Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Review of "Algorithms of oppression: how search engines reinforce racism," by Noble, S. U. (2018). New York, New York: NYU Press.
View through CrossRef
Read and considered thoughtfully, Safiya Umoja Noble's
Algorithms of Oppression: How Search Engines Reinforce Racism
is devastating. It reduces to rubble the notion that technology is neutral and ideology-free. Noble's crushing the neutrality myth does several things. First, this act lays foundations for her argument: only if you recognize and understand that technology is built with, and integrates, bias, can you then be open to her primary thesis: search engines advance discriminatory and often racist content. Second, it banishes a convenient response for many self-identified meritocratic Silicon Valley "winners" and their supporters. Post-reading, some individuals may retain their beliefs in a neutral and ideology-free technology in spite of the overwhelming evidence and citations Noble brings to bear. Effective countering of Noble's claims is unlikely to occur. For professionals working in technology, information, argumentation, and/or rhetorical studies,
Algorithms of Oppression
is refreshing. Agonistic towards structural racism and its defenses, single-minded in its evidentiary presentation, collaborative in its acknowledgement of others' scholarship and research, Noble models many academic, critical, and social moves. Technology scholars and writers will find in
Algorithms of Oppression
a masterful mentor text on how to be an activist researcher scholar. Noble also makes this enjoyable reading. It is uncommon to find academic books that can simultaneously be read, used, and applied by academics and non-academics alike.
Title: Review of "Algorithms of oppression: how search engines reinforce racism," by Noble, S. U. (2018). New York, New York: NYU Press.
Description:
Read and considered thoughtfully, Safiya Umoja Noble's
Algorithms of Oppression: How Search Engines Reinforce Racism
is devastating.
It reduces to rubble the notion that technology is neutral and ideology-free.
Noble's crushing the neutrality myth does several things.
First, this act lays foundations for her argument: only if you recognize and understand that technology is built with, and integrates, bias, can you then be open to her primary thesis: search engines advance discriminatory and often racist content.
Second, it banishes a convenient response for many self-identified meritocratic Silicon Valley "winners" and their supporters.
Post-reading, some individuals may retain their beliefs in a neutral and ideology-free technology in spite of the overwhelming evidence and citations Noble brings to bear.
Effective countering of Noble's claims is unlikely to occur.
For professionals working in technology, information, argumentation, and/or rhetorical studies,
Algorithms of Oppression
is refreshing.
Agonistic towards structural racism and its defenses, single-minded in its evidentiary presentation, collaborative in its acknowledgement of others' scholarship and research, Noble models many academic, critical, and social moves.
Technology scholars and writers will find in
Algorithms of Oppression
a masterful mentor text on how to be an activist researcher scholar.
Noble also makes this enjoyable reading.
It is uncommon to find academic books that can simultaneously be read, used, and applied by academics and non-academics alike.
Related Results
Which innovations can improve timeliness of investigations and address the backlog in endoscopy for patients with potential symptoms of upper and lower Gastrointestinal (GI) cancers?
Which innovations can improve timeliness of investigations and address the backlog in endoscopy for patients with potential symptoms of upper and lower Gastrointestinal (GI) cancers?
TOPLINE SUMMARYWhat is a Rapid Review?Our rapid reviews use a variation of the systematic review approach, abbreviating or omitting some components to generate the evidence to info...
Whose agenda is it? Regulating health research ethics in Labrador
Whose agenda is it? Regulating health research ethics in Labrador
In Labrador, the NunatuKavut (formerly Labrador Inuit Métis) have begun to introduce a rigorous community-based research review process. We conducted a study with leaders and healt...
Electric Circus, Electric Ear and the Intermedia Center in Late-1960s New York
Electric Circus, Electric Ear and the Intermedia Center in Late-1960s New York
Composer Morton Subotnick moved to New York in 1966 for a brief but productive stay, establishing a small but notable electronic music studio affiliated with New York University. I...
Grotowski in New York City, 1993: Expectations, Hopes, and Stereotypes
Grotowski in New York City, 1993: Expectations, Hopes, and Stereotypes
The legacy of Jerzy Grotowski twenty years after his death still presents a powerful challenge for theatre-makers, not only in experimental theatre, and theoreticians – which is al...
Impact of Smoking and Vaping in Films on Smoking and Vaping Uptake in Adolescents: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Impact of Smoking and Vaping in Films on Smoking and Vaping Uptake in Adolescents: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Prevention of smoking uptake in young people is an essential public health target. We have previously reported a systematic review and meta-analysis of the effect of exposure to sm...
“It Cancels the Slave Ship!”: Africa, Slavery, and the Haitian Revolution in Langston Hughes’sEmperor of Haitiand Aimé Césaire’sThe Tragedy of King Christophe
“It Cancels the Slave Ship!”: Africa, Slavery, and the Haitian Revolution in Langston Hughes’sEmperor of Haitiand Aimé Césaire’sThe Tragedy of King Christophe
Langston Hughes and Aimé Césaire knew each other only slightly but shared a dedication to telling stories of a noble and uplifting black past. They also shared a fascination with t...
A taste for knottiness: skaldic art at Cnut’s court
A taste for knottiness: skaldic art at Cnut’s court
AbstractDuring Cnut’s two decades on the throne, his English court was the most vibrant centre in the North for the production and performance of skaldic praise poetry. Icelandic p...
Russian Constitutionalism and Elections in Noble Assemblies under Alexander I
Russian Constitutionalism and Elections in Noble Assemblies under Alexander I
In historiography, the Russian constitutionalism of the first quarter of the nineteenth century has traditionally been considered a result of the ideological influence of the Europ...
Recent Results
On the Lapidary Style
On the Lapidary Style
“The lapidary style” suggests a manner of writing that runs close to working a material—carving lettering into rock, cutting a gem into fine facets. Poised between the properties o...
Korea-KOSCO Oil Agreement, September 1949
Korea-KOSCO Oil Agreement, September 1949
In September 1949, the Korean government signed a toal of four oil agreements with foreign oil companies. This article specifically analyzes one of those agreement, the Agreement B...
Kinetics of Hole Burning in Inhomogeneously Broadened Spectra: the Origin of Nonexponentiality and Problem of Burning Efficiency Dispersion
Kinetics of Hole Burning in Inhomogeneously Broadened Spectra: the Origin of Nonexponentiality and Problem of Burning Efficiency Dispersion
High inhomogeneous broadening of impurity spectra in amorphous media reflects one type of dispersion, characteristic for disordered systems: dispersion of electronic transition fre...