Javascript must be enabled to continue!

What is Moral about Moral Outrage?

View through CrossRef

In this paper we critically review the extant literature on outrage to show that some of the assumptions of the working definitions on outrage are not widely shared, hindering thus cumulative progress of research on this topic. We identify the issue of the disinterestedness of the experiencer of the emotion as a key barrier to understand the moral character of outrage and other emotions. By examining the challenges that this requirement brings, we show that a different characterization of moral emotion is needed. We propose an alternative analysis of outrage, based on a socio-constructionist perspective on emotions. The social norms that underpin the expression, negotiation and prognosis of moral anger allow a richer characterization of the moral character of emotions in general. The constitutive role of social norms is highlighted to show how these ideas can help advance the empirical research on outrage.

Elsevier BV

William Jiménez-Leal Carlos Cortissoz-Mora

Title: What is Moral about Moral Outrage?

Description:

In this paper we critically review the extant literature on outrage to show that some of the assumptions of the working definitions on outrage are not widely shared, hindering thus cumulative progress of research on this topic.

We identify the issue of the disinterestedness of the experiencer of the emotion as a key barrier to understand the moral character of outrage and other emotions.

By examining the challenges that this requirement brings, we show that a different characterization of moral emotion is needed.

We propose an alternative analysis of outrage, based on a socio-constructionist perspective on emotions.

The social norms that underpin the expression, negotiation and prognosis of moral anger allow a richer characterization of the moral character of emotions in general.

The constitutive role of social norms is highlighted to show how these ideas can help advance the empirical research on outrage.

Related Results

Can outrage be truly moral?

We critically examine the concept of moral outrage within the context of contemporary psychological and moral theory. The prevailing assumption that moral outrage should be a form ...

How effective is online outrage?

In today’s polarized political climate, it is important to consider whether moral emotions like outrage can be harnessed for good. Spring et al. thoughtfully examine the “upsides” ...

Moral Panics on Social Media are Fueled by Signals of Virality

Moral panics have regularly erupted in society, but they appear to occur almost daily on social media. We propose that social media helps to fuel moral panics by combining societal...

Escaping the Shadow

Photo by Karl Raymund Catabas on Unsplash The interests of patients at most levels of policymaking are represented by a disconnected patchwork of groups … “After Buddha was dead, ...

A Critique of Principlism

Photo by Towfiqu barbhuiya on Unsplash INTRODUCTION Bioethics does not have an explicitly stated and agreed upon means of resolving conflicts between normative theories. As such, b...

From Corporate Hypocrisy to Consumer Protest: The Role of Moral Outrage and Mobilization Networks

How do consumers respond when they perceive that a company is not what it claims to be? It is evident that customers are becoming increasingly aware of the ethical aspects of produ...

Moral Epistemology

Moral epistemology is the study of moral knowledge and related phenomena. The recorded history of work in the field extends (at least) 2,500 years to Socrates’s inquiries into whet...

Courage in the Civil Society — Historical, Cultural, and Conceptual Differences of Moral Courage and Zivilcourage

<p><strong>Zivilcourage, as it is known in Germany, is the courage of citizens to stand up to defend democratic norms. Recent attacks on democratic institutions all ove...