratings; when the range of icons was limited, this would create bias given participants’ expectation that a full range of icon values was being presented.
Six key icon characteristics were rated, which were visual (visual complexity, appeal), affective (valence, feelings), and semantic (concreteness, semantic distance).
Some icon characteristics were susceptible to rating bias while others were not.
Where subjective judgements were being made of visual icon characteristics (appeal/complexity) and highly concrete icons which were very pictorial, there was clear evidence of substantial bias in ratings.
The same susceptibility to bias was not evident when ratings relied solely on learned semantic associations or were associated with the emotional attributions made to icons.
The dynamic nature of the ratings bias was demonstrated when the rating context was changed without participants’ knowledge.
When participants rated further blocks of icons providing a different range of the to-be-rated characteristic, this resulted in rapid and dramatic changes in rating behaviour.
These findings demonstrate the need for representative sampling of icon characteristics to avoid ratings bias.
Practically, this is important when determining the usability of newly designed icon sets in order to avoid over-valuing or under-valuing of key characteristics.
Related Results
Cometary Physics Laboratory: spectrophotometric experiments
Cometary Physics Laboratory: spectrophotometric experiments
<p><strong><span dir="ltr" role="presentation">1. Introduction</span></strong&...
Experiences and Perceptions of Default Nudges
Experiences and Perceptions of Default Nudges
In this thesis I argue that how people perceive and experience nudge interventions is an underappreciated factor that can help assess, and potentially address, both effectiveness a...
Discussion on the Feasibility of Nudge in Education
Discussion on the Feasibility of Nudge in Education
This paper first introduces the definition of nudge, the history of nudge and the advantages of nudge. This concept means a relatively subtle policy shift that encourages people to...
Default Nudge Efficacy in Lower Versus Higher SEP-Groups: Two Online Supermarket Experiments
Default Nudge Efficacy in Lower Versus Higher SEP-Groups: Two Online Supermarket Experiments
Objective: Nudging is commonly assumed to be particularly effective among subpopulations with lower socio-economic position (SEP) hence to combat health disparities, but empirical ...
Assessing Icon Appropriateness and Icon Discriminability with a Paired-Comparison Testing Procedure
Assessing Icon Appropriateness and Icon Discriminability with a Paired-Comparison Testing Procedure
Traditional methods of evaluating icon comprehension and discriminability have relied on a sequence of multiple screening tests to measure various aspects of icon meaning, image co...
Exploring the Prebiotic Chemistry of Europa
Exploring the Prebiotic Chemistry of Europa
<div class="page" role="region" data-page-number="1" aria-label="Page 1" data-loaded="true&a...
Behavioral Bias Investors in Indonesia
Behavioral Bias Investors in Indonesia
The purpose of this study is to examine the impact of behavioral biases (risk-aversion bias; overconfidence bias; disposition bias; and herding bias) on gender-based Invesment deci...
Vrijeme i snaga jednostavne psihomotorne reakcije kao pokazatelji placebo učinka pri doživljaju boli
Vrijeme i snaga jednostavne psihomotorne reakcije kao pokazatelji placebo učinka pri doživljaju boli
Introduction: The analgesic placebo effect refers to the phenomenon that a certain treatment that should not lead to a reduction of pain (e.g. consumption of a pill that does not c...

